The solid Earth: plate tectonics, rocks and minerals: India's journey, the Deccan Traps, mountains and ores
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 18: The solid Earth: plate tectonics, rocks and minerals Part 6 of 6India's journey, the Deccan Traps, mountains and ores
India offers a whole course in one subcontinent. It broke from a southern supercontinent, raced north, crashed into Asia and raised the highest mountains on Earth. On the way it crossed a hotspot and was buried under lava. The same processes also concentrate the ores that the commodities course traces to market.
6.1 India sped north across a vanishing ocean and hit Asia about 50 million years ago
Take the story from the south. Some 120 million years ago, India was joined to Antarctica, Australia and Madagascar in the southern supercontinent Gondwana. Rifting freed it, first from Antarctica and Australia and later from Madagascar, and the Indian plate set off north across the Tethys Ocean, whose floor sank under the southern edge of Asia. About 80 million years ago India lay roughly 6,400 km south of Asia and moved at about 9 m a century, or 9 cm a year (USGS). Before the collision it reached about 15 cm a year (EARTH Magazine, 2015). Slivers of the closing ocean's floor were scraped onto the land and mark the Indus-Tsangpo suture north of the Himalaya.
When did the continents touch? Estimates run from about 59 to 34 million years ago, because contact was gradual and different markers record different stages. A 2016 review dates the first contact, in the central and eastern Himalaya, to 59 plus or minus 1 million years, from a sudden change in the sediment reaching the trench (Hu and colleagues). The USGS gives 40 to 50 million years. Then came the puzzle: India did not stop. Its advance slowed by about half (USGS), but it still moves north-north-east by a few centimetres a year, because buoyant continental crust cannot be dragged down a trench while the forces on the rest of the plate continue.
GPS shows where that motion goes. The interior of the plate deforms by only 1 to 2 mm a year (Jade and colleagues, 2017), but about 2 cm a year of shortening is taken up across the Himalaya (Paul and colleagues, 2000), most of it stored as strain on the locked Main Himalayan Thrust (Wang and Fialko, 2015). That strain is released in great earthquakes such as Nepal's in 2015.
| Stage | Speed | Time | Distance = speed x time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before contact, 80 to 50 million years ago | About 12 cm a year on average (9 cm at the start, up to 15 cm later) = 120 km per million years | 30 million years | 3,600 km (calculated) |
| After contact, 50 million years ago to now | About 5 cm a year on average, slowing towards a few cm today = 50 km per million years | 50 million years | 2,500 km (calculated) |
| Total | 80 million years | 6,100 km (calculated) | |
| Check | USGS: India lay about 6,400 km south of Asia 80 million years ago | Within about 5 per cent (calculated) |
Distance = speed x time. The two averages are round values chosen inside the published ranges, so the match shows that the speeds and the distance are consistent, not that the averages were measured. After contact, part of the convergence is taken up by Asia deforming, not only by India moving.
