Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Matter at the atomic scale: bonds, reactions and process engineering: Equilibrium, recycle and the balances that size a plant

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 10: Matter at the atomic scale: bonds, reactions and process engineering Part 3 of 5

Equilibrium, recycle and the balances that size a plant

Reactions stop short, so plants send unreacted feed round again. Engineers also draw a box round a plant and count what crosses its walls, kilogram by kilogram and joule by joule. This part uses an ammonia loop for equilibrium and recycle, and an Indian sugar mill for the mass balance and the energy balance.

3.1 Reactions run both ways, so many stop short of completion, and plants recycle what has not reacted

Stir salt into water until no more dissolves: from then on salt dissolves and crystallises at the same rate. Reactions can behave the same way. Nitrogen and hydrogen join into ammonia, but ammonia also breaks back into nitrogen and hydrogen. At the point where the two rates are equal the mixture stops changing. That point is chemical equilibrium (see the science node Chemical equilibrium (Le Chatelier's principle)), and it sets the most that a reactor can convert, whatever the catalyst or the time given.

The equilibrium can be moved. If a change is imposed on a mixture at equilibrium, it shifts to oppose the change. Ammonia synthesis puts four molecules (one of nitrogen, three of hydrogen) into two. Squeezing favours the side with fewer molecules, so high pressure, 150 to 250 bar, pushes toward ammonia. The reaction gives out heat, so a lower temperature also favours ammonia. But rate falls steeply as the temperature drops (Part 2), so the plant runs the catalyst at about 400 to 500 degrees C and accepts that the gas leaving the converter is only about a fifth ammonia.

That is where recycle comes in. The gas leaving the reactor is chilled until ammonia condenses, and the liquid is drawn off. The leftover nitrogen and hydrogen go back to the front, with a small bleed to keep the loop clean. The table shows the arithmetic for one tonne of ammonia per hour at a per-pass conversion of 25 per cent, an assumed round figure. The loop carries four times the fresh feed, so compressors and pipes are four times the size that net production suggests.

The cement kiln uses the same rule by removing a product: its gas flow sweeps away carbon dioxide so the limestone keeps decomposing.

Data Estimate 4: the recycle loop of an ammonia reactor making 1 tonne of ammonia an hour
QuantityWorkingResult
Ammonia made1,000 kg / 17.03 kg per kmol58.7 kmol per hour
Reactants used (N2 + 3 H2, 4 mol give 2 mol of NH3)2 x 58.7117.4 kmol per hour
Fresh feed neededequals reactants used (nothing is lost)117.4 kmol per hour
Per-pass conversion (assumed)25 per cent
Gas entering the reactor117.4 / 0.25470 kmol per hour
Recycle gas470 - 117.4352 kmol per hour
Recycle ratio352 / 117.43 times the fresh feed
Without recycle: feed for the same output117.4 / 0.25470 kmol per hour, three quarters wasted

The 25 per cent conversion is an assumed round figure. Modern converters send out gas with about 19 to 21 per cent ammonia (AIChE); with some ammonia and inert gas already in the inlet, that means roughly a quarter to a third of the hydrogen and nitrogen react on each pass (calculated). Real plants also lose a little gas in a purge and in dissolved ammonia, so make-up is slightly above 117.4 kmol per hour. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (mass balances; idea source only, the loop calculation is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)
  • Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. I (Caltech online edition) · ch. 40, 'The Principles of Statistical Mechanics', https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_40.html
  • AIChE, 'Introduction to Ammonia Production', Chemical Engineering Progress (read November 2026) · converter exit ammonia concentration raised from about 12 to 19 to 21 per cent; synthesis loops at 150 to 200 bar; https://aiche.org/redirect/cep-highlight-introduction-ammonia-production

3.2 Worked estimate: a tonne of ammonia needs 178 kg of hydrogen, and where it comes from sets the energy and the carbon dioxide

Ammonia is the base of nitrogen fertiliser. Start with N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3. One tonne of ammonia is 58.7 kmol. It needs half as many kilomoles of nitrogen, 29.4 kmol (822 kg), and one and a half times as many of hydrogen, 88.1 kmol (178 kg). Check: 822 kg plus 178 kg make 1,000 kg.

Now the hydrogen. About 70 per cent of the world's ammonia uses steam reforming of natural gas, and most of the rest uses coal. In the idealised gas route, one methane and two water molecules give one carbon dioxide and four hydrogen. So 88.1 kmol of hydrogen needs 22 kmol of methane, 353 kg, and 44 kmol of steam, 0.79 t, and it releases 22 kmol of carbon dioxide, 0.97 t. That 0.97 t is the carbon dioxide inherent in the chemistry. Burning gas to heat the reformer tubes adds more, which is why IEA puts the world average at about 2.4 t of carbon dioxide per tonne of ammonia, coal included. Best natural-gas plants use about 28 GJ per tonne; the world average is about 41 GJ (IEA, 2021).

