Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Force, motion and energy: the laws every machine obeys: Force, weight and friction: what pushes a machine and what holds it back

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 3: Force, motion and energy: the laws every machine obeys Part 1 of 5

Force, weight and friction: what pushes a machine and what holds it back

Every machine, from a bicycle to a goods train, is a device for making forces and steering them. This part gives you the three laws of motion in working form, separates mass from weight, and shows why friction is both the thing wheels depend on and the thing bearings fight. It builds on the estimating habits of module 2.

1.1 A body keeps its motion until a net force changes it, and the change is force divided by mass

Push a loaded handcart along a flat lane and it rolls. Stop pushing and it slows and halts. It is tempting to think that motion needs a continuing push. The cart slows because friction in the axles and the ground pushes back. This tendency of a body to carry on with whatever velocity it has is called inertia. It is the first law of motion: with no net force, neither the speed nor the direction changes.

The second law says what a net force does. It changes the velocity, and the change each second is the acceleration. In words: force = mass x acceleration. Mass is how strongly a body resists being speeded up, slowed down or turned. The same push gives a big acceleration to a light cart and a small one to a heavy cart. In SI units one newton gives one kilogram an acceleration of one metre per second, every second.

The word net matters. Several forces usually act at once, and only their sum, with directions counted, decides the motion. A scooter at steady speed has a driving force from the road and an equal drag from air and tyres. The sum is zero, so there is no acceleration, although the engine is working.

The third law says forces come in pairs. When a tyre pushes backwards on the road, the road pushes forwards on the tyre by the same amount. A vehicle is driven by the ground, not by its engine alone, which is why a powerful motor achieves nothing on wet ice. The table works a scooter through these laws.

Data Worked estimate 1: what force does a scooter need to reach 36 km/h in 8 seconds?
StepWorkingResult
Mass of scooter and rider125 kg scooter + 75 kg rider200 kg
Target speed in SI units36 km/h = 36 x 1000 / 360010 m/s
Acceleration10 m/s / 8 s1.25 m/s2
Force to accelerate200 kg x 1.25 m/s2250 N
Weight, for scale200 kg x 9.8 m/s2about 2,000 N, so the push is about one eighth of the weight
Rolling drag (coefficient about 0.015)0.015 x 2,000 N30 N
Air drag at 10 m/s (drag area 0.7 m2, air 1.2 kg/m3)half x 1.2 x 0.7 x 10 x 10about 40 N at the end of the run
Peak force from the road250 + 30 + 40about 320 N
Peak power at the wheel320 N x 10 m/sabout 3.2 kW, or 4.3 horsepower
Distance coveredhalf x 1.25 x 8 x 840 m

Check: a 110 to 125 cc scooter engine is rated at several kilowatts, so a brisk start at 3 kW at the wheel is plausible. The estimate shows that most of the force goes into acceleration, not drag.

Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 1, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 1'
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 1, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 1'

1.2 Weight is the pull of the Earth on a mass, and on a slope only part of it works against you

Mass is the amount of matter and the resistance to acceleration, measured in kilograms. Weight is a force, the pull of gravity on that mass, measured in newtons. Near the Earth's surface, weight = mass x g, with g about 9.8 metres per second squared. When a shopkeeper says a bag of rice weighs 50 kg, strictly he is giving its mass; its weight is about 490 N. The difference is real: g varies from about 9.78 at the equator to 9.83 at the poles, so a spring scale reads slightly differently from place to place, while a beam balance, which compares two masses, does not.

One consequence of the second law surprises most people. The pull of gravity on a body and the body's inertia both grow in proportion to its mass, so their ratio, the acceleration of a fall, does not depend on mass at all. Without air, a coin and a brick dropped together from a balcony would land together; air holds back only light, spread-out things such as a sheet of paper.

Weight is what you feel through a support, so it can seem to change. In a lift that accelerates upwards, the floor must carry your weight and also push you upwards, so the force you feel is mass x (g + a). With a lift acceleration of 1 m/s2 the change is about 10 per cent, which is why your stomach notices it.

On a slope, gravity still points straight down, but only the part along the slope pulls the vehicle back. For gentle gradients that part is simply weight x gradient. A road climbing 5 m in every 100 m has a gradient of 5 per cent, so a 200 kg scooter and rider feel a backward pull of 5 per cent of 1,960 N, about 100 N, however fast they go.

