Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Gravity, projectiles and orbits: One pull for apples and the Moon: Newton's law and how we know it

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 4: Gravity, projectiles and orbits Part 1 of 6

One pull for apples and the Moon: Newton's law and how we know it

A dropped spoon and the Moon in the sky look like different things. Newton's claim, published in the Principia of 1687, was that one pull governs both. This part follows the claim: the argument that the Moon is falling, the law that results, the way the pull weakens with distance, and the 1798 experiment that weighed the Earth. Each step uses ideas from 'Motion and force'.

1.1 The Moon is falling, and its fall matches the apple's after a correction for distance

Newton asked a bolder question: does the same pull reach as far as the Moon? If it does, the Moon cannot be a body drifting freely. A body moving freely goes in a straight line (the first law, from 'Motion and force'). The Moon curves around the Earth every 27.3 days, so something must be pulling it sideways off its straight path, towards the Earth. That pull is what Newton called gravity.

He then tested the idea with arithmetic. The Moon is about 60 times as far from the Earth's centre as we are on the surface. If the pull weakens as the square of the distance, then at the Moon's distance it should be 60 x 60, or about 3,600 times weaker than the 9.8 m/s² we feel. That predicts an acceleration of about 0.0027 m/s².

Now compute the acceleration the Moon actually has, from its orbit alone. A body going round a circle of radius r once in time T has an inward acceleration of 4 x pi² x r / T². With r = 384,400 km and T = 27.32 days, this gives 0.0027 m/s². The two numbers agree to about one per cent (calculated). Nothing was adjusted to make them agree.

The agreement is the evidence. It says that the force which makes a stone fall and the force which keeps the Moon in orbit are the same force, obeying the same weakening rule.

Data Worked estimate: does the Moon fall like the apple?
StepWorkingResult
Distance of Moon in Earth radii384,400 km / 6,371 kmabout 60.3
Weakening of pull if inverse-square60.3 x 60.3about 3,640 times
Predicted acceleration at the Moon9.82 / 3,640about 0.0027 m/s²
Moon's period27.32 days x 86,400 s2.36 million s
Acceleration from the orbit itself4 x 9.87 x 3.844 x 10^8 m / (2.36 x 10^6)²about 0.0027 m/s²
Distance the Moon falls from a straight line each secondhalf x 0.0027 x 1 s x 1 sabout 1.4 mm

Moon distance, radius and period from the NASA fact sheets; the working is calculated.

Source: NASA NSSDCA, Moon Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/moonfact.html (mass 0.07346 x 10^24 kg; radius 1737.4 km; gravity 1.62 m/s²; escape 2.38 km/s; distance 0.3844 million km; period 27.3217 days)

1.2 Every mass pulls every other mass, and the force grows with both masses

Newton's law of universal gravitation says: any two bodies attract each other with a force proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between their centres. In words with symbols: force = G x mass 1 x mass 2 / distance². The letter G is a fixed number for the whole universe, the next section's subject.

Why both masses? Take the weight of an apple. Doubling the apple's mass doubles the pull on it, which is why the force is proportional to its mass. But the Earth is pulled by the apple with an equal and opposite force (the third law, from 'Motion and force'). That force must also be proportional to the Earth's mass if the rule is to look the same from either side. A rule that treats the two bodies alike must therefore contain the product of the masses.

The law also accounts for the result in 'Motion and force' that heavy and light bodies fall together: the pull grows with a body's mass exactly as its inertia does, so the mass cancels.

The pull is mutual, and it is the same size on both bodies. A 0.1 kg apple and the Earth pull each other with about 1 newton. The apple accelerates at 9.8 m/s². The Earth, with a mass 6 x 10^24 kg, accelerates at about 10^-25 m/s². The Earth does move towards the apple, by an amount that no instrument could detect.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
  • NASA NSSDCA, Earth Fact Sheet · web

1.3 Gravity weakens with the square of distance because its pull spreads over a sphere

'How science knows' met the inverse-square rule for light, which thins out because it spreads over a sphere whose area grows as the radius squared. Gravity obeys the same rule. One way to picture it is as a fixed number of field lines running out from the Earth in every direction. At twice the distance from the centre the same lines pierce a sphere with four times the surface, so each square metre gets a quarter as many, and the pull per kilogram is a quarter. Because space has three dimensions, the exponent is two.