The alternative is water electrolysis (see Electrolysers and Low-carbon hydrogen and e-fuels). At about 52 kWh per kg of hydrogen (the IEA's 2024 average electrolyser efficiency of 63 per cent gives 53, calculated), 178 kg needs 9.2 MWh, or 33 GJ of electricity. That is more joules than the gas route, and at an assumed Rs 4 per kWh the power costs about Rs 37,000 per tonne, against about Rs 25,000 for gas at an assumed Rs 900 per GJ. The gain is carbon, none if the power is clean; the price is dearer power today.

One tonne of ammonia holds about 18.6 GJ of fuel value, so the best gas plant keeps two thirds of its input as product. The synthesis itself releases only 2.7 GJ; the energy goes into making hydrogen and compressing gas. Fritz Haber proved the process on a bench in 1909; Carl Bosch's first BASF plant ran in 1913, serving fertiliser and, in the First World War, munitions.

Process flowchart Making one tonne of ammonia from natural gas (idealised chemistry)
Inputs Natural gasabout 28 GJ in all at best practice, of which 0.35 t of methane is the chemical need Steam (water)about 0.8 t as reactant Airabout 1.1 t, for 0.82 t of nitrogen Process steps 1 Reformer

methane + steam → carbon monoxide + hydrogen at 800 to 900 degrees C, absorbs heat, nickel catalyst

2 Shift reactor

carbon monoxide + steam → carbon dioxide + more hydrogen

3 Carbon dioxide removal

gas scrubbed free of CO2 before it reaches the iron catalyst

4 Synthesis loop

N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3 at 150 to 250 bar and 400 to 500 degrees C, about 25 per cent per pass, recycle 3 to 1

Outputs Ammonia1 t, about 18.6 GJ of fuel value Carbon dioxideabout 1 t from the reaction (more from fuel); often sold on to make urea

Quantities are the idealised stoichiometric amounts worked out in the text; IEA best-practice energy is 28 GJ per tonne, and the world average about 41 GJ. Modern converters send out gas that is about 19 to 21 per cent ammonia (AIChE).

Source: International Energy Agency, Ammonia Technology Roadmap (2021, read November 2026), executive summary: about 8.6 EJ used, over 70 per cent from natural gas steam reforming, best-practice 28 GJ per tonne, about 2.4 t CO2 per tonne on average; https://www.iea.org/reports/ammonia-technology-roadmap/executive-summary
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)
  • International Energy Agency, Ammonia Technology Roadmap (2021, read November 2026) · executive summary, https://www.iea.org/reports/ammonia-technology-roadmap/executive-summary
  • International Energy Agency, Global Hydrogen Review 2025, Assumptions annex (read November 2026) · production pathways: water electrolysis efficiency 63 per cent (LHV) in 2024; https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/15673ab3-a86a-4434-bff4-490bb42d3563/GlobalHydrogenReview2025AssumptionsAnnex.pdf

3.3 A mass balance counts every kilogram crossing a boundary, and a 5,000 tonne-a-day sugar mill shows it closing

A process engineer's first tool is an accounting identity: at steady state, what goes into a box equals what comes out. The box can be a mill, a reactor or a single tank. The rule applies to total mass, to each element, and to each component that does not react. Choose a basis (here 100 t of cane), list every stream, and write one equation per unknown. If the books do not close, a stream is missing.

The table follows 100 t of cane through an Indian sugar mill. Cane is about 14.5 per cent fibre, 14.5 per cent dissolved solids, mostly sucrose, and 71 per cent water; these are typical values, assumed round. Rollers squeeze it, and water (imbibition water) is sprayed on to wash out more sugar. The leftover fibre is bagasse. Lime treatment drops the dirt out as filter cake. The clear juice is boiled in evaporators to a 60 per cent syrup, then in vacuum pans until sugar crystals grow, and a centrifuge spins out crystals, leaving molasses.

Totals match at 125 t. Water is the biggest stream, so the mill is mostly a machine for boiling water away: 78 t per 100 t of cane. At 5,000 t of cane a day, a typical size, that is 520 t of sugar, 1,500 t of bagasse, 175 t of molasses and 3,900 t of water boiled off. Sugar recovery of 10.4 per cent is near what Indian mills achieve; India made about 25.7 million tonnes of sugar in 2024-25 (ISMA, to mid-May 2025).

The balance also shows where money leaks: one point of recovery on 5,000 t a day is 50 t of sugar, about Rs 20 lakh at an assumed Rs 40,000 per tonne. Mill chemists therefore test bagasse, cake and molasses every shift.

