Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Permanent magnet: Interventions

Interventions

Changes that would cut emissions or material use, by lever and life stage, with effect per unit, readiness, adoption, evidence and who acts

LeverLife stageChangeEffect per unitReadinessAdoptionWho actsSource
CircularityEnd of lifeRecycle magnet scrap into new magnetsMagnets from anticipated large-scale recycling have over 80% lower impacts than primary ones in most impact categories [7]Research and pilot: recycling of rare earth elements is below 1% today [21]Below 1%Recyclers, magnet makers, wind and car makers[7][21]
SubstituteComponents designUse ferrite instead of NdFeB where the weaker field is acceptableNo rare earths, but ferrite has about a tenth of the energy product (38 against 410 kJ per m3), so more mass is needed for the same field; no per-kg emissions comparison was found in a source that opened [9]Deployed in many small motors; a 100 kW ferrite motor prototype exists [9]Widely used in small motors; no dated share foundMotor and device designers[9]
Change routeMakingMake magnets on a cleaner gridElectricity generation is 42.9% of the 23.5 kg CO2e per kg in the VALOMAG baseline, so a cleaner grid cuts the largest single contributor [6]Deployed in principle; depends on the gridNot foundMagnet makers, governments[6]
DesignComponents designUse hybrid or geared generators in wind turbines to cut neodymium per MWNeodymium falls from 180 kg per MW (direct drive) to 51 kg (hybrid) and 12 kg (geared, doubly fed) [4]DeployedA Vestas V236-15 MW offshore turbine still holds about 909 kg of magnets (calculated) [26]Turbine makers[4][26]
Business modelSupply chainBuild magnet capacity outside ChinaNo emissions saving; cuts the supply risk of the 94% Chinese share [2]. India plans 6,000 t a year [18]Announced: projects outside China add up to about 18 kt of rare earth content as of early 2026 [2]Announced projects outside China are small against China's outputGovernments, magnet makers[2][18]

as of 2026-11-13

Sources

  1. Rare Earth Elements: executive summary International Energy Agency, 2026
  2. Raw materials demand for wind and solar PV technologies in the transition towards a decarbonised energy system (Carrara et al., EUR 30095 EN), Table 4 European Commission Joint Research Centre, 2020
  3. Upscale of Permanent Magnet Dismantling and Recycling, VALOMAG (19049): Life cycle assessment baseline, version 1 (Li and Sprecher, 17 March 2022) Leiden University, 2022
  4. Ex-ante LCA of magnet recycling: progressing towards sustainable industrial-scale technology (van Nielen et al.) Journal of Cleaner Production, 2024
  5. Powering the green economy: the quest for magnets without rare earths (James McKenzie) Physics World, 2023
  6. Cabinet approves Rs 7280 crore Rare Earth Permanent Magnets scheme to enhance self-reliance, promote REPM ecosystem The Tribune, 2025
  7. Neodymium for the energy transition: Outlook to 2030 and key challenges (Materials Factsheet) Energy Transitions Commission
  8. Life Cycle Assessment of Electricity Production from an offshore V236-15 MW Wind Plant (April 2024) Vestas Wind Systems A/S, 2024