Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Gravity, projectiles and orbits: Gravitational fields, tides and the points where pulls balance

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 4: Gravity, projectiles and orbits Part 3 of 6

Gravitational fields, tides and the points where pulls balance

Newton's law gives the force between two named bodies. The field idea turns this into a map: at every point in space, there is a pull per kilogram. This part uses the map to explain a puzzle, why the Moon raises bigger tides than the Sun although the Sun pulls harder, and to show how ISRO's Aditya-L1 sits at a point where the Sun's and the Earth's pulls combine.

3.1 A gravitational field is the pull per kilogram at each point, and it reads off as an acceleration

Instead of asking what force two bodies exert on each other, ask what a planet does to the space around it. At each point, imagine placing a 1 kg test mass. The force on it, in newtons, is the field strength at that point. A newton per kilogram is the same unit as a metre per second squared, so the field is also the acceleration a free body would have there. The field of a body of mass M at distance d is G x M / d².

The field is useful because fields add. At any point, the pulls of several bodies are combined as arrows (vectors, from 'Motion and force'). Near Earth the Sun's field and the Moon's field are both present, each small compared with the Earth's own. The table gives some values at the Earth's distance.

The Sun's field at the Earth's distance is 0.0059 m/s², more than twice the field of the Earth at the Moon's distance. This is what keeps the Earth in its yearly orbit: the Earth and everything on it fall around the Sun at 0.0059 m/s². Everything near the Earth shares that fall, so we do not feel it. Only differences in the field across a body can be felt, and that is the key to tides.

Data Gravitational field strengths (acceleration of a free body)
PlaceSourceField strengthWorking
Earth's surfaceEarth9.82 m/s²measured
Moon's surfaceMoon1.62 m/s²NASA
Mars's surfaceMars3.73 m/s²NASA
At the Earth, from the SunSun0.0059 m/s²1.327 x 10^20 / (1.496 x 10^11)²
At the Moon, from the EarthEarth0.0027 m/s²3.986 x 10^14 / (3.844 x 10^8)²
At the Earth, from the MoonMoon0.000033 m/s²4.90 x 10^12 / (3.844 x 10^8)²

The products G x mass used are 3.986 x 10^14 (Earth), 4.90 x 10^12 (Moon) and 1.327 x 10^20 (Sun), in m³/s². Calculated.

Source: NASA NSSDCA, Moon Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/moonfact.html (mass 0.07346 x 10^24 kg; radius 1737.4 km; gravity 1.62 m/s²; escape 2.38 km/s; distance 0.3844 million km; period 27.3217 days)

3.2 Tides come from the difference in the Moon's pull across the Earth, which is why the Moon beats the Sun

At the Earth, the Sun's field (0.0059 m/s²) is about 180 times the Moon's (0.000033 m/s²). If tides came from the size of the pull, the Sun would dominate. It does not, and the reason is that the whole Earth falls towards the Sun at its centre value. What the ocean feels is only the difference between the pull at one place and the pull at the Earth's centre.

Take the Moon. The side of the Earth facing it is about 6,400 km nearer than the centre, so it is pulled slightly harder. The far side is 6,400 km further and is pulled slightly less. Relative to the centre, the near water is pulled towards the Moon, and the far water is left behind, away from the Moon. Both produce a bulge. The result is two high tides, on the side facing the Moon and on the opposite side. The differences come from the cube of the distance: the tidal acceleration is about 2 x G x M x R / d³, where R is the Earth's radius. A distance in the cube makes the nearer Moon matter more than the far larger Sun.

The numbers: the Moon gives about 1.1 x 10^-6 m/s², the Sun about 0.5 x 10^-6 m/s². The Moon's tidal effect is about 2.2 times the Sun's. These are about a ten-millionth of g, enough to lift the open ocean by only some tens of centimetres. As the Earth turns beneath the bulges, a coast sees two highs and two lows a day. The gap between high tides is about 12 hours 25 minutes, not 12, because the Moon has moved on in its orbit.

When the Sun and Moon line up, at new and full Moon, their effects add and give spring tides. At the quarter phases they pull at right angles, giving weaker neap tides.