Data Estimate 5: mass balance of a sugar mill on a basis of 100 t of cane (all in tonnes)
StreamTotalFibreDissolved solidsWater
IN: cane100.014.514.571.0
IN: imbibition water25.00025.0
IN total125.014.514.596.0
OUT: bagasse30.014.51.014.5
OUT: filter cake3.000.32.7
OUT: water boiled off in evaporators and pans78.10078.1
OUT: sugar10.4010.40
OUT: molasses (80 per cent solids)3.502.80.7
OUT total125.014.514.596.0

Evaporators remove 70.0 t of water to make 22.0 t of 60 per cent syrup from 92 t of clarified juice; the pans remove a further 8.1 t. Sugar is taken as dry. Lime and the soil that leave in the filter cake are not counted, so the cake here is only its juice. The composition of cane and the split of losses are assumed round values. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (mass balances across a boundary; idea source only, the sugar-mill balance is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)
  • Press release reported by Business Today, 'India's sugar production reaches 257.44 lakh tonnes as of May 15' (16 May 2025, read November 2026), citing the Indian Sugar and Bio-energy Manufacturers Association · national output 2024-25; https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy/story/indias-sugar-production-reaches-25744-lakh-tonnes-as-of-may-15-positive-outlook-for-2025-26-476600-2025-05-16

3.4 An energy balance does the same for heat, and the sugar mill's own bagasse covers its steam with some left over

The energy balance is the mass balance's twin: at steady state, energy in equals energy out, with heat moved by temperature change (mass x specific heat x temperature rise), by phase change (mass x latent heat) and by the reaction itself. In the sugar mill the chief heat use is evaporating 70 t of water per 100 t of cane, and that is where the energy balance starts.

Boiling a kilogram of water needs about 2.26 MJ, so a single evaporator makes about 1 kg of vapour per kilogram of steam. Mills use a train of four or five evaporators called effects; each effect's vapour heats the next, which is held at a lower pressure so that it boils at a lower temperature. A train of five gives roughly 3.5 kg of evaporation for each kilogram of fresh steam (an assumed economy). The estimate below turns this into a fuel budget. About 40 t of steam is needed per 100 t of cane, and the bagasse contains more heat than that.

Steam is raised at high pressure, passed through a turbine that runs the mill and a generator, and the exhaust steam is the process steam (Bagasse and black-liquor cogeneration; module 6, Heat and thermodynamics, explained why this saves fuel). Mills with efficient boilers sell power to the grid, which raises the value of every tonne of cane. The trade-off: bagasse is also a raw material for paper and board, and burning it in a poor boiler wastes it.

Data Estimate 6: steam and bagasse energy for 100 t of cane
StepWorkingResult
Water to evaporate in the evaporatorsfrom the mass balance70 t
Evaporator economy (assumed)5 effects3.5 t evaporated per t of steam
Live steam for the evaporators70 / 3.520 t
Steam for heaters, pans and other uses (assumed)20 t
Total steam40 t, or 40 per cent on cane
Heat added in the boiler40 t x 2.8 GJ per t (high-pressure steam from feed water)112 GJ
Fuel needed at 70 per cent boiler efficiency112 / 0.70160 GJ
Heat in 30 t of bagasse30 t x 7.5 GJ per t (half-wet bagasse, lower heating value)225 GJ
Share of bagasse burned for steam160 / 22571 per cent
Surplus225 - 160 = 65 GJabout 9 t of bagasse per 100 t of cane

Steam use, economy and bagasse heating value are typical figures, assumed round; a mill rarely matches them exactly. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (energy balances; idea source only, the sugar-mill case is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 7, 'Heat and Phase Transitions' (latent heat, boiling)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterGas Natural gasNaCl SaltCem CementCaO LimeSu SugarH2 HydrogenCO2 Carbon dioxideNH3 AmmoniaeF Low-carbon hydrogen and e-fuelsElz ElectrolysersBag Bagasse and black-liquor cogenerationEl Electricity

Check your understanding

In the ammonia loop the reactor converts 25 per cent of what enters on each pass. For each kilomole of fresh feed, how much gas circulates in the recycle?

The reactor inlet is the fresh feed divided by 0.25, which is 4 kmol. Of this, 1 kmol is fresh, so 3 kmol are recycled.

Why does raising the pressure help the ammonia reaction at equilibrium?

Le Chatelier's rule: squeezing the mixture shifts it toward the smaller number of molecules. A catalyst or faster motion does not shift the equilibrium.

In the sugar-mill balance, water boiled away is 78 t per 100 t of cane. What does this tell the mill's designer?

Latent heat of about 2.26 MJ per kg of water dominates the mill's energy needs, which is why multiple-effect evaporators are used.
← Part 2: Reactions: energy, rate and catalystsMark read · Part 4: Unit operations and scale-up →