Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Heat, temperature and the laws of thermodynamics: Expansion: bridges, rails, ice and the strange case of water

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 5: Heat, temperature and the laws of thermodynamics Part 4 of 6

Expansion: bridges, rails, ice and the strange case of water

Nearly everything grows when warmed, and the growth is small but forceful. A railway line, a bridge, a football and a pond all depend on it. This part explains why heat makes things expand, uses numbers to see how much and with what force, then turns to water, which breaks the rule just above freezing and so keeps lakes alive in winter.

4.1 Warming makes particles vibrate wider and push neighbours apart, so most solids grow by a small, steady fraction

A surveyor's steel tape reads short on a hot afternoon, because the tape itself has grown. Indian Railways lays much of its track as long welded rail, kilometres of steel without joints, and patrols it closely every summer. Both are the same effect: nearly every solid grows a little when warmed, and if it cannot grow, it pushes.

Why does heat do this? Think of two neighbouring atoms in a solid as joined by a bond. The bond is lopsided. It is hard to push the atoms closer, because they repel steeply, but easy to pull them apart, because the attraction fades slowly. A warmer solid has atoms that vibrate more widely. The wider swing explores the easy, stretched side more than the squeezed side, so the average spacing grows. A bond that was a perfectly symmetric spring would give no expansion at all.

For a bar of length L warmed by a temperature change dT, the growth is dL = a x L x dT, where a is the coefficient of linear expansion. Typical values are small: about 11 to 12.5 millionths per kelvin for steel, 23 for aluminium and 9 for plate glass. Concrete is close to steel, at about 13 to 14. That is why reinforced concrete works: bars and concrete grow together and do not tear apart.

Mismatch causes most of the damage and much of the cleverness. Wires sealed through the glass of a lamp must be chosen to grow at the glass's rate, or the seal cracks and leaks. In an electric iron, two bonded metal strips that grow at different rates curl as they warm and open a switch at the set heat: a bimetal thermostat. Liquids grow several times more than solids for the same warming, which is why the liquid in a thermometer climbs its tube.

Data Worked estimate: how much does steel grow, and with what force?
ItemWorkingResult
Growth of a 100 m steel deck warmed from 10 °C to 50 °C12e-6 per K x 100 m x 40 K0.048 m, about 48 mm (calculated)
Growth of a free 13 m rail warmed by 25 K12e-6 per K x 13 m x 25 Kabout 3.9 mm (calculated)
Stress if the same rail is held rigidly (steel stiffness 200 GPa)200e9 Pa x 12e-6 per K x 25 Kabout 60 MPa (calculated)
Cross-section of a 60E1 (UIC 60) rail, 60.21 kg per metre76.70 cm²7,670 mm² = 7.67e-3 m²
Thrust60e6 Pa x 7.67e-3 m²about 460 kN, close to 47 tonnes of force (calculated)

Calculated here with a rounded expansion coefficient for steel. The thrust is for a rail held at both ends with no room to move, an upper bound.

Source: Engineering ToolBox, Linear thermal expansion coefficients of materials, https://engineeringtoolbox.com/linear-expansion-coefficients-d_95.html (steel 10.8 to 12.5; aluminium 23; plate glass 9.0; Pyrex 4.0; concrete 13 to 14; copper 16 to 16.7, all in millionths per kelvin); ArcelorMittal Rails, Types of rails (EN 13674-1 profiles), https://rails.arcelormittal.com/pl/?p=18820 (60E1, UIC 60: cross-section 76.70 cm2, mass 60.21 kg/m); Research Designs and Standards Organisation (Indian Railways), Hot weather patrolling, https://rdso.indianrailways.gov.in/uploads/files/Hot%20weather%20patrolling_Pamphlet.pdf (patrolling of long welded rail starts when rail temperature exceeds the de-stressed temperature by 25 C on dense PSC sleeper track, 20 C otherwise)

4.2 Water breaks the rule near 4 °C, because its open, hydrogen-bonded structure collapses on melting

In a cold climate a pond freezes from the top down. A bottle of water left in a freezer cracks. Ice floats in your glass with about nine tenths of it under the surface. All three facts come from one oddity: ordinary water expands when it freezes, and between about 4 °C and 0 °C it expands as it cools.

