Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Gravity, projectiles and orbits: Satellites and orbits: falling around the Earth

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 4: Gravity, projectiles and orbits Part 5 of 6

Satellites and orbits: falling around the Earth

A satellite is a projectile that moves so fast that the ground curves away beneath it as quickly as it falls. This part works out that speed, the orbits ISRO uses and why, Kepler's three laws and how Mangalyaan obeyed them, and the speed needed to leave a planet altogether. The rocket's job, to supply these speeds, is touched on only as history.

5.1 A satellite is a projectile that keeps missing the ground

Newton pictured a cannon on a very high mountain. Fire a ball horizontally and it lands some way off. Fire it faster and it lands further, but the Earth is round, so the ground curves away. At some speed the ball falls just as fast as the ground curves away below it. It then never lands. Each second it falls about 4.9 metres below its straight path, and the surface curves away by the same amount.

The speed follows from the turning rule in 'Motion and force': a body moving at speed v round a circle of radius r needs an inward acceleration of v² / r. Skimming the surface, gravity supplies g, so v = square root of (g x R) = square root of (9.82 m/s² x 6.371 x 10^6 m) = 7.9 km/s (calculated), about 28,500 km/h. Geometry gives a cross-check. The ground falls below a level line by distance² / (2R), so it falls 4.9 m over square root of (2 x 6.371 x 10^6 m x 4.9 m) = 7.9 km (calculated). A body covering that in one second keeps pace with the curve.

That speed would, in a vacuum and at ground level, give an orbit of about 84 minutes. In practice, air and mountains prevent it, so real satellites are placed higher. At 400 km, the speed is a little lower, 7.67 km/s, and the period is 92 minutes. The International Space Station goes round the Earth about 15.6 times a day (calculated).

Orbiting is falling. The satellite is under gravity alone, and its sideways speed keeps turning the direction of the fall, so the path is a circle instead of a drop.

Reaching that speed is the rocket's job. A rocket throws gas backwards and is pushed forwards in return (the third law of 'Motion and force', and the momentum balance behind the Rocket equation node), so it needs no air to push on. A launch climbs steeply only to clear the dense lower air, then tips over, because most of the work goes into sideways speed rather than height. The idea is old: Chinese armies used rocket arrows by 1232, Konstantin Tsiolkovsky argued in 1903 for liquid propellants, Robert Goddard flew the first liquid-propellant rocket on 16 March 1926, and Sputnik became the first artificial satellite on 4 October 1957. India's first sounding rocket rose from Thumba on 21 November 1963, and its SLV-3 put the Rohini satellite into orbit on 18 July 1980.

Data Worked estimate: circular orbit speed and period
OrbitRadius from Earth's centreSpeed: square root of (GM / r)Period: 2 x pi x r / v
Just above the ground6,371 km7.91 km/s84 min
International Space Station (about 400 km)6,771 km7.67 km/s92 min
PSLV-C37 orbit of 15 February 2017 (506 km)6,877 km7.61 km/s95 min
Geostationary (35,786 km)42,164 km3.07 km/s23 h 56 min
The Moon384,400 km1.02 km/s27.5 days (observed 27.3)

All values calculated with G x Earth mass = 3.986 x 10^14 m³/s². Higher orbits are slower and have longer periods. The Moon row ignores the Moon's own mass, which shortens the real period slightly.

Source: NASA NSSDCA, Earth Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html (mass 5.9722 x 10^24 kg; mean radius 6371 km; escape velocity 11.186 km/s)

5.2 Higher orbits move slower and take longer, and each ISRO orbit is chosen for a job

Look at the table above. The higher the orbit, the lower the speed, which can seem backwards. The reason is that gravity is weaker higher up, so less sideways speed is needed to keep falling around. The period grows even faster, because the path is longer too.

Two families of orbit cover most of India's Earth-observing and communication satellites. Low orbits, at about 400 to 800 km, give sharp images and quick coverage. On 15 February 2017 PSLV-C37 placed 104 satellites into an orbit of 506 km, tilted 97.46 degrees to the equator, in a single flight, which was a record. A tilt near 98 degrees at this height is a 'sun-synchronous' orbit: the orbit's plane turns slowly (because the Earth's equator bulges) at just the rate that keeps the satellite passing over any given place at the same local solar time each day. Photos of a field are then taken in the same lighting each time, so change is easy to see.

In the geostationary orbit, 35,786 km up, the period is 23 hours 56 minutes, matching one turn of the Earth. A satellite over the equator in this orbit stays above one point of the ground. Communication and weather satellites, such as INSAT and GSAT, use it. A fixed dish can then point at the satellite without tracking. The price is distance: a signal up and down travels about 72,000 km, which takes about a quarter of a second, a delay noticeable in a phone call.

5.3 Kepler's three laws describe every orbit, and Newton's gravity explains why they hold

Before Newton, Kepler had found patterns in the data of Tycho Brahe, who died in 1601. In 1609 Kepler published two laws and in 1619 a third.

First law: each planet moves in an ellipse with the Sun at one focus. An ellipse is a closed oval in which the distances from any point on it to two fixed points, the foci, always add to the same total. Bring the foci together and it becomes a circle. A satellite given a little more than circular speed overshoots the circle and swings out on an ellipse, slowing as it climbs and speeding up as it falls back. The Earth's orbit is nearly circular; many comets follow long, thin ellipses.

