Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Matter at the atomic scale: bonds, reactions and process engineering: Unit operations and scale-up

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 10: Matter at the atomic scale: bonds, reactions and process engineering Part 4 of 5

Unit operations and scale-up

Very different plants turn out to be built from the same short list of steps: reactors, separators, heat exchangers and pumps. This part sorts those steps, works through the heat duty of a distillation column and the energy floor of a membrane, and then explains why a recipe that works in a 1-litre flask can fail in a 10-cubic-metre vessel.

4.1 A plant is a chain of unit operations, with a reactor in the middle and most of the equipment around it

Walk through a fertiliser factory, a dairy and a refinery and you meet the same hardware: tanks, columns, heat exchangers and pumps. A step that recurs like this is a unit operation. Learn how drying works once, and the urea prill tower, the tea dryer and the detergent spray dryer become variations on it.

The reactor is the heart, and three layouts cover most cases. A batch reactor is a stirred tank filled, run and emptied. It is flexible, so it suits medicines and small volumes, but loses time on filling and cleaning. A continuous stirred tank receives feed and sheds product all the time. Its contents are uniform and easy to control, and volume is flow x residence time: 30 minutes at 20 m3 per hour needs 10 m3. A tube or packed bed, as in the ammonia converter or catalytic converter, lets reactants travel along its length, which gives the most conversion per volume. The trade-off is flexibility for output per rupee of equipment: batch is cheap to build and costly to run for large volumes; continuous is costly to build and cheap to run.

Around the reactor lie the steps that prepare feed (crushing, heating, compressing), those that separate product from by-products and unreacted feed, and the utilities that serve them all: steam, cooling water, electricity and air. In many plants the reactor is a minority of the capital cost, and separation and heat exchange take the larger share. The tree lists the main groups.

Value chain The main unit operations
  • Unit operations
    • Reaction turns feed into product
      • Batch tank
      • Continuous stirred tank
      • Tube or packed catalyst bed
    • Separation splits a mixture
      • Distillation (by boiling point)
      • Filtration (by particle size)
      • Crystallisation (by solubility)
      • Membranes (by molecular size and pressure)
    • Moving energy and material
      • Heat exchangers and boilers
      • Pumps and compressors
    • Changing form
      • Crushing and grinding
      • Drying
      • Mixing
Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (unit operations as a concept; the grouping is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)

4.2 Distillation separates liquids by boiling point, and its heat duty is the price of every unit of reflux

Fermented sugarcane wash is mostly water with about 8 per cent ethanol by weight. Heat it and the vapour that rises is richer in ethanol than the liquid, because ethanol boils at 78.4 degrees C and water at 100 degrees C. Condense that vapour and you have a stronger liquid. Repeat the step and it gets stronger again. A distillation column does the repetition inside one tall shell: trays or packing make vapour rising and liquid falling meet many times, and each meeting is one stage (see Distillation and the science node Vapour-liquid equilibrium (Raoult's law)).

Two features set the cost. The first is reflux. Some of the liquid condensed at the top is sent back down the column instead of being drawn off. The returned liquid lets the same column reach a higher purity, or a shorter column reach the same purity, but every kilogram of it has to be boiled again. The trade-off is a taller column against a bigger boiler. The second is the azeotrope: ethanol and water form a mixture at 95.6 per cent ethanol by weight that boils as a single substance, so ordinary distillation cannot pass it. Fuel ethanol is dried further with molecular sieves (see Bioethanol).

The table sizes the heat for a modest distillery. It is a floor: the stripping part of the column and heating the feed need more. Even so, the figure shows the scale of the energy bill, about 14 per cent of the heat content of the ethanol, and the cooling water that the condenser needs. Heat from one column's top vapour can boil another (see Heat exchangers and pinch integration).

Data Estimate 7: heat duty of an ethanol rectifying column fed with 10 t an hour of wash
StepWorkingResult
Ethanol in the wash10 t per hour x 8 per cent0.80 t per hour
Product at 95 per cent by weight (all ethanol recovered)0.80 / 0.950.84 t per hour, about 1,050 litres
Reflux ratio (assumed)3 parts returned per 1 part drawn off3
Vapour rising to the condenser(3 + 1) x 0.843.37 t per hour
Latent heat of the vapour0.95 x 0.84 + 0.05 x 2.26 MJ per kg0.91 MJ per kg
Condenser duty, equal to the reboiling needed3,370 kg x 0.91 MJ per kg3.07 GJ per hour, 850 kW
Steam at 2.16 MJ per kg latent heat3,070 / 2.16about 1.4 t per hour, or 1.4 kg per litre of ethanol
Cooling water, 10 K rise3,070,000 kJ / (4.186 kJ per kg per K x 10 K)about 73 t per hour
Heat as a share of the ethanol's fuel value3.07 / (0.80 t x 26.8 GJ per t = 21.4 GJ)14 per cent

A floor, not a design: the beer column, feed preheating and losses add to it. Reflux ratio, wash strength and full recovery are assumed round values. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (distillation as the standard separation in refineries; idea source only, the ethanol case is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)

4.3 Filtration, crystallisation and membranes separate by size, solubility and pressure, and each has an energy floor

Not every mixture needs boiling. Filtration works on particles. The sugar mill passes limed juice through rotary vacuum filters, and a water works passes river water through sand beds (Sand filtration of drinking water); the energy cost is that of pumping against the cake. Crystallisation works on solubility. Cool a concentrated solution, or boil off water, and it holds more sugar than it can keep; crystals grow on seeds. Slow growth gives pure crystals that leave impurities in the liquid, so sugar pans run gently and the molasses keeps 2.8 t of solids in Part 3's balance.

