Gravity, projectiles and orbits: Gravity tested and stretched: Neptune, black holes and the limits of Newton
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 4: Gravity, projectiles and orbits Part 6 of 6Gravity tested and stretched: Neptune, black holes and the limits of Newton
A good law predicts things nobody has seen. This part gives the best Newtonian example, the planet found by arithmetic, then pushes the escape-speed idea to its extreme and meets black holes, and finishes by asking where Newton's account runs out. It also gathers the module into one map.
6.1 Newton's law found a planet on paper: Neptune in 1846
By the 1840s Uranus had been watched for decades, and its orbit did not match the predictions made from Newton's law with the known planets. There were two ways out. Either the law fails at that great distance, or an unseen body was pulling on Uranus. Two mathematicians took the second view: John Couch Adams in Britain and Urbain Le Verrier in France. Each calculated where such a planet would have to be to produce the observed pull.
Le Verrier sent his prediction to Johann Galle at the Berlin Observatory, and on 23 September 1846 Galle and his assistant Heinrich d'Arrest found a new planet very near the predicted place. It was Neptune. The law had not failed; it had pointed to something new. The credit was later shared between Adams and Le Verrier.
Kepler's third law gives a quick feel for the new planet. Neptune is about 30 times as far from the Sun as the Earth. The period in years is then 30 to the power 1.5, which is 164 years (calculated; NASA gives about 165). So Neptune completed its first full orbit since its discovery only in July 2011. The Sun's pull there is 1/900 of its pull at the Earth, which is why Neptune moves so slowly: about 5.4 km/s (calculated) against the Earth's 29.8 km/s.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Distance in Earth-Sun units | about 30 | 30 |
| Period in years | 30^1.5 = 30 x square root of 30 | 164 years |
| Sun's pull compared with Earth's distance | 1 / 30² | 1/900 |
| Speed compared with Earth's 29.8 km/s | 29.8 / square root of 30 | 5.4 km/s |
All values calculated; 30 is NASA's rounded figure for Neptune's mean distance in Earth-Sun units.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Neptune's discovery, https://www.britannica.com/place/Neptune-planet/Neptunes-discovery (Adams and Le Verrier; Galle at Berlin, 23 September 1846)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Neptune's discovery · web
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Understanding Kepler's laws of planetary motion · web
- NASA Science, Neptune facts · web
- Physics Today, Neptune completes its first orbit since discovery (12 July 2011) · web
6.2 A black hole is a body so dense that its escape speed exceeds the speed of light
Escape speed goes up with mass and down with radius. Squeeze a body to a smaller radius and the speed needed to leave it rises. The Earth's is 11.2 km/s. Compress the Earth to the size of a marble and it would rise to the speed of light. Nothing has been found to travel faster than light, so nothing could leave.
In 1783 the Reverend John Michell and, a little later, Pierre-Simon Laplace followed this thought through with Newton's laws and concluded that very massive, compact stars could be 'dark'. Setting escape speed equal to the speed of light, c, gives a critical radius of 2 x G x M / c². Karl Schwarzschild found an exact solution in Einstein's theory in 1916. His radius is the same formula.
For the Sun, the critical radius is 2 x 1.327 x 10^20 / (3.0 x 10^8)² = 2.95 km. The Sun, with a radius of 700,000 km, is nowhere near this density. The collapsed core of a very massive star, a few times the Sun's mass, can end up that small. On 10 April 2019 the Event Horizon Telescope released the first image of a black hole's shadow, in the galaxy M87. On 12 May 2022 it released one of the black hole at the centre of our Galaxy, Sagittarius A*, about 4 million times the mass of the Sun and about 27,000 light-years away. With the formula above, its critical radius is about 12 million km, roughly 17 times the Sun's radius (calculated).
| Body | Mass | Working: 2 x G x M / c² | Critical radius |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earth | 5.97 x 10^24 kg | 2 x 3.99 x 10^14 / (3.0 x 10^8)² | about 9 mm |
| Sun | 1.99 x 10^30 kg | 2 x 1.327 x 10^20 / 9.0 x 10^16 | about 3 km |
| Sagittarius A* | 4 million Suns | 4 x 10^6 x 2.95 km | about 12 million km |
Calculated; c = 3.0 x 10^8 m/s. For Sagittarius A*, the mass of 4 million suns is from the NSF.
Source: US National Science Foundation, Image of Sgr A*, https://www.nsf.gov/science-matters/image-sgr-black-hole-center-our-galaxy (M87 image 10 April 2019; Sgr A* image 12 May 2022; 4 million solar masses); distance about 27,000 light-years from ESO, https://www.eso.org/public/news/eso2208/- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
- Developments in Black Hole Research: Classical, Semi-classical, and Quantum (arXiv:0711.2279) · web
- US National Science Foundation, Image of Sgr A* · web
6.3 Gravity is the weakest pull, yet it rules the large scale, and Newton's account has limits
Between two people the pull is about 3 x 10^-7 N, so gravity is extremely weak between small bodies. It rules large ones for two reasons. It has only one sign: mass always attracts, never repels, so the pulls of all the atoms in a planet add up. And it reaches far, falling only as the inverse square. In bulk matter other pulls cancel, and gravity is what is left over.
Newton's account works superbly. Every Indian mission in this module, from Aryabhata in 1975 to Chandrayaan-3 in 2023, was planned with it. But the account has gaps. It does not say how a pull gets across empty space, and Newton himself called the question beyond him. It treats the pull as acting at once everywhere. And it cannot explain the small shift of Mercury's orbit. Einstein's general theory of 1915 describes gravity as the curving of space and time by mass, and reduces to Newton's law when pulls are weak and speeds are low. It predicted that starlight would bend as it passes the Sun, which the eclipse of 1919 measured (the test described in 'How science knows').
- Universal gravitation: force = G x m1 x m2 / d²
- Falling things
- Weight and weightlessness
- Projectiles and the parabola
- Orbiting things
- Satellites, geostationary and sun-synchronous orbits
- Kepler's three laws
- Escape speed and ISRO's journeys to the Moon and Mars
- Differences of pull
- Tides
- Balance points such as L1 and Aditya-L1
- Gravity at its extreme
- Black holes, where escape speed reaches that of light
- Falling things
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 5, 'Gravity'
- Developments in Black Hole Research: Classical, Semi-classical, and Quantum (arXiv:0711.2279) · web
- NASA NSSDCA, Moon Fact Sheet · web
See it in the table
Hg MercuryCheck your understanding
What did the mismatch in the orbit of Uranus lead to in 1846?
Adams and Le Verrier calculated where an unseen planet would have to be to explain Uranus's path. Galle found Neptune near the predicted place on 23 September 1846.What is the critical radius of a black hole of mass M in the Newtonian argument?
Setting the escape speed square root of (2GM / r) equal to c and solving for r gives r = 2GM / c². The same formula comes from Einstein's theory.Why does gravity dominate the large-scale universe although it is the weakest pull between small bodies?
Gravity has one sign and long reach, so its contributions accumulate. Other forces, which come in two signs, cancel in neutral bulk matter.