Source: US Geological Survey, This Dynamic Earth: The Himalayas, two continents collide, https://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/dynamic/himalaya.html (about 80 million years ago India lay roughly 6,400 km south of Asia, moving north at about 9 m a century; collision 40 to 50 million years ago slowed its advance by about half; a 6,000 km plus journey; the Himalaya rise more than 1 cm a year); EARTH Magazine, Himalayas get a new birthdate (2015), reporting the Sydney University microplate study, https://www.earthmagazine.org/article/himalayas-get-new-birthdate/ (new estimate of collision 47 million years ago; older estimates 34 to 59 million years; India moving north at about 15 cm a year before the collision); Hu, Garzanti, Wang, Huang, An and Webb, The timing of India-Asia collision onset: facts, theories, controversies, Earth-Science Reviews 160, 264 to 299 (2016), https://boa.unimib.it/handle/10281/292577 (initial collision in the central-eastern Himalaya dated at 59 plus or minus 1 million years from an abrupt change in sediment provenance in trench settings)- US Geological Survey, This Dynamic Earth: The Himalayas, two continents collide · web
- EARTH Magazine, Himalayas get a new birthdate (2015), reporting the Sydney University microplate study · web
- Hu, Garzanti, Wang, Huang, An and Webb, The timing of India-Asia collision onset: facts, theories, controversies, Earth-Science Reviews 160, 264 to 299 (2016) · web
- Jade and colleagues, India plate angular velocity and contemporary deformation rates from continuous GPS measurements from 1996 to 2015, Scientific Reports 7 (2017) · web
- Paul, Burgmann, Gaur, Bilham and colleagues (CSIR C-MMACS, Bangalore), The motion and active deformation of India, Geophysical Research Letters (2000) · web
- Wang and Fialko, Slip model of the 2015 Mw 7.8 Gorkha (Nepal) earthquake, Geophysical Research Letters (2015) · web
6.2 Mountains rise because colliding crust thickens, and a deep root holds them up
When the Indian plate pushes at Asia, the crust has nowhere to go but up and down. Rock layers buckle into folds and break along thrust faults, so that slices of rock are stacked on top of each other. Folds and faults are the two basic responses of rock to squeezing: bending when deep, warm and slow, breaking when cool and fast. The crust under the Himalaya and the Tibetan plateau is about 70 km thick, twice the usual 35 km of continents. Most of the growth took place in the past 10 million years (USGS). The summit of Everest, 8,848.86 m by the figure Nepal and China announced jointly in December 2020, is limestone holding fossils of sea creatures, laid down on an ancient sea floor long before the collision.
Why does thick crust stand high? Continental crust is lighter than the mantle and, over long times, floats on it, much as a block of wood floats on water: a thicker block rides higher above the waterline and also reaches deeper below it. This balance is isostasy, and it gives every high range a deep root.
The height is checked by erosion. Rain, rivers and glaciers wear a mountain down, and when mass is removed from the top, the root floats the range up again, a little. So a range is a balance between the push from below and the wearing away from above. The USGS puts the present rise of the Himalaya at more than 1 cm a year, while the Aravallis, over a billion years old, have been worn down to low stumps. More on erosion in module 19.
the Tethys floor sinks, leaving sutures and ocean rocks on land
2 Crust shortensfolds and thrust faults stack slices of crust
3 Crust thickensup to about 70 km under Tibet
4 Isostasy lifts itlight thick crust floats high, with a deep root
5 Erosion wears itrivers and glaciers carry rock to the plains and ocean
Outputs The Himalaya and the Tibetan plateauEverest, 8,848.86 mHimalayan rivers feed the Ganga plain with sediment, which is how the mountains build the land below them.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 22, 'Plate Tectonics'; US Geological Survey, This Dynamic Earth: The Story of Plate Tectonics (Understanding Plate Motions), https://pubs.usgs.gov/gip/dynamic/understanding.html (Mid-Atlantic Ridge spreading about 2.5 cm a year; East Pacific Rise more than 15 cm a year; Arctic Ridge under 2.5 cm a year; Pacific Plate past North America about 5 cm a year; most Himalayan growth in the past 10 million years); Paul, Burgmann, Gaur, Bilham and colleagues (CSIR C-MMACS, Bangalore), The motion and active deformation of India, Geophysical Research Letters (2000), https://repository.ias.ac.in/21806/1/346.pdf (observed contraction across the Himalaya of 20 mm a year or less); The Kathmandu Post, It's official: Mount Everest is 8,848.86 metres tall (8 December 2020), https://kathmandupost.com/national/2020/12/08/it-s-official-mount-everest-is-8-848-86-metres-tall (height announced jointly by the foreign ministers of Nepal and China; earlier accepted height 8,848 m)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 22, 'Plate Tectonics'
- US Geological Survey, This Dynamic Earth: The Story of Plate Tectonics (Understanding Plate Motions) · web
- US Geological Survey, This Dynamic Earth: The Himalayas, two continents collide · web
- The Kathmandu Post, It's official: Mount Everest is 8,848.86 metres tall (8 December 2020) · web
- Standard reference values used for the paper estimates (Britannica and USGS general articles on Earth's structure, mineral properties and earthquake magnitude) · layer depths and densities, P and S wave speeds, Mohs numbers and specific gravities, the energy factor of about 31.6 per magnitude unit, the half-lives of potassium-40 (1.25 billion years), uranium-238 (4.47 billion years) and carbon-14 (5,730 years)
6.3 The Deccan Traps are a mass of lava poured out as India crossed a hotspot
The word trap comes from a Swedish word for steps, because weathered lava flows form terraced hillsides. The Deccan Traps are a pile of basalt flows that still cover about 500,000 square km of western and central India, in places about 3 km thick. The original field was larger, perhaps a million square km or more as module 15 noted, because part now lies under the Arabian Sea and part has been eroded. This flood basalt, one of the biggest eruptions of the past 250 million years, sits far from any plate edge. It formed when India, moving north, passed over the Reunion hotspot, a long-lived plume, about 66 million years ago, and huge volumes of melt broke through the plate.
