Force, motion and energy: the laws every machine obeys: Momentum, collisions and stopping: how safety design works
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 3: Force, motion and energy: the laws every machine obeys Part 3 of 5Momentum, collisions and stopping: how safety design works
Crashes and emergency stops are about the same few ideas: how much motion a vehicle carries, how quickly it must be removed, and where the energy goes. This part introduces momentum and impulse, works a collision between a heavy and a light vehicle, shows how crumple zones and belts spread the stop, and sizes the braking of an express train. It gives principles, not accident reconstruction.
3.1 Momentum and impulse: the same stop can be gentle or brutal, depending on how long it takes
Momentum is mass x velocity. A body that is heavy or fast, or both, has a lot of it. The second law can be restated in terms of momentum: force x time = change in momentum. The product of force and time is called the impulse. A fixed change of momentum can therefore be delivered in more than one way. A 1,000 kg car losing 10 m/s needs 10,000 kg m/s of impulse: 100 kN for a tenth of a second, or 10 kN for a whole second. Engineers spend much of their working lives arranging for the longer time.
A jump from a wall shows this. A person falling 1 m reaches about 4.4 m/s. The momentum of a 70 kg person at that speed is about 310 kg m/s, and the ground must remove it. Landing stiff-legged, the body stops in about a centimetre. Landing with bent knees, it stops over some 40 cm. The average force differs by the ratio of the two distances. The table works it out. Bending the knees is the habit of everyone who jumps for a living.
The same logic stands behind many everyday designs. A running shoe sole, a cycle helmet liner, the sand in a long-jump pit and the foam round a packed phone all stretch the time of a stop.
The design trade-off is always space. A longer stopping distance needs more room, more material or more weight. A bicycle helmet is as thick as people will tolerate wearing, and not thicker.
| Step | Working | Stiff legs | Bent knees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Speed on arrival | square root of (2 x 9.8 x 1) | 4.4 m/s | 4.4 m/s |
| Stopping distance | assumed | 0.01 m | 0.4 m |
| Average deceleration | speed squared / (2 x distance) = 19.6 / (2 x d) | about 980 m/s2 (100 g) | about 25 m/s2 (2.5 g) |
| Time to stop | 2 x distance / speed | 0.005 s | 0.18 s |
| Average force on the body | 70 kg x deceleration | about 69,000 N | about 1,700 N |
| Plus holding the weight up | 70 x 9.8 | 700 N | 700 N |
The stiff landing gives a force equal to the weight of about seven tonnes; the bent-knee landing about 2.4 kN in total, a bit over 3 times body weight. The estimate ignores the knees' complex action, but the ratio of 40 between the two forces is robust.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
3.2 In a collision momentum is conserved, so the lighter vehicle takes the bigger jolt
In a crash each vehicle pushes on the other, and by the third law the two pushes match in size and point opposite ways at every instant. They also begin and end together, so each vehicle receives the same impulse in opposite directions, and whatever momentum one gains the other loses. The total stays fixed. This conservation of momentum holds however messy the crash, provided no strong outside force acts during the brief impact.
Take a heavy truck and a light car hitting head-on, each at 15 m/s (54 km/h), and locking together. The total momentum is 9,000 x 15 minus 1,000 x 15, taking the truck's direction as positive, which gives 120,000 kg m/s. Divide by the combined 10,000 kg and the wreck moves on at 12 m/s in the truck's direction. The truck's velocity changed by 3 m/s. The car's changed by 27 m/s, from 15 m/s one way to 12 m/s the other. The same impulse acts on both, so the vehicle with one ninth of the mass changes velocity nine times as much, and its occupants feel nine times the acceleration.
Energy tells a different part of the story. The two vehicles had 1.125 MJ of kinetic energy before and 0.72 MJ after, so 0.405 MJ, about 36 per cent, went into bending metal and heating it. Collisions in which bodies stick or crush are called inelastic: momentum is conserved, kinetic energy is not. A bouncy collision, such as one steel ball bearing striking another, is close to elastic, and little energy is lost.
