Heat, temperature and the laws of thermodynamics: Heat is energy in transit, and how experiment showed it
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 5: Heat, temperature and the laws of thermodynamics Part 2 of 6Heat is energy in transit, and how experiment showed it
Everyday speech says a stove 'has a lot of heat'. Physics uses the word more carefully, and the careful use was won by experiment. This part separates heat from temperature and internal energy, follows the evidence from Rumford's cannon to Joule, and states the first law, which links heat, work and the energy inside things.
2.1 Heat is energy that moves because of a temperature difference; once it arrives it is internal energy
Think of money. A bank balance is what you hold; a transfer is money moving between accounts. Heat is the transfer. Unaided, it flows only from hot to cold. A hot stone dropped into cool water gives up energy until the two temperatures match, and then the flow stops, though both still hold plenty of internal energy. Internal energy, the sum of all the motion and bonding energy of the particles, is the balance. Heat is energy that passes from one body to another because their temperatures differ, and it always runs from the hotter to the colder.
The unit is the joule, the same as for all energy. An older unit, the calorie, survives in diets and food labels. One calorie is 4.184 joules, the heat that warms 1 g of water by 1 K. The food 'Calorie' is a kilocalorie, 4,184 J, so a 2,000 kcal day is about 8.4 MJ, or 2.3 kWh.
Heat usually raises temperature, so adding it warms a body, but at a melting or boiling point it changes the state of matter instead, which is latent heat (see the Latent heat node).
Until the 1840s many scientists pictured heat as a weightless fluid called caloric that flowed from hot bodies to cold ones. The idea was not foolish. Lavoisier listed caloric among the elements in 1789, and it fitted every mixing experiment. What it could not explain was the endless heat of friction.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Heat'
- Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. I (Caltech) · further reading only: https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_39.html (the kinetic theory of gases), I_44 (the laws of thermodynamics), I_45 (illustrations of thermodynamics) and I_46 (ratchet and pawl)
2.2 Rumford's cannon and Joule's paddles showed that motion turns into heat at a fixed rate
Benjamin Thompson, born in Massachusetts and made Count Rumford in Bavaria, supervised the boring of brass cannon at the Munich arsenal. He noticed how hot the metal became. Caloric's defenders said the chips cut away hold less caloric than solid metal, so the surplus is squeezed out.
Rumford tested this. He used a blunt borer that cut hardly any metal, and still the heat came out in great quantity. He sealed a cylinder of metal in a box of water and turned the borer with horses. The water boiled in two and a half hours. He reported this in 1798. His argument was clean. The source of the heat seemed inexhaustible, as long as the horses kept walking, and anything that can be supplied without limit cannot be a material stored in the metal. It must be motion.
What Rumford lacked was an exchange rate between work and heat. James Joule measured it in the 1840s, as 'Momentum, energy and why they are conserved' tells. The same work gave the same heat whatever the method, so heat and work are two forms of one quantity, energy.
The table shows that Rumford's numbers are sensible: his water needed about 3 MJ, and one horse could have supplied more work than that.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Mass of water | 18.77 lb x 0.4536 kg per lb | 8.5 kg (calculated) |
| Temperature rise (the water started at 60 °F, 15.6 °C) | 100 - 15.6 | 84.4 K |
| Heat taken up by the water | 8.5 kg x 4,186 J/kg K x 84.4 K | about 3.0 MJ (calculated) |
| Time | 2.5 hours x 3,600 s | 9,000 s |
| Average heating power | 3.0e6 J / 9,000 s | about 330 W (calculated) |
| Work from one horse, which Rumford said was enough (assume 500 W) | 500 W x 9,000 s | 4.5 MJ (calculated), half as much again as the heat in the water; the rest warmed the metal and the box |
Weight of water, starting temperature and time are from Rumford's paper, which says one horse could turn the machine though two were used. The power of a horse is an assumption, so the result is a check on size only.
Source: Rumford (Benjamin Thompson), An Experimental Enquiry Concerning the Source of the Heat which is Excited by Friction, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society (1798), reproduced online, https://av8n.com/physics/refs/rumford-1798.html (water 18.77 lb avoirdupois, starting at 60 F; boiled at 2 hours 30 minutes; one horse could turn the machinery, two were used; heat that can be furnished without limit cannot be a material substance)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Heat'
- Rumford (Benjamin Thompson), An Experimental Enquiry Concerning the Source of the Heat which is Excited by Friction, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society (1798), reproduced online · web
2.3 The first law: heat added plus work done equals the change in internal energy
Rub your hands together and they warm. Bend a wire back and forth and the bend grows hot. A spray can feels cold after a long spray. In each case a body changes temperature with no flame, and the idea behind all of them is the first law of thermodynamics: the change in internal energy of a system equals the heat added to it plus the work done on it. Written in symbols, change in U = Q + W. The First law of thermodynamics node tells the Mayer, Joule and Helmholtz story.
Compression shows how work becomes heat. A molecule hitting a wall that is moving towards it bounces off faster, in the way a ball hit by an advancing bat does. A piston pushed in quickly raises the speed of the molecules, so the temperature rises. If the compression is too quick for heat to leak out, it is called adiabatic. The reverse also holds. When gas expands against a piston or the surrounding air, it does work, and its molecules slow, so it cools. That is why the nozzle of a spray can chills.
The same physics runs the weather. A bubble of dry air rising through the atmosphere expands as the pressure around it falls, and it cools by roughly 9.8 K for each kilometre it climbs. Cool enough and its water vapour condenses into cloud. The Atmospheric dynamics and weather prediction node follows this further.
A diesel engine uses no spark plug. Its cylinder squeezes air to about one seventeenth of its volume so quickly that the air becomes hotter than the fuel's ignition point.
| Case | Working (temperature in kelvin x volume ratio^0.4) | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Start | air at 27 °C | 300 K |
| Pump squeezes air to one quarter of its volume, no heat escaping | 300 x 4^0.4 = 300 x 1.74 | about 520 K (250 °C) (calculated) |
| Diesel engine, compression ratio 17 | 300 x 17^0.4 = 300 x 3.11 | about 930 K (660 °C) (calculated) |
| Real pump | heat leaks to the walls and the stroke is slow | only a few tens of degrees |
The exponent 0.4 is for air treated as an ideal gas compressed with no heat flow. Real engines lose some heat to the cylinder walls, so the true value is lower, but still above the ignition temperature of diesel fuel.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Heat'
- Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. I (Caltech) · further reading only: https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_39.html (the kinetic theory of gases), I_44 (the laws of thermodynamics), I_45 (illustrations of thermodynamics) and I_46 (ratchet and pawl)
See it in the table
H₂O WaterCheck your understanding
Which statement about heat is correct?
Heat is energy in transit. Bodies hold internal energy, not heat, and the transfer always runs from hot to cold.What was the central point of Rumford's experiment with boring cannon?
Anything supplied without limit cannot be a finite stock held inside the metal. Rumford concluded that heat is motion.Air squeezed quickly in a diesel cylinder gets hot enough to light the fuel. Which is the best explanation?
By the first law, work done on a gas raises its internal energy. Molecules that bounce off an advancing piston leave faster.