Fluids: pressure, flow, lift and drag: Drag and lift: forces from moving through a fluid
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 5: Fluids: pressure, flow, lift and drag Part 4 of 5Drag and lift: forces from moving through a fluid
A car at highway speed spends most of its fuel pushing air aside, and an aeroplane stays up by pushing air down. Both forces come from the same source, a body moving relative to a fluid. This part builds the drag formula, shows why it grows with the square of speed and the power with the cube, explains streamlining, and builds the lift formula for a wing.
4.1 Drag grows with the square of speed because a body must shove aside more air, and shove each kilogram faster
Put your hand out of a moving bus window. At walking pace you feel almost nothing, at 40 km/h a firm push, at 80 km/h a shove you must resist. The push grows faster than the speed, and an energy count shows why. Each metre the bus travels, your hand disturbs a tube of air one metre long with the hand's frontal area A, a mass of density x A x 1 m. That air is flung aside at a speed comparable with the bus's speed v, so it takes kinetic energy of about half x density x A x v squared for every metre. Energy per metre is force, so the drag is of that size, and it rises with the square of speed: twice the speed means the same air struck twice as hard.
Engineers put a coefficient in front to cover shape: drag = half x density x Cd x A x speed squared. Cd is the drag coefficient, a pure number set by shape and by Reynolds number. It is about 1.1 for a flat plate facing the wind, near 0.3 for a modern hatchback and about 0.01 for a thin wing section at a small angle. The product Cd x A is called the drag area and is what really matters, because a large vehicle with a clean shape can match a small one with a rough shape.
Power is force x speed, so the power needed to overcome drag grows with the cube of speed. Doubling speed means eight times the power. The tyre adds rolling resistance, a nearly constant drag, so air dominates only at speed. The table shows both.
The trade-off is plain: speed saves time, but each extra kilometre per hour costs disproportionately more fuel, which is why fleets set speed limits.
| Speed | Air drag: half x 1.2 kg/m3 x assumed Cd 0.33 x assumed area 2.2 m2 x v squared | Power for air drag | Rolling drag (assumed coefficient 0.012 x assumed 1,200 kg x 9.8 = 141 N) | Rolling power |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 km/h (13.9 m/s) | 84 N | 1.2 kW | 141 N | 2.0 kW |
| 80 km/h (22.2 m/s) | 215 N | 4.8 kW | 141 N | 3.1 kW |
| 100 km/h (27.8 m/s) | 336 N | 9.3 kW | 141 N | 3.9 kW |
| 120 km/h (33.3 m/s) | 484 N | 16.1 kW | 141 N | 4.7 kW |
All results calculated; power = force x speed. Check: at 100 km/h the wheels need about 13 kW. With an assumed engine efficiency of 25 per cent that is 53 kW of fuel energy, about 1.65 millilitres (some 1.2 g) of petrol a second at 32 MJ per litre, or 5.9 litres per 100 km, since 100 km takes 3,600 s. That is close to the real 6 litres per 100 km of a small petrol car, and going from 100 to 120 km/h raises air-drag power by 73 per cent.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 6, 'Fluids and Motion', section 6.2 (aerodynamics, drag)- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 6, 'Fluids and Motion', section 6.2 (aerodynamic drag, viscous drag, pressure drag)
4.2 Streamlining fights pressure drag by keeping the flow attached to the body
Ride a scooter behind a loaded lorry on a dusty road and you meet a swirling cloud of grit that follows it along. That cloud is the wake, a region of slow, tumbling air at low pressure dragged behind the square back. The lorry's nose meets air at high pressure, its back faces air at low pressure, and the difference, summed over the frontal area, is pressure drag. A second, smaller cost is skin friction, the shear in the thin layer of air next to the surface, called the boundary layer. For a blunt lorry, pressure drag is nearly all of it; for a well-shaped body, skin friction dominates.
The size of the wake depends on where the flow lets go of the surface. Along the front of a body the air is squeezed past and speeds up, and by Bernoulli's principle its pressure falls. Towards the rear the passage widens again, the air must slow, and the pressure climbs back. The boundary layer, having spent energy on friction against the skin, copes worst with that climb. If it is steep, the slowest air near the wall comes to rest, starts to creep backwards and lifts the main flow off the surface. That is separation, and everything downstream of it is wake.
Streamlining makes the pressure climb gently so that separation comes late or not at all, which is why aircraft fuselages close in slowly. A flat-backed Goods vehicle does the opposite, and tail extensions recover a little.
