What engineers do: rules of thumb, the method and the kinds of engineering knowledge: Key terms, quiz and sources
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 1: What engineers do: rules of thumb, the method and the kinds of engineering knowledge Wrap-upWhat engineers do: rules of thumb, the method and the kinds of engineering knowledge: review
Key terms
- Engineering method
- The engineer's way of reaching a working design: combining tested shortcuts with the materials, money and knowledge on hand, judged by results, without waiting for a full explanation.
- Rule of thumb
- A quick, imperfect guide that raises the odds of a good answer without guaranteeing one.
- Heuristic
- The technical name for a rule of thumb: any aid to solving a problem that is trusted for its results rather than proved.
- Satisficing
- Looking for a design that is good enough on every count that matters, instead of the single best.
- Safety factor
- A multiple by which a part is made stronger than the load it is expected to carry, to cover what is unknown.
- Working idea
- The trick by which a device does its job, which makes it the kind of device it is; philosophers call it the operational principle.
- Normal configuration
- The layout an industry has come to expect for a device, settled by years of trying alternatives.
- Design targets
- The quantities a design will be judged on, and the numbers or limits set for them.
- Calculation methods
- Formulas, models and procedures that predict how a design will behave.
- Measured values
- Numbers about real materials, parts and processes that must be found by test because no formula supplies them.
- Field lessons
- Knowledge from workshops and from use that no formula contains but that a design ignores at its peril.
- Design judgement
- The working habits and the sense of risk by which a designer carries a design through to the end.
- Normal design
- Design that improves a device whose working idea and usual shape are already known.
- Radical design
- Design for which the working idea or shape is unknown and success is not assured.
- Design hierarchy
- The layering of a device into systems, subsystems and parts, each with its own design problem.
- Learning from service
- Knowledge gained from finished machines in use, including from how they fail.
- Tacit knowledge
- Skill and judgement that people hold from experience and can seldom write down.
- Engineering field
- A speciality such as civil, mechanical, electrical or chemical engineering, defined by the physics and problems it handles.
Try it in the table
- Open the Products table and find 'Centrifugal water pump'. Redo the rooftop tank estimate for a tank of 2,000 litres filled in 15 minutes through 12 m, and compare the power with the pump sizes you see for sale.
- Look up 'Lighting and displays' and the 'LED lamp' product. Estimate the yearly energy saved by replacing ten 60 W filament lamps in a flat with 9 W LEDs at five hours a day, and say what working idea changed.
- Open 'Reinforced concrete' and 'Steel reinforcing bar'. Use the one twenty-eighth rule to size a slab for a 3.5 m room and estimate the weight per square metre.
- Pick 'Electric motors and drives' and 'Gear train'. Name which engineering fields are involved, and say whether the technology is a normal design or a radical part inside a normal device.
- Open 'Electric bus' in the Products table. Estimate range from a pack size and an energy use per kilometre of your own choosing, then compare with a maker's published figures.
- Browse the Periodic Table of Technologies for 'Haber-Bosch ammonia synthesis' and 'Drip irrigation'. For each, write down the working idea in one sentence and the field that dominates.
Final quiz
What most clearly separates the question an engineer asks from the one a scientist asks?
Engineering aims at a working object under constraints, and science at general explanation. They overlap but their goals differ.Thickness rules for load-bearing brick walls fell out of use once concrete frames carried the load. This shows that rules of thumb:
A rule belongs to the job that produced it. When the structure changed, the rule stopped being useful without ever being shown wrong.A rope for a 1,000 kg lift is designed for 49 kN with a factor of 5. Why not choose a factor of 50?
A margin is bought with material and money. Engineers, and the codes they write, set it by weighing the cost of failure against the cost of the margin; lift ropes get about 12.Which of these is a design target rather than a calculation method?
A target is a numerical goal. The first option is a formula, the second a measured value, the fourth a field lesson.A pump gives 163 W to the water, and pump and motor together are about 40% efficient. What electric power is needed?
Electric power = hydraulic power divided by efficiency: 163 / 0.4, about 408 W.Which statement about learning from machines in service is correct?
Running real machines reveals behaviour no calculation anticipated, so use in service is a source of knowledge.Replacing the engine of a car by a motor and battery, while keeping the rest of the car, is best described as:
The drive train working idea changed, but the overall device and much other knowledge stayed. Interfaces needed new work.Why do real products need several engineering fields?
A product is a system of parts whose key problems lie in structures, power, chemistry, software and production.Sources for this module
- Hammack, The Things We Make (Sourcebooks, 2023) · ch. 1, 'The Invisible Method' (the idea of the engineering method as rules of thumb used with incomplete information, restated here in the course's own words); ch. 4, 'Resources'; ch. 6, 'Science: The Gold Standard for Rules of Thumb'
- Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 1, 'Introduction: Engineering As Knowledge' (normal and radical design, design hierarchy); ch. 3, 'Establishment of Design Requirements'; ch. 7, 'The Anatomy of Engineering Design Knowledge' (the six categories of design knowledge and seven knowledge-generating activities on which Part 2's own grouping draws)
- Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · part 1, ch. 1, 'What Engineers Do'
- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 456:2000 Plain and Reinforced Concrete: Code of Practice, as applied in Central Institute for Educational Technology (CEC) course notes · cl. 24.1 span to overall depth ratios for slabs up to 3.5 m, https://cec.nic.in/webpath/curriculum/Module/Arch/Paper16/30/downloads/faq.pdf
- Lift and Escalator Library, paper on suspension rope safety factors under EN 81 · minimum factors of 12 (three or more ropes) and 16 (two ropes), https://liftescalatorlibrary.org/paper_indexing/papers/00000145.pdf
- CEEW, 'How the mandatory standard and labelling programme affects the Indian fan market' (2023) · service value in cubic metres per minute per watt, https://www.ceew.in/blogs/how-mandatory-standard-and-labelling-programme-affects-indian-fan-market
- Press Information Bureau, Government of India, 'UJALA: 10 years' backgrounder (January 2025) · 36.87 crore LED bulbs at Rs 70 each, launched 5 January 2015, https://static.pib.gov.in/WriteReadData/specificdocs/documents/2025/jan/doc202516481801.pdf
- HDFC Sky, 'Petrol, diesel prices today, November 11, 2026' (from Goodreturns) · petrol Rs 102 to Rs 112 a litre in Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru and Chennai, https://hdfcsky.com/news/petrol-diesel-prices-today-november-11-2026-check-latest-rates-in-delhi-mumbai-kolkata-chennai-bengaluru-hyderabad
- ICCT, 'Emissions reduction and benefits of the first 3,825 electric buses under PM e-Bus Sewa' (November 2024) · 1.3 kWh per km assumed for 12 m e-buses (upper limit from the CESL tender), https://theicct.org/emissions-reduction-and-benefits-of-the-first-3825-electric-buses-under-pm-ebus-sewa-nov24
- ITDP India, 'E-Bus Basics' (2023) · batteries above 300 kWh recommended for daily routes of 180 to 230 km, https://itdp.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/E-Bus-Basics.pdf
- Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. I (Caltech online edition) · ch. 1, 'Atoms in Motion', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_01.html; ch. 4, 'Conservation of Energy', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_04.html (further reading)