Carnot batteries: What to track
Waiting for the first grid-scale plant to report real results
The key signal is the first grid-scale plant reporting measured efficiency and availability.
| Category | Attribute | Latest | Trend | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Techno-economic | LCOS trajectory | NLR silica PTES USD 115 per MWh (10 h, modelled 2025); reviewed averages USD 230-369; 4-hour lithium USD 210-292 (Lazard 2026)135 | ↗ improving | Shows whether long-duration costs fall below batteries. |
| Technical | Measured round-trip efficiency (analogue of state of health) | SPIC pilot over 65% (company claim, Dec 2025); Isentropic 77% (reduced-power test); Siemens Gamesa rock store about 25%29 | ↕ volatile | Efficiency decides arbitrage margin. |
| Supply chain | Critical mineral cost and geopolitical concentration | None; steel, nitrate salt, sand, standard turbomachinery2 | → stable | Low exposure to mineral shocks. |
| Market | Ancillary service market saturation | Battery LCOS USD 210-292 per MWh at 4 h (Lazard 2026) sets the bar5 | → stable | PTES needs long-duration or capacity payments, not fast frequency markets. |
| Regulatory | Safety and environmental compliance | Process-plant rules; some designs use methanol or hexane24 | → stable | Flammable cold stores add permitting work. |
| Impact | Lifecycle carbon payback period | No payback figure found; home-scale LCA finds impacts driven by PV and grid power, not the storage8 | → stable | Low efficiency means charging power must be clean. |
| Market | Commercial-scale deployment and developer funding | SPIC 1 MW / 4 MWh pilot, Beijing (Dec 2025); Malta heat-exchanger tests at DLR (Store2REPower); Malta Series B USD 50 million (2021); no grid-scale PTES operating6910 | ↕ volatile | Bankability needs operating references. |
| Market | Long-duration storage demand | LDES Council: thermal storage could help lift long-duration capacity to 2-8 TW by 20407 | ↗ improving | Sets the size of the prize. |
Sources
- Carnot Battery development: A review on system performance, applications and commercial state-of-the-art (Vecchi et al., Journal of Energy Storage 55, 105782) University of Birmingham repository, 2022
- Review of Carnot Battery Technology Commercial Development (Novotny et al., Energies 15(2), 647) MDPI, 2022
- Advancing Pumped Thermal Energy Storage Performance and Cost Using Silica Storage Media (Applied Energy 387, 125567) National Laboratory of the Rockies (formerly NREL), 2025
- Design-Point Techno-Economics of Brayton Cycle PTES for Combined Heat and Power (Neises and McTigue, GTP-24-1410) NREL (now National Laboratory of the Rockies) / OSTI, 2024
- Lazard's Levelized Cost of Energy+ (LCOE+), July 2026 (LCOS) Lazard, 2026
- Long-duration 'pumped heat energy storage' startup Malta raises US$50 million in Series B round (news report of company claims) Energy-Storage.news, 2021
- Long Duration Energy Storage Council report spotlights opportunity for thermal energy storage (Net-Zero Heat report, press release) LDES Council, 2022
- Comparative and prospective life cycle assessment of residential Carnot batteries (Laterre, Coppitters, Lemort and Contino, 4th International Workshop on Carnot Batteries) UCLouvain DIAL repository, 2024
- World-first 560 C Carnot battery unveiled as SPIC launches ultra-high-temperature heat storage (news report of company claims) ESS News, 2026
- Malta Inc. Store2REPower project breaks ground for full-scale heat exchanger qualifications Energy Storage Europe, 2024