The practical result is that the pull is never zero but drops fast. Climb to the top of Mount Everest, a height of 8.8 km above sea level, and you are only 0.14 per cent further from the Earth's centre. The pull falls by about 0.28 per cent. You do not float up there; gravity has barely changed. Even at the height of the International Space Station, about 400 km, the pull is still about 88 per cent of its surface value.

The table gives the pull at several distances, in Earth radii from the centre.

Data How the pull changes with distance (relative to the surface)
Distance from Earth's centreWorkingPull compared with the surfaceAcceleration
1 Earth radius (surface, 6,371 km)1 / 1²19.82 m/s²
2 Earth radii (a height of 6,371 km)1 / 2²one quarter2.5 m/s²
3 Earth radii1 / 3²one ninth1.1 m/s²
1.06 radii (ISS, about 400 km up)(6,371 / 6,771)²about 0.88about 8.7 m/s²
6.6 radii (geostationary, 35,786 km up)(6,371 / 42,164)²about 0.023about 0.22 m/s²
60.3 radii (the Moon)1 / 60.3²about 0.00027about 0.0027 m/s²

Calculated from g = 9.82 m/s² at the surface and the radii given.

Source: NASA NSSDCA, Earth Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html (mass 5.9722 x 10^24 kg; mean radius 6371 km; escape velocity 11.186 km/s)
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
  • NASA NSSDCA, Earth Fact Sheet · web

1.4 Cavendish weighed the Earth in 1798 by measuring a pull between two lead balls

The law needs the number G. Newton could not give it. Astronomers could find ratios (the Sun is about a third of a million times the Earth's mass) but not the mass in kilograms, because that needs an independent measurement of a gravitational pull between bodies of known mass.

In 1798 Henry Cavendish did it in London. He used a torsion balance, adapted from a design by John Michell: a light rod hung from a thin wire, with a small lead ball at each end. Two large lead balls, much heavier, were brought near the small ones. Each pair attracted. The rod twisted a little, and the wire twisted back. From the time the rod took to swing back and forth, and the stiffness of the wire, Cavendish worked out the pull. It was about one fifty-millionth of the weight of the lead balls, so small that air currents had to be kept out of the room.

With G in hand, the Earth's mass follows. At the surface, the pull on a mass m is m x g, and the law says it also equals G x m x Earth mass / radius². Cancel m and solve: Earth's mass = g x radius² / G. The result is about 6 x 10^24 kg, and the average density of the Earth is about 5,500 kg/m³, five and a half times water. Surface rock is only about half that, so the core must be dense. Cavendish's own density was within about one per cent of today's.

G is still a hard number to measure. Its accepted value is 6.674 x 10^-11 in SI units, with an uncertainty of about one part in 50,000, much worse than for most constants. The pull is so weak that any stray mass or vibration spoils the result. Two people of 70 kg standing 1 metre apart pull on each other with about 3 x 10^-7 N, about the weight of 0.03 milligrams (calculated).

Data Worked estimate: the mass and density of the Earth
StepWorkingResult
Radius squared(6.371 x 10^6 m)²4.06 x 10^13 m²
g x radius²9.82 x 4.06 x 10^133.99 x 10^14
Mass = g x radius² / G3.99 x 10^14 / 6.674 x 10^-115.97 x 10^24 kg
Volume4/3 x 3.14 x (6.371 x 10^6)³1.08 x 10^21 m³
Mean density5.97 x 10^24 / 1.08 x 10^21about 5,500 kg/m³

Compare the NASA value of 5.9722 x 10^24 kg.

Source: NASA NSSDCA, Earth Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html (mass 5.9722 x 10^24 kg; mean radius 6371 km; escape velocity 11.186 km/s)

See it in the table

H₂O Water

Check your understanding

The Moon is about 60 times as far from the Earth's centre as the Earth's surface is. By what factor is gravity weaker there, if gravity follows an inverse-square law?

The pull falls as 1 / distance². With 60 times the distance, the pull is 60 x 60 = 3,600 times weaker. Newton found this matched the Moon's measured acceleration.

Why does a heavier body not fall faster than a lighter one under gravity alone?

Force = G x mass x Earth mass / d². Acceleration = force / mass. The body's own mass appears in both and cancels, leaving the same acceleration for all.

A 0.1 kg apple and the Earth pull on each other. Which statement is correct?

Newton's third law gives equal and opposite forces. Acceleration = force / mass, so the small mass accelerates a great deal and the large mass hardly at all.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: Weight, weightlessness and the way gravity feels →