Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Carnot batteries: Science

Principles

The science it rests on, with why each principle matters to it

Limited by
  • Carnot's limit on heat engines Carnot showed in 1824 that the work an ideal heat engine gets from heat is fixed only by the temperatures between which it works [3], which caps the discharge of every Carnot battery.
  • Second law of thermodynamics Heat flows by itself only from hot to cold, as Clausius stated in 1850 [5]; a heat pump must spend work to pump it uphill, and every irreversible step in that round trip loses energy.

as of 2026-11-12

Discoveries

The discoveries that made it possible: when, by whom and what was found

YearWhoWhat
1824Sadi CarnotPublished Reflections on the Motive Power of Fire: an ideal engine's work is fixed by its temperatures [3]
1848William Thomson (Lord Kelvin)Proposed an absolute scale of temperature from his thermodynamic studies [4]
1850Rudolf ClausiusPublished his paper on the mechanical theory of heat, with a form of the second law [5]

as of 2026-11-12

Physical limits

The limits nature sets, today's best and how far there is still to go

LimitBest todayGap
Carnot limit on the discharge engine, set only by the hot and cold store temperatures [3]About 66% round trip modelled for a particle pumped thermal design [2]; about 77% thermodynamic in a reduced-power test [1]Compressor, turbine and heat exchanger losses; a heater-based plant returns about 25% [1]

as of 2026-11-12

The science explained

The science behind it explained for a curious reader

Think of heat as water held behind a dam. A heat engine makes work by letting heat fall from a hot place to a cold one, and Carnot showed in 1824 that how much work it can make depends only on how far the heat falls, that is, on the two temperatures [3]. A Carnot battery builds that dam on purpose. While charging, a heat pump lifts heat from a cold store to a hot store, like a pump raising water uphill; Clausius's second law of 1850 says this always costs work [5]. While discharging, a heat engine lets the heat fall back and turns a generator. If both machines were perfect, nearly all the electricity would come back. Real ones lose energy at every step, so the best modelled designs return about two-thirds [2].

as of 2026-11-12

Sources

  1. Review of Carnot Battery Technology Commercial Development (Novotny et al., Energies 15(2), 647) MDPI, 2022
  2. Advancing Pumped Thermal Energy Storage Performance and Cost Using Silica Storage Media (Applied Energy 387, 125567) National Laboratory of the Rockies (formerly NREL), 2025
  3. June 12, 1824: Sadi Carnot Publishes Treatise on Heat Engines APS News, American Physical Society, 2009
  4. William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews
  5. Rudolf Julius Emmanuel Clausius MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews