Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Fluids: pressure, flow, lift and drag: Fans, propellers, turbines and models: putting flow to work and learning to predict it

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 5: Fluids: pressure, flow, lift and drag Part 5 of 5

Fans, propellers, turbines and models: putting flow to work and learning to predict it

A ceiling fan, a ship's propeller and a wind turbine blade are the same kind of object used in different directions: a rotating wing that either gives energy to a fluid or takes it. This part shows why big slow rotors are efficient, estimates the power of a wind turbine, and explains how engineers use scale models and test data to design what theory cannot yet predict.

5.1 A propeller or fan is a spinning wing, and it is cheaper to push a lot of air slowly than a little air fast

Stand under a ceiling fan and the breeze you feel is the downward momentum of the air its blades have turned. Seen up close, every blade is a wing whose flight path is a circle: it meets the air at an angle of attack, and its lift, pointing along the axis, is the thrust. A point near the tip travels round much faster than a point near the hub, so a well-made blade is set at a steeper angle near the hub and a flatter one near the tip, keeping each part at a useful angle to the air it meets. The designer chooses diameter, blade angles, blade count and turning speed.

Which combination is best follows from the control volume of part 2. Thrust = mass flow x increase in air speed. Now look at power. The jet leaving the fan carries kinetic energy, half x mass flow x speed squared, and this is wasted unless it is the goal. For a fixed thrust, mass flow x speed gain is fixed, so you can choose a big mass flow and a small speed gain, or the reverse. Wasted kinetic energy is proportional to speed gain times thrust, so the first choice wastes less. A large propeller turning slowly is more efficient than a small one turning fast. That is why airliner engines have huge fans, why a Helicopter has long rotor blades, why tug boats have big slow propellers, and why a ceiling fan has a wide sweep.

Tips moving near the speed of sound lose efficiency and make noise, so size is limited. The table puts numbers on a ceiling fan.

Data Worked estimate 10: a ceiling fan, old and new
QuantityConventional induction fanBLDC (brushless motor) fan
Sweep and area of disc1,200 mm, 1.13 m21,200 mm, 1.13 m2
Electric power at full speedabout 75 Wabout 28 W (tested range 27 to 35 W)
Air delivery at full speedabout 210 m3/min (assumed round figure)about 228 m3/min (tested value for one Indian brand)
Average air speed through the disc210 / 60 / 1.13 = 3.1 m/s228 / 60 / 1.13 = 3.4 m/s
Service value, air delivered per watt210 / 75 = 2.8 m3/min per W228 / 28 = 8.1 m3/min per W
Running 10 hours a day for 300 days3,000 h x 0.075 kW = 225 kWh3,000 h x 0.028 kW = 84 kWh
Cost at an assumed Rs 7 per kWhabout Rs 1,575about Rs 590, saving about Rs 990 a year

Sources: BLDC figures from a March 2023 laboratory test of four 1200 mm BLDC fans to IS 374:2019 by the VOICE Society, hosted on the Department of Consumer Affairs website (power 26.9 to 35.4 W; service values 6.7 to 8.2; the 28 W and 228 m3/min pair is one fan). The 75 W conventional fan is the figure used in the same report as an example. The saving comes mainly from a more efficient motor, not from a larger sweep.

Source: VOICE Society (Consumer VOICE), comparative test of BLDC ceiling fans, hosted by the Department of Consumer Affairs, Government of India (March 2023), https://consumeraffairs.nic.in/sites/default/files/file-uploads/ctocpas/BLDC_Ceiling_Fans_Choosing_Efficiency.pdf
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 6, 'Fluids and Motion', section 6.3 (thrust, airplane propulsion)

5.2 A wind turbine takes power from the wind in proportion to the cube of its speed, and cannot take all of it

A wind turbine is a propeller run backwards. The wind turns the blades and the blades turn a generator. To estimate how much power is available, use the kinetic energy of the air that passes through the rotor circle. The mass flow is density x swept area x wind speed. The kinetic energy per second is half x mass flow x speed squared. Together, the power in the wind is half x density x swept area x speed cubed.

The cube is the single most important number for wind energy. Doubling the wind speed multiplies the available power by eight. A site with steady winds of 7 m/s has about 1.6 times the power of a site with 6 m/s, and a site at 10 m/s has nearly five times as much as one at 6 m/s. So siting matters, and tall towers that reach faster winds pay off.

A turbine cannot take all of this power. If it stopped the air completely, the air could not leave and the flow would pile up and go around the rotor. If it took nothing, it would make nothing. There is a best compromise in between, published in 1920 by the German physicist Albert Betz, in which the wind is slowed to a third of its speed far behind the rotor. The result is that no turbine can take more than 16/27, about 59 per cent, of the wind's power. Good modern rotors reach 45 to 50 per cent. The Wind turbine blade must be long, light and strong, and the Wind turbine generating set turns the slow shaft into electricity.