The cause is the hydrogen bond. A water molecule is bent, and each one can cling to four neighbours: two through its hydrogens and two through its oxygen. In ice all four bonds are made at fixed angles, which builds a hexagonal lattice that is mostly open space, and is why snowflakes have six arms. Melting breaks only some of these bonds, but enough for the lattice to sag; molecules drop into the holes, and the liquid ends up about nine per cent denser than ice.

Cold liquid water still holds short-lived patches of the open arrangement, most of all near 0 °C. Warming dissolves more of them, which packs the liquid tighter, while the usual jostling of warmer molecules spreads it out. Up to about 4 °C the packing is the larger effect, so water shrinks as it warms; beyond that, ordinary expansion takes over. The densest water is at 3.98 °C (277.13 K), and below that point water has what is called negative thermal expansion (Sci. Rep. 2018).

The consequences are large. As a lake's surface cools in autumn, water above 4 °C sinks and mixes. Once the surface drops below 4 °C it becomes lighter, stays on top, and finally freezes. The ice also insulates, so the water below stays near 4 °C and fish survive. Dal Lake in Srinagar freezes at the surface in its coldest winters while the water below stays liquid.

Data Density of water and ice (kg per cubic metre)
Substance and temperatureDensityWhat it means
Water at 0 °C999.84slightly lighter than at 4 °C
Water at 4 °C999.97the densest state
Water at 10 °C999.70lighter again, as for other liquids
Water at 20 °C998.21lighter still
Water at 30 °C995.65lighter still
Ice at 0 °Cabout 9171,000 kg of water becomes 1.09 m³ of ice, and about 92 per cent of a block floating in fresh water is below the surface (calculated)

Standard reference densities, rounded. The volume and floating figures are calculated: 1,000 / 917 = 1.09, and 917 / 1,000 = 0.917.

Source: Scientific Reports 8 (2018), Structure and hydrogen bonding at the limits of liquid water stability, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-18975-7 (density maximum at 277.13 K; negative thermal expansion below it allows ice to float)

4.3 Gases expand the most, and their pressure and volume tie temperature to the absolute scale

For each degree of warming, a solid grows by some tens of parts per million and a liquid by up to a few parts in ten thousand. A gas held at steady pressure grows by about a third of a per cent, 1/273 of its 0 °C volume, since its molecules are not held to each other at all. Hold the pressure fixed and the volume is proportional to the kelvin temperature; hold the volume fixed and the pressure is. An empty plastic bottle capped in a warm room and left in a fridge crumples slightly. Raise the temperature in a closed vessel, and the molecules hit the walls harder and more often, so the pressure goes up. The two rules combine, with Boyle's law for fixed temperature, into p x V = n x R x T. The Gas laws node gives the details and the history.

Everyday life is full of this. A tyre that reads 2.2 bar (gauge) at breakfast reads more after an hour of fast driving. A pressure cooker heats water above 100 °C because the lid keeps pressure in, and higher pressure raises the boiling point. A hot-air balloon rises because the air inside is spread thinner than the air outside.

Why does the rule use the kelvin scale, not Celsius? Because average molecular energy is proportional to T in kelvin. Double the kelvin temperature and the molecules have twice the energy. Going from 20 °C to 40 °C is not a doubling, since it is only 293 K to 313 K.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Heat'
  • Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. I (Caltech) · further reading only: https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_39.html (the kinetic theory of gases), I_44 (the laws of thermodynamics), I_45 (illustrations of thermodynamics) and I_46 (ratchet and pawl)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterAl AluminiumSt SteelH2 HydrogenO2 Oxygen

Check your understanding

Why do steel bars in concrete not tear the concrete apart on a hot day?

Their expansion coefficients are close, about 11 to 14 millionths per kelvin, so the two grow together and little stress builds up.

A pond is at 8 °C throughout and the air turns cold. Which happens first as the surface cools below 8 °C?

Above 4 °C cooler water is denser, so it sinks and mixes. Only after the whole pond reaches about 4 °C does further cooling make the top lighter, so it stays on top and freezes.

A rigid sealed can of gas is warmed from 300 K to 360 K. By what factor does the absolute pressure change?

At constant volume pressure is proportional to the kelvin temperature: 360 / 300 = 1.2.
← Part 3: Specific heat: why water, sand and steel warm at different ratesMark read · Part 5: How heat moves: conduction, convection and radiation →