Force, motion and energy: the laws every machine obeys: Levers, pulleys, gears and wheels: trading force for distance
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 3: Force, motion and energy: the laws every machine obeys Part 4 of 5Levers, pulleys, gears and wheels: trading force for distance
Simple machines do not create energy. They exchange force for distance, or torque for speed, so that a small push can move a large load slowly. This part states that one rule, then applies it to a village hand pump, a car jack, a crane hoist, a bicycle's gears and a potter's wheel, and ends with torque and the flywheel, which stores energy in rotation.
4.1 A lever or ramp exchanges force for distance, and the work out never exceeds the work in
A lever is a stiff bar turning about a pivot. Push down on one end and the other end lifts. If the arm on your side is five times as long as the arm on the load's side, your end moves five times as far as the load's end, and the force on the load is five times your push. That ratio of load force to effort force is the mechanical advantage. A crowbar, a pair of pliers and a wheelbarrow are levers, and so is the long handle of a village hand pump.
The key point is that a simple machine cannot be a source of extra work. Work is force x distance, and you pay in distance what you gain in force. If a machine had no friction, the work done on it by your hand would exactly equal the work it did on the load. Real machines do slightly worse, since friction in the pivot turns some of the work into heat.
A screw is a slope wrapped round a rod. In a car's screw jack rising 3 mm per turn, with a handle cranked round a 0.25 m radius, the hand travels about 1.57 m per 3 mm of lift, a ratio over 500, so one corner of a car, about 4,000 N, would need under 8 N without friction. Real jacks need several times that, lost to friction in the thread. Designers accept the loss on purpose: such a thread cannot run backwards under load, so the car stays up when you let go.
The hand pump estimate shows the exchange with numbers. The trade-off in a lever is between force and stroke. A longer handle needs less effort but a wider sweep, and a pump handle is limited by the arc a person can comfortably push. Designers choose the ratio so that a typical person delivers a comfortable force over a comfortable stroke, and the water output follows from the pump bore.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Lever ratio | handle arm 1.0 m, rod arm 0.2 m | 5 |
| Hand force and stroke | 60 N through 0.5 m | work in 30 J |
| Force on the rod, no friction | 60 N x 5 | 300 N |
| Rod stroke | 0.5 m / 5 | 0.1 m |
| Water lifted per stroke (50 mm bore, area 0.00196 m2) | 0.00196 x 0.1 = 0.000196 m3 | 0.196 litre, 0.196 kg |
| Work done on the water | 0.196 kg x 9.8 x 15 m | 28.8 J |
| Weight of the water column the 300 N can hold | 300 / 9.8 = 30.6 kg; column mass = 1,000 x 0.00196 x 15 | about 29 kg, a match |
| Efficiency | 28.8 / 30 | about 96 per cent |
| Strokes for a 20-litre bucket | 20 / 0.196 | about 100 |
Check: real hand pumps lose more to friction and to leakage past the piston, so a figure of 60 to 80 per cent is more realistic than 96. The pump also needs the human to deliver 30 J per stroke, about 100 strokes or 3,000 J a bucket, on top of walking time.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 1, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 1'
4.2 Pulleys and hoists spread a load over several ropes, so a small tension lifts a heavy weight
A single fixed pulley only changes the direction of the pull; you still haul with a force equal to the load. The gain appears when the rope passes round a moving pulley attached to the load. Then two sections of rope share the weight, and each carries half. Add more sheaves and the load hangs from four, six or eight sections, each taking a fraction. The mechanical advantage equals the number of rope sections that support the load. As with the lever, the price is distance: to lift the load 1 m with four sections, you must draw in 4 m of rope.
A lifting crane is built on this idea. A hoist drum winds in rope, passing through a block with several sheaves on the hook. The drum turns fast and with modest torque; the hook rises slowly with large force. Power at the hook is the weight times lifting speed, and this is unchanged by the number of falls. More falls reduce the rope tension and the torque the drum must supply, but increase the length of rope and the speed at which it must be wound. In practice, each sheave wastes a few per cent in friction, so more falls also mean lower efficiency, and engineers pick a number that balances tension against losses.
