The solid Earth: plate tectonics, rocks and minerals: From drifting continents to spreading seafloors
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 18: The solid Earth: plate tectonics, rocks and minerals Part 4 of 6From drifting continents to spreading seafloors
A map of the world invites a childish question: do the coasts of Africa and South America fit? In 1912 a German meteorologist took the question seriously, and geologists rejected his answer for some fifty years. Then the ocean floor was explored and the answer came from an unexpected direction, magnetism.
4.1 Wegener gathered evidence for drifting continents but could not say what moved them
Alfred Wegener, a meteorologist and polar explorer, set out his case in 1912 and expanded it in a book in 1915. All the land, he said, had once formed a single supercontinent, Pangaea, which later broke up. His strongest clue came from ice. Rocks about 300 million years old in southern Africa, South America, Australia, Antarctica and India carry boulder clay and scratched rock floors left by glaciers; in Odisha they are the Talchir boulder beds. Today these places are scattered from the tropics to the pole, and if the continents had stayed put the ice must have reached the tropics. Fit the continents back together and the scratches radiate from one shared centre, as from a single ice cap. Living things agree. Leaves of Glossopteris, a seed fern, lie in the coal of all five landmasses, and Mesosaurus, a small freshwater reptile, is found only in southern Africa and South America. Rock layers and old mountain belts also line up across the Atlantic, and the coasts of Africa and South America match, best at the edge of the continental shelf.
Geologists nonetheless said no. The strongest objection was a physical one. Wegener thought the continents ploughed through the ocean floor, driven by Earth's rotation and the tides. Physicists such as Harold Jeffreys showed that those forces are far too weak to move a continent, and that solid rock would resist the ploughing. Wegener died in Greenland in 1930, with a minority of scientists in his support.
| Line of evidence | What it showed | What was said against it |
|---|---|---|
| Permian ice sheet | One polar cap if the continents are rejoined | Climate change in place |
| Fossils (Mesosaurus, Glossopteris) | Same species on continents now separated by ocean | Land bridges; seeds carried across by sea or wind |
| Matching rock belts | Same strata and mountain trends across the Atlantic | Could be explained by ancient land bridges |
| Jigsaw fit of coasts | Africa and South America match at the shelf edge | Could be chance, or a result of sinking land |
| Mechanism: rotation and tides | Continents ploughing through ocean crust | Forces thousands of times too weak; rock too strong |
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 22, 'Plate Tectonics'
- Introduction to physical geology (BCcampus open textbook), Alfred Wegener: the father of plate tectonics · web
4.2 Mapping the ocean floor showed young rock, a ridge system and a place where crust ends
The answer lay under the sea. Echo sounders, which time a pulse of sound to the bottom and back, were used widely during and after the Second World War, and in the 1950s Marie Tharp and Bruce Heezen turned the soundings into maps of the Atlantic floor. They showed a chain of undersea mountains, the mid-ocean ridge, which winds about 65,000 km through all the oceans, with a rift valley along its crest. Deep, narrow trenches, such as the Mariana Trench, lie beside island arcs and some coasts. The rocks dredged up were basalt, and the mud on top was thin. Drilling since the late 1960s has found no ocean floor older than about 180 to 200 million years, and its average age is only about 64 million years (Seton and colleagues, 2020), while continental rocks go back more than 4 billion. The oceans are young.
Harry Hess, a geologist and naval officer, drafted a proposal in 1959 and 1960 and published it in 1962, calling it an essay in geopoetry. Hot mantle rises under the ridge and partly melts, and the melt fills the crack as new basalt. The new floor moves away on both sides, and at trenches old floor bends down and sinks back into the mantle: subduction. Earth is not growing, so floor must be destroyed about as fast as it is made. The continents are carried along with the floor beside them rather than ploughing through it, which removed Jeffreys's objection.
Three predictions followed. Rock should be youngest at the ridge and older with distance. Sediment should be thinner near the ridge. And the ocean floor should carry a record of its own making, if there was a recorder. There was one: the magnetic field.