Data Weight at rest, and the force on the floor of a lift accelerating upwards at 1 m/s2 (calculated, g = 9.8 m/s2)
ObjectMassWeight at restForce on the floor while accelerating up
Mobile phone0.2 kg2.0 N2.2 N
Bag of rice50 kg490 N540 N
Adult passenger70 kg690 N760 N
Scooter and rider in a goods lift200 kg1,960 N2,160 N
Full 8-person lift car (car 700 kg + 630 kg load)1,330 kg13,000 N14,400 N on the ropes

Mass is the same in each row; only the force changes, by the ratio (9.8 + 1) / 9.8, about 1.1. The last row is the pull on the car's ropes before the counterweight of part 2 is counted.

Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 1, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 1'
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 1, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 1'

1.3 Friction is the grip that lets machines move, and the drag they are built to avoid

Friction is the force that resists sliding between two surfaces in contact. To a good first approximation, the largest friction force available is a coefficient times the force pressing the surfaces together: friction limit = coefficient x normal force. The coefficient depends on the pair of materials and not much on the area of contact or the speed of sliding. Static friction, between surfaces not yet slipping, is usually higher than sliding friction.

A walking foot, a tyre, a belt drive, a clutch and a brake all work only because friction exists. Meanwhile bearings, piston rings and chain links must keep friction low, because it wastes energy as heat.

The oldest engineering answer to this is the wheel. Rolling is different from sliding: the part of the tyre touching the road is momentarily still, and the resistance comes only from the small flexing of tyre and ground. Rolling resistance coefficients are around 0.01, against 0.3 or more for sliding, a saving of roughly thirty times. A smooth steel wheel on steel rail is even lower, about 0.002, which is why a locomotive can pull a thousand tonnes.

That low friction is also the railway's weakness. The wheel can push on the rail only as hard as friction allows, so a locomotive must be heavy to pull heavily. Once a driving wheel starts to spin, its contact slides and the grip falls to the lower sliding value. Modern locomotives therefore compare the speeds of their axles and trim the motor torque the moment one axle runs ahead of the others, so the wheel bites again.

Data Worked estimate 2: how hard can a 123-tonne electric locomotive pull before its wheels slip?
StepWorkingResult
Mass on driven wheelsall six axles are driven, so all 123,000 kg counts (weight from secondary sources)123,000 kg
Weight pressing on the rails123,000 kg x 9.8 m/s21.2 million N (1,205 kN)
Friction coefficient, dry steel on steeltypical 0.25 to 0.30; take 0.270.27
Greatest pull before slip0.27 x 1,205 kNabout 325 kN
Published starting tractive effortabout 322 kN in secondary sources; the RDSO specification for the three-phase drive asks for at least 340 kN on dry rail322 to 340 kN
Same locomotive on a wet rail (coefficient about 0.15)0.15 x 1,205 kNabout 180 kN
Pull to move a 1,000-tonne train on level track at low speed (resistance about 3 N per kN of weight)0.003 x 9,800 kNabout 30 kN, one tenth of the limit

The published 322 kN implies an adhesion coefficient of 322 / 1,205, about 0.27 (calculated), inside the usual dry-rail range, so designers rate locomotives close to the friction limit. Sand dropped on the rail raises the coefficient in wet weather.

Source: RDSO (Ministry of Railways), Specification RDSO/2007/EL/SPEC/0048 Rev. 0, IGBT based three-phase drive electrics for WAG-9 and WAP-7 locomotives (January 2007), WAP-7: starting tractive effort not less than 340 kN on dry rail; continuous power not less than 6,000 hp; maximum design speed 140 km/h; https://rdso.indianrailways.gov.in/uploads/files/48.pdf
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 1, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 1'
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
  • RDSO (Ministry of Railways), Specification RDSO/2007/EL/SPEC/0048 Rev. 0, IGBT based three-phase drive electrics for WAG-9 and WAP-7 locomotives (January 2007) · WAP-7: starting tractive effort not less than 340 kN on dry rail; continuous power not less than 6,000 hp; maximum design speed 140 km/h; https://rdso.indianrailways.gov.in/uploads/files/48.pdf

See it in the table

H₂O WaterSt SteelRi Rice

Check your understanding

A scooter cruises at a steady 40 km/h on a level road. Which statement is correct?

Steady speed means zero acceleration, so the forces add to zero. The engine is working, but its push through the road is exactly matched by air and rolling drag.

A 60 kg person stands in a lift that accelerates upwards at 1 m/s2. Compared with standing still, the floor pushes on the feet with a force that is:

The floor must support the weight and also give the upward acceleration, so the force is mass x (g + a), about 9.8 + 1 against 9.8. That is roughly 10 per cent more.

Why does a wide tyre not necessarily grip more than a narrow one, on the simple friction rule?

To a good first approximation the friction limit is a coefficient times the force pressing the surfaces together. Real tyres add effects such as heat and deformation, but area alone is not the cause.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: Work, energy and power: the engineer's first audit →