Permanent magnet: Interventions
Interventions
Changes that would cut emissions or material use, by lever and life stage, with effect per unit, readiness, adoption, evidence and who acts
| Lever | Life stage | Change | Effect per unit | Readiness | Adoption | Who acts | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Circularity | End of life | Recycle magnet scrap into new magnets | Magnets from anticipated large-scale recycling have over 80% lower impacts than primary ones in most impact categories [7] | Research and pilot: recycling of rare earth elements is below 1% today [21] | Below 1% | Recyclers, magnet makers, wind and car makers | [7][21] |
| Substitute | Components design | Use ferrite instead of NdFeB where the weaker field is acceptable | No rare earths, but ferrite has about a tenth of the energy product (38 against 410 kJ per m3), so more mass is needed for the same field; no per-kg emissions comparison was found in a source that opened [9] | Deployed in many small motors; a 100 kW ferrite motor prototype exists [9] | Widely used in small motors; no dated share found | Motor and device designers | [9] |
| Change route | Making | Make magnets on a cleaner grid | Electricity generation is 42.9% of the 23.5 kg CO2e per kg in the VALOMAG baseline, so a cleaner grid cuts the largest single contributor [6] | Deployed in principle; depends on the grid | Not found | Magnet makers, governments | [6] |
| Design | Components design | Use hybrid or geared generators in wind turbines to cut neodymium per MW | Neodymium falls from 180 kg per MW (direct drive) to 51 kg (hybrid) and 12 kg (geared, doubly fed) [4] | Deployed | A Vestas V236-15 MW offshore turbine still holds about 909 kg of magnets (calculated) [26] | Turbine makers | [4][26] |
| Business model | Supply chain | Build magnet capacity outside China | No emissions saving; cuts the supply risk of the 94% Chinese share [2]. India plans 6,000 t a year [18] | Announced: projects outside China add up to about 18 kt of rare earth content as of early 2026 [2] | Announced projects outside China are small against China's output | Governments, magnet makers | [2][18] |
as of 2026-11-13
Sources
- Rare Earth Elements: executive summary International Energy Agency, 2026
- Raw materials demand for wind and solar PV technologies in the transition towards a decarbonised energy system (Carrara et al., EUR 30095 EN), Table 4 European Commission Joint Research Centre, 2020
- Upscale of Permanent Magnet Dismantling and Recycling, VALOMAG (19049): Life cycle assessment baseline, version 1 (Li and Sprecher, 17 March 2022) Leiden University, 2022
- Ex-ante LCA of magnet recycling: progressing towards sustainable industrial-scale technology (van Nielen et al.) Journal of Cleaner Production, 2024
- Powering the green economy: the quest for magnets without rare earths (James McKenzie) Physics World, 2023
- Cabinet approves Rs 7280 crore Rare Earth Permanent Magnets scheme to enhance self-reliance, promote REPM ecosystem The Tribune, 2025
- Neodymium for the energy transition: Outlook to 2030 and key challenges (Materials Factsheet) Energy Transitions Commission
- Life Cycle Assessment of Electricity Production from an offshore V236-15 MW Wind Plant (April 2024) Vestas Wind Systems A/S, 2024