In 2019 two teams published dates in the journal Science. One used uranium-lead in zircon from ash beds between the flows and found four main pulses between about 66.3 and 65.8 million years ago, each lasting about 100,000 years or less, with the largest beginning tens of thousands of years before the asteroid impact at Chicxulub. The other dated the basalt itself by the argon-argon method and concluded that about three quarters of the lava came after the impact. Both put the whole outpouring at about a million years. Module 15 weighed the two suspects for the extinction; the answer turns on dating 66-million-year-old rock to within tens of thousands of years.
The Deccan basalt gives the flat-topped hills of the Western Ghats, the black soils of the plateau and the rock-cut temples of Ellora.
| Quantity | Value | Working |
|---|---|---|
| Group of flows, volume | About 50,000 cubic km | Reported as possibly above this figure |
| Exposed area | About 500,000 sq km | Rounded |
| Average thickness of that group | 100 m (calculated) | 50,000 cubic km / 500,000 sq km = 0.1 km |
| Duration of a pulse | 100,000 years or less | Uranium-lead dating of zircon in ash beds |
| Average output | 0.5 cubic km a year (calculated) | 50,000 cubic km / 100,000 years, a lower limit if the pulse was shorter |
| Kilauea in a long eruption | About 0.09 cubic km a year | USGS study, 1993 |
| Ratio | About 5 to 6 times (calculated) | 0.5 / 0.09 = 5.6 |
- Schoene and colleagues, U-Pb constraints on pulsed eruption of the Deccan Traps across the end-Cretaceous mass extinction, Science 363 (2019) · web
- Science News, Dueling dates for a huge eruption reignite the debate over dinosaurs' death (21 February 2019) · web
- Deposits Magazine, The Deccan Traps, India (Part 1): the story of its genesis (2020) · web
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 22, 'Plate Tectonics'
6.4 Plate settings concentrate metals into ore, and the commodities course takes it from there
An ore is a rock that can be mined at a profit for one of its metals. Most metals are thinly spread: copper makes up about 0.006 per cent of the crust, and an ore needs perhaps 0.5 per cent, a concentration of 0.5 / 0.006 = about 80 times (calculated). Each concentrating process is part of the systems you have just met.
The main routes are these. In a cooling magma chamber, heavy early crystals such as chromite settle into layers: the Sukinda and Nuasahi belts of Odisha hold about 95 per cent of India's chromite resources (Indian Bureau of Mines). Hot water circulating through cracks dissolves metals and drops them as it cools, giving the gold-quartz veins of Kolar in Karnataka and the copper of the Khetri belt in Rajasthan's Jhunjhunu district. Hot brines that vented onto the floors of ancient rift basins built layered zinc and lead sulphides, the ores mined at Zawar near Udaipur and at Rampura Agucha; Rajasthan holds about 89 per cent of India's lead and zinc ore resources and is the only producer. Deep tropical weathering washes out soluble elements and leaves aluminium as bauxite; Odisha has about half of India's. Waves sort heavy grains from light, so ilmenite, zircon and monazite gather in the beach sands of Kerala and of Ganjam in Odisha. And in ancient oceans more than two billion years ago, dissolved iron settled out as banded iron formations, which supply the haematite of Odisha, about a third of India's iron ore resources, and of Jharkhand.