The rope itself is sized with a safety factor, the margin described in module 1. Crane ropes are commonly selected so that the breaking load is at least five times the working load.
A tower crane on a building site, as in the Tower crane and Lifting crane entries of the Periodic Table of Technologies, adds a second balance. The jib reaches out with the load on one side of the mast, and a counterweight hangs on the other, so that the turning effects about the mast cancel, as the rotation section below explains. The estimate below sizes the hoist for a 2-tonne steel bundle.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Weight of the load | 2,000 kg x 9.8 | 19,600 N |
| Tension in each of four falls, ideal | 19,600 / 4 | 4,900 N |
| Rope speed at the drum | 4 x 0.5 m/s | 2 m/s |
| Power at the hook | 19,600 N x 0.5 m/s | 9.8 kW |
| Efficiency of the sheaves, drum and gears | assume 0.9 x 0.9 | about 0.8 |
| Motor power needed | 9.8 / 0.8 | about 12 kW |
| Rope breaking load for a safety factor of 5 | 5 x 4.9 kN | about 25 kN per fall |
| Energy to raise the bundle 60 m | 19,600 N x 60 m | 1.18 MJ, or 0.33 kWh |
Check: ten-odd kilowatts is a plausible order for a small site crane hoist; compare it with a maker's data sheet. Real ratings also reflect starting loads, heavier lifts at short radius and duty cycle.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
4.3 Gears and chains trade speed for torque, and a bicycle shows the arithmetic
A gear pair does for rotation what a lever does for a straight push. A small gear driving a large one turns it more slowly but with more torque. The ratio of the teeth numbers sets both: if the large gear has three times the teeth, it turns a third as fast and delivers three times the torque, ignoring losses. The product of torque and rotation speed is power, and it stays the same through the gears except for friction. Belts, chains and gearboxes work the same way.
Motors and engines are happiest at high speed with modest torque, while wheels, drums and machine tools often need slow speed with high torque. The gearbox sits between the two. A fan runs without one; a lorry and a crane need heavy reduction. The trade-off is cost, weight, noise and a loss of a few per cent in each stage, so designers use the fewest stages that give the ratio.
A bicycle is the most familiar gearbox. The chainring at the pedals and the sprocket at the rear wheel set a ratio. With 36 teeth at the front and 30 at the back, the wheel turns 1.2 times for each pedal turn. A 28-inch wheel, about 2.1 m round, then travels 2.5 m per pedal turn. At a cadence of 80 turns a minute, that is 200 m a minute, 12 km/h, the speed of the hill climb in part 2. At that ratio the wheel turns faster than the pedals, so the torque at the wheel is smaller by the same factor.
On a 10 per cent hill at the same 183 W the speed falls to about 7 km/h (calculated); in the 36 to 30 gear the cadence would drop to about 46 turns a minute and the crank force rise to about 225 N. A ratio near 0.7, such as 30 teeth at the front and 44 at the back, restores a cadence of about 80. Chain drives lose little: tests at Johns Hopkins University in 1999 measured 81 to 98.6 per cent, with larger sprockets doing better.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Gear ratio | 36 teeth at chainring / 30 teeth at sprocket | 1.2 wheel turns per pedal turn |
| Wheel speed | 80 rpm x 1.2 | 96 rpm, or 10.05 rad/s |
| Road speed | 96 x 2.1 m / 60 | 3.4 m/s, or 12 km/h |
| Pedal speed | 80 rpm = 80 x 2 x pi / 60 | 8.4 rad/s |
| Pedal torque | 183 W / 8.4 rad/s | about 22 N m |
| Force on a 0.17 m crank | 22 / 0.17 | about 128 N average |
| Wheel torque (chain 97 per cent efficient) | 178 W / 10.05 rad/s | about 17.7 N m |
| Push of tyre on road (wheel radius 0.335 m) | 17.7 / 0.335 | about 53 N |
| Check against the hill forces | slope 41.7 N + rolling 8.3 N + air 3.3 N | 53 N, a match |
The average crank force is about 128 N, but a leg pushes hard only on the down-stroke, so the peak is several times higher. That is why a gear that is too high makes a hill feel like pushing a heavy door.
