Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Matter at the atomic scale: bonds, reactions and process engineering: Reactions: energy, rate and catalysts

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 10: Matter at the atomic scale: bonds, reactions and process engineering Part 2 of 5

Reactions: energy, rate and catalysts

A chemical reaction rearranges atoms. Whether it gives out heat or soaks it up, how fast it goes, and what can speed it up are the three questions a process engineer asks first. This part answers them with a bond tally for natural gas, rate estimates for a fridge and a pressure cooker, and a look at catalysts.

2.1 A reaction rearranges atoms, and the heat it gives out is the energy of the bonds formed minus the bonds broken

Burn the gas in a kitchen stove and nothing is lost: the carbon and hydrogen atoms in the gas and the oxygen atoms in the air are all still there afterwards, now arranged as carbon dioxide and water. A chemical equation is a ledger of atoms, and it must balance on both sides. It is the atom-by-atom twin of the conservation of energy met in Force, motion and energy.

The heat comes from a second ledger, kept in energy. Add up what it costs to separate every bond in the reactants, then subtract what is handed back as the product bonds close. A positive balance left over is released (exothermic); a shortfall must be supplied (endothermic). A gas flame is the first kind and an instant cold pack the second. The table tallies methane burning with typical bond energies, and its result lands on the measured heating value of natural gas, which is a nice check on the whole idea.

The sign matters in plant design, since heat must be removed from one reactor and supplied to another. Burning and ammonia synthesis (about 46 kJ released per mole of ammonia) are exothermic, so the reactor must lose heat or its contents will warm up. Steam reforming of methane is strongly endothermic, about 206 kJ absorbed per mole of methane, so heat must be fed in through hot furnace tubes. Much of a plant's equipment and fuel bill exists to move this heat to where it is needed.

Data Estimate 2: the heat from burning one mole of methane, from bond energies
StepWorkingEnergy (kJ per mol of CH4)
Bonds broken: 4 C-H4 x 413+1,652
Bonds broken: 2 O=O2 x 498+996
Total spent+2,648
Bonds made: 2 C=O (in CO2)2 x 799-1,598
Bonds made: 4 O-H (in 2 H2O)4 x 463-1,852
Total returned-3,450
Net released3,450 - 2,648802
Per kilogram802 kJ / 0.016 kgabout 50 MJ per kg
Checkpublished lower heating value of methane about 50 MJ per kgagrees

Bond energies are average values for gases and are rounded; the tally is accurate to a few per cent only, but it gives the sign and the size of the heat. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (heating value of fuels as idea source; the bond tally is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)
  • Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. I (Caltech online edition) · ch. 1, 'Atoms in Motion', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_01.html (chemical reactions as rearrangements)

2.2 Reaction rate rises steeply with temperature because only molecules that carry enough energy can climb the barrier

Milk keeps for days in a fridge and sours within hours on a summer counter. Molecules meet and collide all the time, but a collision turns into a reaction only if the pair has enough energy to push through a barrier of bond-stretching, the activation energy. At a temperature T the share of molecules with at least that energy is proportional to exp(minus activation energy / (R x T)), where R is 8.314 J per mol per K. This factor changes very quickly with T, because T sits in the exponent.

The table puts numbers on it. For a reaction with an activation energy of 50 kJ per mol, typical for many food and organic changes, a 10 K rise at room temperature nearly doubles the rate. Cooling from 25 degrees C to 5 degrees C slows it more than fourfold, which is why a fridge extends shelf life from a day to several days. For pulses, an assumed 80 kJ per mol is a fair guess; raising the temperature in a pressure cooker from 100 to 120 degrees C makes it go about 3.7 times faster, so a 40-minute pot of pulses takes about 11 minutes, close to what cooks report.

Two more levers matter. Rate rises with concentration, so squeezing gases speeds a reaction. For solids only the exposed surface reacts: icing sugar dissolves faster than a lump, and a lump of coal burns steadily while a cloud of coal or bagasse dust can explode.