The key point is that geology gives an ore its location, grade and size, and these in turn set the cost curve and the supply risk. Mining also disturbs land and water, so restoring the ground afterwards is part of the cost. The commodities module 'From ground to market' explains how deposit type sets a mine's economics; this module explains why the deposits are where they are.
| Process | Setting | Ore or mineral | Indian example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Magmatic settling | Cooling magma chamber | Chromite | Sukinda and Nuasahi, Odisha |
| Hot water veins | Above subduction zones or near granite | Gold, copper | Kolar gold field, Karnataka (closed in 2001); Khetri copper, Rajasthan |
| Brines on ancient sea floors | Rift basins and spreading ridges | Zinc and lead sulphides | Zawar and Rampura Agucha, Rajasthan |
| Deep weathering | Warm, wet climate on stable land | Bauxite, laterite | Eastern Ghats of Odisha and the Deccan |
| Sorting by water | Rivers and beaches | Ilmenite, zircon, monazite | Kerala and Ganjam (Odisha) beach sands |
| Evaporation | Shallow basins | Salt, gypsum | Rann of Kutch; gypsum of western Rajasthan |
| Chemical sedimentation | Ancient oceans, more than 2 billion years ago | Banded iron | Keonjhar and Sundargarh (Odisha) and Jharkhand |
Shares of national resources are from the Indian Bureau of Mines state reviews in the Indian Minerals Yearbook 2022 (published 2024).
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 23, 'Rocks and Minerals'; Indian Bureau of Mines, Indian Minerals Yearbook 2022, State Reviews: Odisha (advance release, July 2024), https://ibm.gov.in/writereaddata/files/173253530167446405cd4d320_Odisha_IMYB_2022.pdf (Sukinda and Nuasahi ultramafic belts hold 95 per cent of India's chromite resources; Odisha has 96 per cent of chromite, 51 per cent of bauxite and 34 per cent of haematite iron ore; iron ore in Keonjhar, Sundargarh and other districts; titanium minerals and zircon in Ganjam); Indian Bureau of Mines, Indian Minerals Yearbook 2022, State Reviews: Rajasthan (advance release, July 2024), https://ibm.gov.in/writereaddata/files/17325353756744644f45ed822_Rajasthan_IMYB_2022.pdf (lead-zinc at Zawar, Udaipur district, Rajpura-Dariba and Rampura-Agucha, Bhilwara; copper in the Khetri belt, Jhunjhunu district; the state holds 89 per cent of India's lead and zinc ore resources, 54 per cent of copper ore and 82 per cent of gypsum, and is the sole producer of lead and zinc ores)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 23, 'Rocks and Minerals'
- Indian Bureau of Mines, Indian Minerals Yearbook 2022, State Reviews: Odisha (advance release, July 2024) · web
- Indian Bureau of Mines, Indian Minerals Yearbook 2022, State Reviews: Rajasthan (advance release, July 2024) · web
See it in the table
H₂O WaterU UraniumCu CopperAl AluminiumZn ZincFe Iron oreAu GoldPls PulsesAr ArgonCheck your understanding
The Indian plate slowed after contact with Asia, but did not stop. The main reason is that
Light continental crust resists subduction. The convergence continues and is absorbed by folding, faulting and thickening, building the range.A plateau stands 4 km above sea level on crust of density 2.8 over mantle of 3.3. The root below the normal crust is about
Root = 4 x 2.8 / (3.3 minus 2.8) = 11.2 / 0.5, about 22 km.What does the dating of the Deccan Traps show?
Uranium-lead dates of zircon found four high-volume pulses between about 66.3 and 65.8 million years ago. One began before the impact.