Turbulence in the boundary layer is, surprisingly, an ally: it keeps stirring fast outer air down towards the wall, so it can push further into rising pressure before it stops. Engineers use this: grit glued near the nose of a small wind-tunnel model makes it separate where the full-size machine would.
The trade-off is length: a long tapering tail costs space and weight, so road vehicles settle for a rounded nose, a smooth underside and as much rear taper as the use allows.
about 25 per cent of fuel energy becomes shaft work; about 40 kW leaves as hot exhaust and coolant
2 Transmissiongearbox and axle losses are left out of this estimate
Outputs Air drag9.3 kW, 70 per cent of the wheel power Rolling drag3.9 kW, 30 per cent of the wheel powerWheel power 13.2 kW is calculated from estimate 8. Module 6, Heat and thermodynamics, explains why the engine loses three quarters of the fuel energy as heat. Engine 25 per cent is an assumed round figure.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 6, 'Fluids and Motion', section 6.2 (drag forces)- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 6, 'Fluids and Motion', section 6.2 (boundary layers, flow separation, pressure drag)
4.3 Lift: a wing turns air downward, and the reaction holds the aeroplane up
On a windy Makar Sankranti afternoon, a paper kite tilted into the breeze climbs and tugs at its string. The kite meets the wind at an angle and sends it off slightly downward. Giving the air downward momentum each second needs a downward force on the air, so the air pushes the kite up. A wing is a refined kite, and the tilt at which it meets the oncoming air is called the angle of attack. Seen from the wing's surface, the same force appears as lower pressure over the top than underneath; the momentum count of part 2 and the pressure picture are two ways of adding up one force.
Engineers write lift = half x density x CL x wing area x speed squared. CL, the lift coefficient, rises with the angle of attack. Because lift goes with speed squared, every aeroplane has a speed below which its wings cannot carry its weight, and the table finds it for an airliner. Flying slower means raising the nose to raise CL, but near 15 degrees the boundary layer over the top can no longer climb the steep pressure rise towards the trailing edge, the flow separates, and lift falls away. That is a stall: separation, as in the last section, and nothing to do with the engines.
For landing, slats slide forward and flaps run back and down, giving a larger, more curved wing with a far higher CL at low speed, paid for with extra drag. Drag also comes with lift itself. The higher pressure under the wing leaks round each tip into the low pressure above, shedding a trailing vortex whose energy the engines must supply, called induced drag. A long, slender wing makes its lift from a wider sweep of air, so it loses less this way. Gliders reach lift-to-drag ratios of 40 or more, against about 17 for a loaded airliner. The trade-off is structural: a long thin wing bends more and needs a heavier root.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Weight on landing | 70,000 kg x 9.8 | 686 kN |
| Wing area | assume 122 m2, typical of a narrow-body twin-jet | 122 m2 |
| Lift coefficient with flaps and slats out | assume 2.5 | CL = 2.5 |
| Speed at which lift equals weight | square root of (2 x 686,000 N / (1.2 kg/m3 x 122 m2 x 2.5)) | 61 m/s, 220 km/h |
| Lift to drag ratio in cruise | assume 17 | drag = 686 kN / 17 = 40 kN |
| Cruise at 11 km height, air 0.36 kg/m3 (standard atmosphere) and assumed speed 230 m/s (830 km/h) | CL = 686,000 / (half x 0.36 x 230 x 230 x 122) | about 0.59 |
All results calculated; the weight is assumed to stay 70 tonnes in cruise for simplicity. Check: airliners of this size cross the runway threshold at about 230 to 260 km/h, a margin above the stalling speed. The cruise CL of 0.59 is far below the 2.5 at landing, and the 40 kN of drag is balanced by engine thrust of about 20 kN each. The weights and areas are assumed round numbers, not a particular Aeroplane.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 6, 'Fluids and Motion', section 6.3 (airfoils, lift, angle of attack, stalled wings)- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 6, 'Fluids and Motion', section 6.3 (airfoils, lifting wings, induced drag, stalled wings)
Check your understanding
A car at 60 km/h faces an air drag of 100 N. What air drag does it face at 120 km/h, assuming the same shape?
Drag goes as speed squared, so doubling speed gives four times the drag, 400 N. The power needed rises eightfold.Why might engineers glue a thin strip of grit near the nose of a small wind-tunnel model?
A turbulent boundary layer resists separation better than a laminar one. Later separation means a smaller low-pressure wake and less pressure drag.A wing is flown at a steady angle of attack. If the aeroplane flies 20 per cent faster, by what factor does lift change?
Lift goes as speed squared: 1.2 x 1.2 = 1.44, about 1.4 times. A pilot must trim the angle of attack down to keep lift equal to weight.