Running hot costs energy and stronger vessels and, as Part 3 shows, changes the equilibrium. Much of process design is the argument between rate and these costs.

Data Estimate 3: how much does a temperature change alter reaction rate?
CaseWorking (rate ratio = exp[(Ea / R) x (1/T1 - 1/T2)])Result
Ea = 50 kJ per mol, so Ea / R50,000 / 8.3146,014 K
Warm day: 25 to 35 degrees C (298 K to 308 K)exp[6,014 x (1/298 - 1/308)] = exp(0.655)1.9 times faster
Fridge: 5 degrees C against 25 degrees Cexp[6,014 x (1/278 - 1/298)] = exp(1.452)4.3 times slower
Ea = 80 kJ per mol, so Ea / R80,000 / 8.3149,622 K
Pressure cooker: 100 to 120 degrees C (373 K to 393 K)exp[9,622 x (1/373 - 1/393)] = exp(1.312)3.7 times faster

The activation energies of 50 and 80 kJ per mol are assumed round values, typical of organic and food reactions. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. I (Caltech online edition), ch. 40, 'The Principles of Statistical Mechanics', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_40.html (the exponential energy factor; formula stated here in the author's words)
  • Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. I (Caltech online edition) · ch. 40, 'The Principles of Statistical Mechanics', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_40.html
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)

2.3 A catalyst lowers the barrier, speeds the reaction both ways equally, and leaves the equilibrium where it was

A catalyst is a material that takes part in a reaction without being used up. It gives the molecules a different route, with a lower barrier, usually by holding them on its surface in a way that weakens a bond that was hard to break. Because the barrier is in the exponent of the rate, the gain is large. Take a reaction at 700 K (427 degrees C), as in an exhaust pipe or an ammonia converter. A catalyst that lowers the activation energy by 20 kJ per mol multiplies the rate by exp[20,000 / (8.314 x 700)] = exp(3.44), about 31.

Three rules apply. First, a catalyst does not change the destination: it speeds the forward and reverse reactions in the same proportion, so it cannot push a reaction past its equilibrium (see the next part). Second, a surface does the work, so catalysts are spread on a porous support with an enormous area, typically 100 to 200 square metres in a single gram of alumina. Third, a catalyst can choose: from the same feed, different catalysts steer to different products, which is how a refinery or a polymer plant gets the one it wants.

The Catalytic converter in a car is the commonplace case. A ceramic honeycomb carries a thin coating of platinum, palladium and rhodium. These metals let carbon monoxide and hydrocarbons burn at only a few hundred degrees and convert nitrogen oxides back to nitrogen. Haber-Bosch ammonia synthesis uses iron with promoters; Ziegler-Natta polymerisation uses a titanium catalyst that steers chain growth. See also the science node Catalysis and the chemicals entry Chemical process catalysts.

The trade-off is fragility and cost. Lead from old petrol and sulphur coat the surface and kill the catalyst (poisoning); high heat fuses the fine particles together (sintering); and platinum-group metals are expensive and often recovered at end of life.

  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)
  • Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. III (Caltech online edition) · ch. 10, 'Other Two-State Systems', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/III_10.html

See it in the table

H₂O WaterGas Natural gasPt PlatinumPd PalladiumRh RhodiumTi TitaniumSu SugarPls PulsesH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenCO2 Carbon dioxideNH3 AmmoniaCat Chemical process catalysts

Check your understanding

Methane burning releases heat because:

Bond breaking costs energy. The net release comes from forming tighter bonds, here 3,450 kJ returned against 2,648 kJ spent per mole.

A reaction with an activation energy of 50 kJ per mol is run at 35 degrees C instead of 25 degrees C. The rate changes by roughly:

The exponential factor gives exp(0.655), about 1.9. This is the origin of the rule that rates roughly double for each 10 K.

What can a catalyst NOT do?

A catalyst speeds forward and reverse reactions alike, so the equilibrium composition stays the same; it only gets there sooner.
← Part 1: Atoms and bonds: why materials behave as they doMark read · Part 3: Equilibrium, recycle and the balances that size a plant →