Data Worked estimate: Moon and Sun tide-raising acceleration
BodyWorking: 2 x GM x R / d³ResultCompared with g
Moon2 x 4.90 x 10^12 x 6.37 x 10^6 / (3.844 x 10^8)³1.1 x 10^-6 m/s²about one ten-millionth
Sun2 x 1.327 x 10^20 x 6.37 x 10^6 / (1.496 x 10^11)³0.5 x 10^-6 m/s²about one twenty-millionth
Ratio1.1 / 0.5about 2.2Moon's effect is more than double

Calculated. The Sun has 27 million times the Moon's mass, but the cube of its extra distance (390 x 390 x 390, about 59 million) wins.

Source: NASA NSSDCA, Moon Fact Sheet, https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/moonfact.html (mass 0.07346 x 10^24 kg; radius 1737.4 km; gravity 1.62 m/s²; escape 2.38 km/s; distance 0.3844 million km; period 27.3217 days)

3.3 Coasts magnify tides, and Aditya-L1 shows a point in space where the Sun's and Earth's pulls combine

The open ocean rises by well under a metre. What a coast sees depends on its shape. Water sloshes in a basin with its own natural period; if that matches the tidal period, the rise grows. Funnel-shaped inlets squeeze the wave into less width and depth. The Gulf of Khambhat in Gujarat is India's clearest case. Government survey figures give a mean spring range of 4.7 m at Mahuva near the mouth, 6.5 m at Gopnath Point and 10.2 m at Bhavnagar further up the gulf, with a maximum spring tide of 12.5 m recorded at Bhavnagar. The range more than doubles along the funnel.

The field idea also gives a second use: finding points where two pulls combine. An object nearer the Sun than the Earth would orbit the Sun faster than the Earth and drift away. But between the Sun and the Earth, the Earth's pull works against the Sun's. This partly cancels the Sun's pull on the spacecraft, so it needs less force to circle, and its orbital period lengthens. At one point, the first Lagrange point (L1), the period equals one year and the craft keeps pace with the Earth, always on the sunward side.

Its distance can be estimated. L1 lies about R x (Earth mass / (3 x Sun mass))^(1/3) from the Earth, where R is the Earth-Sun distance. That is 1.496 x 10^8 km x (5.97 x 10^24 / (3 x 1.99 x 10^30))^(1/3) = 1.5 million km, about 1 per cent of the way to the Sun.

ISRO's Aditya-L1, launched on PSLV-C57 on 2 September 2023, was placed into a halo orbit around L1 on 6 January 2024, roughly 1.5 million km from the Earth. There the Sun is always in view and never eclipsed, which is what a solar observatory wants. Staying there takes small thruster firings, because L1 is balanced rather than stable.

Data Worked estimate: the distance of the Sun-Earth L1 point
StepWorkingResult
Mass ratio5.97 x 10^24 / (3 x 1.99 x 10^30)1.0 x 10^-6
Cube root(1.0 x 10^-6)^(1/3)0.010
Earth-Sun distance149.6 million km1.496 x 10^8 km
L1 distance from Earth0.010 x 1.496 x 10^8 kmabout 1.5 million km
Compare ISROAditya-L1 halo orbitroughly 1.5 million km

Calculated; the cube-root formula is the standard approximation when the Earth's mass is far smaller than the Sun's.

Source: ISRO, Halo orbit insertion of Aditya-L1, https://www.isro.gov.in/halo-orbit-insertion-adtya-l1.html (launched by PSLV-C57 on 2 September 2023; insertion 6 January 2024; about 1.5 million km from Earth)

See it in the table

H₂O Water

Check your understanding

The Sun's pull on the Earth is about 180 times the Moon's pull, yet the Moon raises larger tides. Why?

The whole Earth falls towards each body together. Only the difference in pull between near and far sides is felt as a tide, and that difference scales as 1 / distance³, favouring the nearer Moon.

How many high tides does a coast usually see in a day, and why?

The pull on near water exceeds that on the centre, and the pull on the centre exceeds that on the far water, giving two bulges as the Earth turns.

What is the field strength of a body of mass M at a distance d?

The field is the force on a unit mass: G x M x 1 kg / d² per kilogram. It falls as the inverse square of the distance.
← Part 2: Weight, weightlessness and the way gravity feelsMark read · Part 4: Projectiles: two independent motions make a curve →