Gravity, projectiles and orbits: Projectiles: two independent motions make a curve
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 4: Gravity, projectiles and orbits Part 4 of 6Projectiles: two independent motions make a curve
A thrown ball follows a curve, and the curve has a simple recipe: a steady sideways drift plus a fall that speeds up. Galileo, in 'Motion and force', saw that the two do not interfere. This part builds the path of a projectile, finds how angle and speed set height and range, and then adds air, which spoils the neat curve for fast, light objects.
4.1 A projectile moves sideways at steady speed while it falls with steady acceleration
Stand on a roof and throw a ball horizontally. Once it leaves your hand, only gravity (and later air) acts on it. Gravity pulls straight down, so it changes only the downward part of the velocity. The sideways part has no force on it, and by the first law it stays the same. The two parts of the motion, horizontal and vertical, can be treated one at a time and put together afterwards, as vectors are in 'Motion and force'.
The horizontal motion is steady. In every second the ball covers the same distance sideways. The vertical motion is free fall: the downward velocity grows by 9.8 m/s each second, and the distance fallen grows as half x g x time². The path is a parabola, the same curve for any projectile in a vacuum, drawn at different speeds and angles.
A consequence is surprising at first: a ball thrown horizontally and a ball dropped from the same height reach the ground at the same moment. The sideways speed does not change the time taken to fall. The thrown one simply lands farther away.
The time of fall depends only on the height: t = square root of (2 x height / g). For 20 m, that is 2.0 seconds. The range is then the horizontal speed times that time.
| Quantity | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Fall time | square root of (2 x 20 m / 9.8 m/s²) | 2.0 s |
| Distance fallen after 1 s | half x 9.8 m/s² x (1 s)² | 4.9 m |
| Sideways distance after 1 s | 15 m/s x 1 s | 15 m |
| Range at landing | 15 m/s x 2.02 s | about 30 m |
| Downward speed at landing | 9.8 m/s² x 2.02 s | about 20 m/s |
| Speed at landing | square root of (15² + 19.8²) m/s | about 25 m/s, 53 degrees below horizontal |
All values calculated with g = 9.8 m/s², air ignored.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 5, 'Gravity'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
4.2 Launch angle trades height against range, and 45 degrees gives the farthest throw in a vacuum
Now throw the ball at an angle. Split the launch speed v into a sideways part, v x cos(angle), and an upward part, v x sin(angle). Going up, gravity slows the upward part by 9.8 m/s each second until it is zero at the top of the path; coming down, it speeds up again. The up-and-down motion is symmetrical: the time up equals the time down, so the total time in the air is 2 x v x sin(angle) / g.
The range is the sideways speed times that time, which works out as v² x sin(2 x angle) / g. Because sin(2 x angle) is largest when the angle is 45 degrees, a throw at 45 degrees goes farthest. Two angles that add to 90 degrees, such as 30 and 60, give the same range, because sin(60) = sin(120). The lower throw is quick and flat; the higher is slow and lofty.
The maximum height is (v x sin(angle))² / (2 x g). At 45 degrees the height is a quarter of the range. At steeper angles the height rises while the range falls, and a throw straight up has no range at all. At the top of any path the upward speed is zero, so the ball moves at its sideways speed alone: that is the slowest point of the flight.
On the airless Moon, with g = 1.62 m/s², every range and height grows by 9.8 / 1.62, about 6 (calculated): the 45 degree throw at 30 m/s would carry about 555 m.
| Angle | Range: v² x sin(2 x angle) / g | Peak height: (v x sin(angle))² / (2g) | Time in air: 2 v sin(angle) / g |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 degrees | 900 x 0.50 / 9.8 = 46 m | 3.1 m | 1.6 s |
| 30 degrees | 900 x 0.87 / 9.8 = 80 m | 11.5 m | 3.1 s |
| 45 degrees | 900 x 1.00 / 9.8 = 92 m | 23.0 m | 4.3 s |
| 60 degrees | 900 x 0.87 / 9.8 = 80 m | 34.4 m | 5.3 s |
| 75 degrees | 900 x 0.50 / 9.8 = 46 m | 42.8 m | 5.9 s |
All values calculated. On the Moon (g = 1.62 m/s²) every range, height and time is multiplied by 6.05.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 5, 'Gravity'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
- NASA NSSDCA, Moon Fact Sheet · web
4.3 Air drag shortens the path and makes it steeper on the way down
The tidy parabola assumes no air. Real balls meet drag, a force opposite to the motion that grows with the square of the speed (the same rule as in the terminal speed of 'Motion and force'). The drag force is about half x air density x drag coefficient x frontal area x speed². For a cricket ball of radius 3.6 cm moving at 30 m/s, with air density 1.2 kg/m³ and an assumed drag coefficient of 0.4, drag is about 0.9 N. The ball's weight is 0.16 kg x 9.8 = 1.6 N. So drag at 30 m/s is more than half the weight: the effect is large. At 10 m/s, drag falls by a factor of nine to 0.1 N, and the vacuum picture is a fair approximation.
Drag acts opposite to the velocity at every moment, so it slows the sideways part as well as the upward part. The consequences are definite. The ball rises less and travels less far. It is slower at the top than it would be. The path is no longer symmetric: the descent is steeper than the ascent. The best angle for range falls below 45 degrees, and the more drag matters, the lower it goes.
This is one reason a fielder's throw is flatter than the textbook angle.
| Speed | Working: 0.5 x 1.2 x 0.4 x area x speed² | Drag | Drag / weight (1.57 N) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 m/s | 0.24 x 0.0041 m² x 100 | 0.10 N | 6 per cent |
| 20 m/s | 0.24 x 0.0041 x 400 | 0.39 N | 25 per cent |
| 30 m/s | 0.24 x 0.0041 x 900 | 0.88 N | 56 per cent |
| 40 m/s | 0.24 x 0.0041 x 1,600 | 1.6 N | 100 per cent |
Calculated. Frontal area = 3.14 x (0.036 m)² = 0.0041 m². Mass taken as 0.16 kg, so weight 1.57 N. Drag coefficient 0.4 is an assumption.
Source: Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013), ch. 5, 'Gravity'- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
Check your understanding
A ball is dropped from a balcony at the same moment as a second ball is thrown horizontally from the same height. Which reaches the ground first, if air is ignored?
Vertical motion is independent of horizontal motion. Both start with zero downward velocity and fall with the same acceleration, so they take the same time.For a ball thrown at fixed speed in a vacuum, which pair of launch angles give the same range?
Range depends on sin(2 x angle). Angles adding to 90 degrees have the same value of that sine, so 30 and 60, or 20 and 70, give equal ranges. Only 30 and 60 appear here.Why does air drag lower the best throwing angle below 45 degrees?
Drag removes speed continuously. Less time aloft means less speed lost, so a flatter throw is favoured once drag matters.