Data Worked estimate 11: power from a 3 MW, 144 m rotor at different wind speeds
Wind speedPower in the wind: half x 1.2 x 16,286 m2 x v cubedAfter rotor (45 per cent)After drivetrain and generator (90 per cent)
4 m/s0.63 MW0.28 MW0.25 MW
6 m/s2.11 MW0.95 MW0.85 MW
8 m/s5.00 MW2.25 MW2.03 MW
10 m/s9.77 MW4.40 MW3.96 MW, so capped at 3 MW
12 m/s16.9 MW7.60 MW6.84 MW, so capped at 3 MW

All results calculated, with air at an assumed 1.2 kg/m3. Swept area = 3.14 x 72 m x 72 m = 16,286 m2. Setting 0.405 x 9,772 W per (m/s)3 x v cubed equal to 3,000,000 W gives v cubed = 758, so v is about 9.1 m/s, the point where the cap begins in this estimate. The 45 and 90 per cent are assumed round numbers; a real rotor's efficiency falls near and above rated speed. Rotor diameter and rating are from MNRE's list.

Source: Ministry of New and Renewable Energy, Government of India, Approved List of Models and Manufacturers (ALMM), Wind, as on 29 October 2026, S144 entry: 3,000, 3,150 and 3,300 kW; rotor diameter 144 m; hub heights 105 to 160 m; no rated wind speed given; https://mnre.gov.in/static/uploads/2026/10/c4d85161819b2e95f9779988953be330.pdf

5.3 Models and test data: what engineers do when the flow is too complicated to calculate

Even with modern computers, the flow round a whole aeroplane or propeller cannot be predicted perfectly, and simulations are still checked against tests. A scale model is put in a wind tunnel, air is blown over it, and forces are measured. The question is whether results from a small model hold for the full-size machine.

They do if the flows are similar, and similarity is carried by pure numbers. The Reynolds number is one. For a given shape, the flow pattern depends on the shape and on Re, not on size or speed alone. A model one fifth the size needs five times the speed to have the same Re, which is impractical: at 500 km/h, air starts to compress and behaves differently. So tunnel builders pressurise or cool the air, which raises density or lowers viscosity, or accept the mismatch, trip the model's boundary layer and correct for it. The Mach number, speed divided by the speed of sound, is a second number that must match when air compresses.

For propellers, the governing number is the advance ratio, V/nD: forward speed divided by turning rate times diameter. Two propellers of the same shape at the same V/nD have the same efficiency whatever their size, which is what made model data usable. A well-known early use of this, described by the historian Walter Vincenti, came at Stanford University between 1916 and 1926, where William Durand and Everett Lesley, working under contract to the US National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, tested about a hundred carved wooden model propellers, starting with a planned set of 48 shapes. Their reports gave efficiency and related coefficients against V/nD, and aeroplane designers of the 1920s chose propellers from them. Vincenti treats such systematic testing as a way of producing engineering knowledge in its own right.

Wind-tunnel work still shapes every Passenger car, Aeroplane and Wind turbine blade. Tunnels are costly, so engineers test the few key variables and let calculation fill the rest.

Data Worked estimate 12: matching a model to the real car
StepWorkingResult
Real car: length, speed, Re4.2 m at 27.8 m/s, as in estimate 67.8 million
Model at one fifth scale, same speed0.84 m1.56 million, five times too low
Speed needed for the same Re27.8 m/s x 5139 m/s, about 500 km/h
Mach number at that speed139 / 3400.41, air starts to compress, so the match fails
Fix: cool or pressurise the airraise density by 5 times, or lower viscositye.g. 5 atmospheres at the same speed
Carrying the result acrossmeasure drag on the model, divide by half x density x area x speed squared to get Cduse that Cd for the car, because Cd is a pure number

All results calculated. Propeller testing (Durand and Lesley, 1916 to 1926) used the same idea of pure numbers, with advance ratio as the variable in place of Reynolds number.

Source: Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990), ch. 5, 'Data for Design: The Air-Propeller Tests of W. F. Durand and E. P. Lesley'
  • Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 5, 'Data for Design: The Air-Propeller Tests of W. F. Durand and E. P. Lesley' (parameter variation, model testing, similitude)
  • Vincenti, What Engineers Know and How They Know It (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990) · ch. 4, 'A Theoretical Tool for Design: Control-Volume Analysis' (use of theory with data)

See it in the table

El Electricity

Check your understanding

Why is a large, slowly turning rotor a more efficient way of producing thrust than a small, fast one?

Thrust = mass flow x speed gain. The power lost as jet energy rises with speed gain, so moving more air by a little is cheaper than moving less air by a lot.

The wind at a site rises from 5 m/s to 10 m/s. By what factor does the power in the wind through the rotor change?

Power in the wind goes as speed cubed, and 2 x 2 x 2 = 8. The turbine's output is capped at its rated power, but the wind's power is eightfold.

A wind-tunnel model is one tenth of the size of the real machine. To match the Reynolds number in the same air, what must happen to the speed?

Re = density x speed x size / viscosity. A tenth of the size needs ten times the speed, which is why tunnels may pressurise or cool the air instead.
← Part 4: Drag and lift: forces from moving through a fluidMark read · Wrap-up →