Second law: a line from the Sun to a planet sweeps out equal areas in equal times. Where the planet is close to the Sun, the line is short, so to sweep the same area the planet must move faster. It speeds up when near and slows down when far. This follows from conservation of angular momentum, the turning cousin of the conservation laws in 'Momentum and energy': gravity pulls along the line to the Sun and gives no twist, so the quantity (mass x speed x distance) stays fixed. If the distance is halved, the speed doubles.

Third law: the square of the orbital period is proportional to the cube of the average distance. Newton's gravity gives this directly: for a circle, v² = GM / r and T = 2 x pi x r / v, so T² = 4 x pi² x r³ / (GM).

A check across scales: a satellite just above the ground has an 84-minute period at 1 Earth radius. The Moon is 60.3 radii away, so its period should be 84 minutes x 60.3^1.5 = 84 x 468 = 39,300 minutes, or 27.3 days (calculated). The actual period is 27.3 days. One law ties a satellite and the Moon together.

Data Kepler's laws and what lies behind them
LawStatementWhy, in Newton's terms
First (1609)Orbits are ellipses with the Sun at a focusA pull that falls as 1 / distance² produces closed ellipses
Second (1609)Equal areas in equal timesGravity pulls along the line to the Sun, so angular momentum is conserved
Third (1619)Period² is proportional to distance³Circular speed v² = GM / r combined with T = 2 x pi x r / v
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Understanding Kepler's laws of planetary motion, https://www.britannica.com/story/understanding-keplers-laws-of-planetary-motion (first two laws 1609, third 1619; Tycho Brahe died 1601)

5.4 Mangalyaan and Chandrayaan travelled on ellipses, and the speed that breaks free is escape speed

Elliptical orbits are not a nuisance; they are the way spacecraft reach other worlds. India's Mars Orbiter Mission, Mangalyaan, was launched by a PSLV-XL on 5 November 2013. It first circled the Earth in a widening ellipse, then on 1 December 2013 fired its engine near the low point of that ellipse to leave for Mars. It entered orbit around Mars on 24 September 2014. The final orbit was an ellipse: nearest point 421.7 km above Mars, farthest 76,993.6 km, period 72 hours 51 minutes.

Try the third law on it. The average distance from Mars's centre is half of (421.7 + 76,993.6) km plus Mars's radius (3,389.5 km), about 42,100 km. With Mars's value of G x mass at 4.28 x 10^13 m³/s², the period is 2 x pi x square root of (a³ / GM) = 2.62 x 10^5 s, or 72.8 hours. The published figure of 72.9 hours is reproduced (calculated). By the second law, the speed at the nearest point exceeds the speed at the farthest by the ratio of distances from the centre: (76,993.6 + 3,389.5) / (421.7 + 3,389.5) = 21.

Chandrayaan-3 did something similar around the Earth. After its launch on 14 July 2023 it rose through ellipses, such as 41,762 km by 173 km on 15 July, until the Moon caught it on 5 August and it landed on 23 August 2023. Chandrayaan-1, launched on 22 October 2008, settled into a polar orbit about 100 km above the Moon, and on 14 November 2008 released its Moon Impact Probe, which shed its sideways speed and fell to the surface near the south pole.

To leave a planet for good, a body must have enough kinetic energy to climb out of the planet's gravitational well. Setting kinetic energy equal to the energy needed gives the escape speed: v = square root of (2 x G x M / r), which is 1.41 times the circular orbit speed at the same place. For the Earth's surface, 11.2 km/s. For the Moon, 2.38 km/s. For Mars, 5.03 km/s.

Data Worked estimate: Mangalyaan's orbit period from Kepler's third law
StepWorkingResult
Mean distance from Mars's centre(421.7 + 76,993.6) / 2 + 3,389.542,098 km
Mars's G x mass6.674 x 10^-11 x 0.64169 x 10^244.28 x 10^13 m³/s²
a³ / GM(4.21 x 10^7)³ / 4.28 x 10^131.74 x 10^9 s²
Period2 x 3.14 x square root of 1.74 x 10^92.62 x 10^5 s = 72.8 h
Published period72 h 51 min 51 s72.9 h
Speed ratio, nearest to farthest80,384 / 3,811about 21

All values calculated except the published period. Distances are from Mars's centre.

Source: ISRO, Mars Orbiter Spacecraft successfully inserted into Mars orbit (press release, 24 September 2014, reprinted by ScienceDaily), https://sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/09/140924102520.htm (launch on PSLV 5 November 2013; trans-Mars injection 1 December 2013; periapsis 421.7 km, apoapsis 76,993.6 km; period 72 h 51 min 51 s)

Check your understanding

Why does a satellite in a higher circular orbit move more slowly than one in a lower orbit?

For a circular orbit v² = GM / r, so v falls as r grows. The pull is weaker, so a lower sideways speed keeps the path curving at the right rate.

Kepler's second law says a planet moves faster when nearer the Sun. What is the underlying reason?

The pull acts along the line to the Sun, so it cannot change the turning quantity mass x speed x distance. A shorter distance forces a higher speed.

A spacecraft is in an elliptical orbit around Mars with its nearest point at about 3,800 km and farthest at 80,400 km from Mars's centre. About how much faster does it move at the nearest point?

By equal areas in equal times, speed is inversely proportional to distance at those two points: 80,400 / 3,800 is about 21.
← Part 4: Projectiles: two independent motions make a curveMark read · Part 6: Gravity tested and stretched: Neptune, black holes and the limits of Newton →