Source: Johns Hopkins University news release of 20 August 1999 on chain drive tests by J. B. Spicer and colleagues (ScienceDaily copy), chain efficiency 81 to 98.6 per cent; larger sprockets and higher tension gave higher efficiency; lubricant made little difference; https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1999/08/990819180058.htm- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 4, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 2'
- Johns Hopkins University news release of 20 August 1999 on chain drive tests by J. B. Spicer and colleagues (ScienceDaily copy) · chain efficiency 81 to 98.6 per cent; larger sprockets and higher tension gave higher efficiency; lubricant made little difference; https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1999/08/990819180058.htm
4.4 Torque and rotational inertia decide how fast things spin up and how much a flywheel can store
Torque is the turning effect of a force: torque = force x the perpendicular distance from the pivot. A wheel brace 0.4 m long pushed with 250 N at its end gives 100 N m, the same order as the tightness specified for car wheel nuts; pushing halfway along would need twice the force. Rotation obeys a version of the second law: torque = rotational inertia x angular acceleration. Rotational inertia plays the role of mass, but it also depends on where the mass sits. Mass far from the axis counts for much more, in proportion to the square of the distance.
Balance is also about torque. A tower crane with a 2,000 kg load 20 m from the mast produces a turning effect of 2,000 x 9.8 x 20, about 390 kN m, about the mast. To balance it fully, a counterweight of 8,000 kg must hang 5 m out on the other side. Real cranes balance only part of the load's turning effect, and the mast and its base carry the rest.
A flywheel stores energy of rotation, half x rotational inertia x angular speed squared. Because mass at the rim counts most, flywheels are heavy at the edge. The Potter's wheel, a technology on the site, is a flywheel: a heavy disc that the potter kicks or drives up to speed, and which then carries on spinning smoothly while the clay is shaped. The single-cylinder engines of old pumpsets and tractors, which fire once in every two turns, have massive flywheels for the same reason: they carry the engine through the empty strokes between firings.
There is always a trade-off. A heavier flywheel smooths the running better, but it takes more energy to start and makes the engine slow to respond to the throttle.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Rotational inertia of a disc | half x 30 x 0.4 x 0.4 | 2.4 kg m2 |
| Angular speed | 100 x 2 x pi / 60 | 10.5 rad/s |
| Stored energy | half x 2.4 x 10.5 x 10.5 | about 132 J |
| Same energy as lifting | 132 J / (9.8 x 1 m) | a 13.5 kg bag by 1 m |
| Drag torque from bearing and clay (assumed) | 0.5 N m | 3.1 J lost per turn (0.5 x 2 x pi) |
| Turns before it stops, with no kicks | 132 / 3.1 | about 42 turns, under a minute |
| Same mass concentrated as a ring at the rim | 30 x 0.4 x 0.4 = 4.8 kg m2 | 264 J at the same speed |
The drag torque is an assumption, so the time is an order of magnitude. Heavier clay slows the wheel faster, and that is why potters keep kicking or add a motor.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
See it in the table
H₂O WaterSt SteelCheck your understanding
A lever has the hand 1.0 m from the pivot and the load 0.2 m on the other side. If it is frictionless, what does a 60 N push at the hand give?
The lever multiplies force by the ratio of arms, 5, and divides the distance moved by 5, so work in equals work out: 60 N x 0.5 m = 300 N x 0.1 m.Why does a crane hoist with four rope sections supporting the load need a rope drawn in four times as fast as the load rises?
With four supporting sections each carries a quarter of the load, but every metre of lift needs 4 metres of rope to be pulled in. Force falls and distance rises by the same factor.In a gear where the rear wheel turns faster than the pedals (a ratio above 1), how does the torque at the wheel compare with the torque at the pedals?
Power is torque x rotation speed and is conserved apart from small losses. If the wheel turns faster than the pedals, its torque must be smaller by the same ratio.