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 22, 'Plate Tectonics'
- Material Insights science node 'Plate tectonics' · Hess wrote his seafloor spreading manuscript in 1959 to 1960 and published it in 1962 as History of Ocean Basins; Vine and Matthews 1963; Morley independently
- Seton, Muller, Zahirovic and colleagues, A global dataset of present-day oceanic crustal age and seafloor spreading parameters, Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems (2020) · web
- Standard geological background, checked against general references and not fetched in this session · Makrana marble of Rajasthan is metamorphosed limestone; India's Gondwana coals in the Damodar, Mahanadi and Godavari valleys are of Permian age; the submersible Alvin found the Galapagos Rift vents in 1977; Tharp and Heezen mapped the Atlantic floor in the 1950s; about 1,300 volcanoes have erupted in the Holocene, most of them around the Pacific
4.3 Magnetic stripes on either side of the ridge are a tape recording of the seafloor's birth
Hot basalt contains grains of magnetite. When the rock cools below about 580 degrees Celsius, the grains fix the direction of the Earth's field at that moment and keep it. Rock therefore holds a fossil compass. The field has also reversed, many times: north and south magnetic poles swap places at irregular intervals, on average a few times per million years, with the last full reversal about 780,000 years ago. Module 6 traced these reversals to the geodynamo of Part 1.
In the late 1950s, ships towing magnetometers over the Pacific found the ocean floor to be a pattern of long stripes, alternating between stronger and weaker than expected, running parallel to the ridges. In 1963 the young Cambridge researchers Fred Vine and Drummond Matthews, in a paper in Nature, joined the two facts. Magma rises at the ridge, cools, and records the field of the day. The plate then splits and moves outward, and fresh crust fills the gap and records the next. Whenever the field reverses, the polarity of the new strip reverses. The result is symmetrical stripes on the two sides, like a tape that is spooled in two directions at once. The Canadian Lawrence Morley arrived at the same idea independently. Faster ridges make wider stripes.
The test was that the stripe pattern should match the independently known reversal dates from lava flows on land. It did. By 1966 surveys across the Pacific-Antarctic Ridge showed a pattern that was almost mirror-symmetrical, and the sceptics gave way. Hess's idea had become a theory.
| Setting | Opening speed (cm a year) | Width gained in 100 million years | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arctic Ridge, slowest | Under 2.5 | Under 2,500 km (calculated) | A narrow, slow ocean |
| Mid-Atlantic Ridge, average | About 2.5 | About 2,500 km (calculated) | The Atlantic is far wider because it has been opening for well over 100 million years, faster in places |
| A medium-fast ridge | 6 | 6,000 km (calculated) | A wide ocean in under 100 million years |
| East Pacific Rise, fastest | More than 15 | More than 15,000 km (calculated) | Floor is made and carried away fast, so the eastern Pacific floor is young |
Width = opening speed x time. A speed of 1 cm a year is 10 km in a million years and 1,000 km in a hundred million years. These are full opening rates, the sum of both sides.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 22, 'Plate Tectonics'; US Geological Survey, This Dynamic Earth: The Story of Plate Tectonics (Understanding Plate Motions), https://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/dynamic/understanding.html (Mid-Atlantic Ridge spreading about 2.5 cm a year; East Pacific Rise more than 15 cm a year; Arctic Ridge under 2.5 cm a year; Pacific Plate past North America about 5 cm a year; most Himalayan growth in the past 10 million years); Geological Society of London, Frederick Vine and Drummond Matthews, https://www.geolsoc.org.uk/Plate-Tectonics/Chap1-Pioneers-of-Plate-Tectonics/Vine-and-Matthews.html (1963 paper in Nature; stripes record field reversals; basalts of equal age at equal distances on both sides; Lawrence Morley independently)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 22, 'Plate Tectonics'
- Geological Society of London, Frederick Vine and Drummond Matthews · web
- US Geological Survey, This Dynamic Earth: The Story of Plate Tectonics (Understanding Plate Motions) · web
Check your understanding
Which was the strongest scientific objection to Wegener's idea in the 1920s?
The facts were hard to dismiss, but a hypothesis with no workable cause is incomplete. Rotation and tides cannot move continents.Why does the ocean floor show matching magnetic stripes on both sides of a ridge?
Each reversal of Earth's field is frozen into new crust, then carried away on both sides, making mirror-image strips.The 780,000-year reversal boundary is 31 km from a ridge axis. What is the speed of the seafloor on that side?
31 km / 0.78 million years is about 40 km per million years, which is 4 cm a year.