Membranes work on size and pressure. In reverse osmosis a thin polymer film lets water through and holds salt back. Left alone, water flows from the fresh side to the salt side; to reverse it the pump must exceed the osmotic pressure. Seawater has about 35 g of salt per litre, which is 0.6 mol of NaCl, or 1.2 mol of dissolved ions. At 300 K the osmotic pressure is roughly 1.2 x 0.0831 x 300 = 30 bar. Pushing one cubic metre of water through at 30 bar takes 3 MJ, or 0.83 kWh. That is the floor.

A modern seawater plant uses about 3 to 4 kWh per cubic metre because pumps and membranes are not perfect and the feed must be pushed at 55 to 70 bar, yet it is still tiny next to boiling the same water, which needs 2.26 GJ or 630 kWh of heat per cubic metre if no heat is reused. Hence most new desalination uses membranes (see Reverse osmosis desalination and Osmosis). The cost is a membrane that fouls and ages, and a pre-treatment plant to protect it.

Data Estimate 8: the energy floor of making fresh water from seawater
StepWorkingResult
Dissolved ions in seawater35 g per litre / 58.4 g per mol = 0.60 mol; two ions each1.2 mol per litre
Osmotic pressure at 300 K1.2 mol per litre x 0.0831 litre bar per mol per K x 300 Kabout 30 bar
Minimum work per cubic metre30 bar = 3 x 10^6 Pa x 1 m33 MJ = 0.83 kWh
Typical modern plant (assumed range)pumps at 55 to 70 bar, partial energy recovery3 to 4 kWh per m3
A 100 million litre-a-day plant100,000 m3 x 3.5 kWh350 MWh a day, about 15 MW
Boiling the same water, no heat reuse2.26 GJ per t / 3.6 GJ per MWh630 kWh of heat per m3
Boiling against the pumped route630 / 3.5about 180 times more energy

The 100 million litre-a-day size is that of the first Nemmeli seawater plant near Chennai. The 3 to 4 kWh range is a typical industry figure, assumed. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (separation processes as idea source; the osmotic estimate is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)

4.4 Scale-up is hard because volume grows faster than surface, so the heat made in a vessel cannot leave through its walls

A cook who doubles a recipe finds the pot slower to heat and to cool. A reaction scaled from flask to plant has the same trouble with bigger consequences. Thinking in estimates showed that area grows as length squared and volume as length cubed. For a reactor, heat is made throughout the volume but must leave through the wall, so the ratio of surface to volume falls as the vessel grows.

The table sets a 1-litre flask against a 10 m3 jacketed tank, with a reaction that gives off 100 kW per cubic metre, a moderate rate. In the flask the wall passes 2 kW per square metre, and a gentle 5 K difference between liquid and cooling water is enough. In the tank each square metre of wall must pass 50 kW, and with the same wall performance the liquid would need to run 125 K hotter than the coolant. Cooling water at 30 degrees C would mean a reactor at 155 degrees C or more, which is a different reaction with different products, and a pressure vessel, not a tank.

Engineers answer in four ways. They add surface inside, with coils and plates. They pump the contents through an outside heat exchanger. They feed one reactant slowly (semi-batch), so heat is made at the rate it can be taken away. Or they use many small channels, a tube bundle or a microreactor, so surface to volume stays high and the design grows by numbering up and not by growing large. Scale-up goes in steps (bench, pilot, demonstration, plant) because mixing, heat and side reactions each change with size at their own rate.

Data Estimate 9: heat removal in a lab flask and in a plant tank
Quantity1 litre flask (sphere)10 m3 jacketed tank (2 m across, 3.2 m liquid depth)Ratio
Volume0.001 m310 m310,000
Wall area0.048 m2 (diameter 0.124 m)20 m2 (pi x 2 x 3.2)about 400
Surface to volume48 per m2 per m1 to 24
Heat released at 100 kW per m30.1 kW1,000 kW10,000
Heat through each square metre2.1 kW per m250 kW per m224 times
Temperature gap needed, wall coefficient 400 W per m2 per K (assumed)5 K125 K24 times

The heat release rate and wall coefficient are assumed round values. Same reaction, same chemistry; only the size changes. Values in the right-hand column are calculated from the inputs shown.

Source: Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013), ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; the scale-up estimate is the author's own)
  • Kosky et al., Exploring Engineering (Academic Press, 2013) · ch. 6, 'Chemical Engineering' (idea source only; all wording, numbers and examples are the author's own)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterNaCl SaltSu SugarTea TeaNH3 AmmoniaUr UreaC2H4 EthyleneEO Ethylene oxideEtOH BioethanolHX Heat exchangers and pinch integrationEl Electricity

Check your understanding

Why does raising the reflux ratio in a distillation column cost more energy?

Every kilogram sent back down must be turned to vapour again, so the boiler and condenser duty rise together with the reflux ratio, while purity improves.

Seawater has an osmotic pressure of about 30 bar. A reverse osmosis plant must therefore:

The applied pressure must beat the osmotic pressure. The work for 1 m3 at 30 bar is 3 MJ, about 0.83 kWh, and real plants use several times more.

A reaction that is easy to cool in a 1-litre flask overheats in a 10 m3 tank because:

Heat is made in the volume but removed through the wall. Surface to volume fell from 48 to 2 per metre, so each square metre of wall must carry 24 times more heat.
← Part 3: Equilibrium, recycle and the balances that size a plantMark read · Part 5: Cement, steel and polymer plants, and process safety →