This arithmetic explains a fact of road safety that is easy to miss. Mass matters, and on roads that mix auto-rickshaws, cars, buses and trucks, the people in the lighter vehicle are the ones at greatest risk. Designers cannot change the ratio of masses, but they can make each vehicle take up its energy gently.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Momentum before (truck direction positive) | 9,000 x 15 - 1,000 x 15 | 120,000 kg m/s |
| Speed after, locked together | 120,000 / 10,000 | 12 m/s in the truck's direction |
| Change of velocity, truck | 15 to 12 | 3 m/s |
| Change of velocity, car | -15 to +12 | 27 m/s |
| Ratio of the changes | 27 / 3 | 9, the inverse of the mass ratio |
| Kinetic energy before | half x 9,000 x 225 + half x 1,000 x 225 | 1.125 MJ |
| Kinetic energy after | half x 10,000 x 144 | 0.72 MJ |
| Energy turned into damage and heat | 1.125 - 0.72 | 0.405 MJ (36 per cent) |
Check by symmetry: if both vehicles had equal mass, the speed after would be zero and each would change velocity by 15 m/s, the case in the callout.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
3.3 Crumple zones, belts and helmets stretch the stop and keep the cabin intact
A car that stops without any give would be a poor safety design. Imagine a car at 50 km/h, 13.9 m/s, striking a solid barrier. If the front crumples by 0.6 m while the cabin stays whole, the car stops in about 0.09 s with an average deceleration of about 160 m/s2, around 16 g. If the cabin collapsed after only 0.1 m, the deceleration would be six times higher. The crumple zone converts the impact's kinetic energy into work done bending steel, over the longest distance the car's length allows.
The passenger cell is built for the opposite purpose: it should be stiff and strong, so that the space around people survives and the zone in front does the crushing. The trade-off is length and cost. A longer crush zone makes a longer, heavier, dearer car, and in a small city car the designer has little room to spare.
The belt matters just as much, because the occupant must also stop. An unbelted person keeps moving at 13.9 m/s after the car has stopped, until something solid, perhaps the dashboard or windscreen, halts them in a few centimetres, at an average deceleration around 1,900 m/s2. A belt ties the person to the car's frame, so that they decelerate along with the cabin and use the full 0.6 m of crush, and it spreads the force over the strong bones of the chest and pelvis. Airbags add a cushion that lengthens the stop for the head and chest.
Two-wheeler riders have none of these. The helmet is their only crush zone, with a liner of foam a few centimetres thick that crushes permanently in a heavy impact. Test programmes such as Bharat NCAP, which since October 2023 has crashed cars into an offset deformable barrier at 64 km/h under the standard AIS-197, rate how well these ideas work in real designs.
| Case | Stopping distance | Average deceleration | Average force on 75 kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Belted, car crumples 0.6 m | 0.6 m | 193 / 1.2 = 161 m/s2 (16 g) | about 12,000 N |
| Belted, car crumples only 0.1 m | 0.1 m | 193 / 0.2 = 965 m/s2 (98 g) | about 72,000 N |
| Unbelted, hits a dashboard that gives 0.05 m | 0.05 m | 193 / 0.1 = 1,930 m/s2 (197 g) | about 145,000 N |
These are averages. Real crashes have higher peaks, and test dummies record much more detail. At the 64 km/h of Bharat NCAP the speed is 1.28 times higher and the energy 1.64 times higher than at 50 km/h, so the crush needed rises with it.
Source: Autocar India, 'Bharat NCAP crash test rules revealed ahead of October 1 roll-out' (2023), tests to AIS-197: frontal offset deformable barrier at 64 km/h, side impact, and side pole at 29 km/h for cars scoring 3 stars or more; M1 cars under 3.5 t; from 1 October 2023; https://www.autocarindia.com/industry/bharat-ncap-crash-test-rules-revealed-ahead-of-october-1-roll-out-429113- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 3, 'Mechanical Objects, Part 1'
- Autocar India, 'Bharat NCAP crash test rules revealed ahead of October 1 roll-out' (2023) · tests to AIS-197: frontal offset deformable barrier at 64 km/h, side impact, and side pole at 29 km/h for cars scoring 3 stars or more; M1 cars under 3.5 t; from 1 October 2023; https://www.autocarindia.com/industry/bharat-ncap-crash-test-rules-revealed-ahead-of-october-1-roll-out-429113
3.4 Braking a train turns motion into heat at a rate larger than the locomotive ever delivers in traction
Stopping a vehicle removes all of its kinetic energy, and the energy has to go somewhere. For a friction brake, it goes into heat in the discs or blocks. A railway express shows the scale. Take a locomotive of 123 tonnes pulling 18 modern coaches of about 44 tonnes each when empty, plus about 70 tonnes of passengers and luggage: about 1,000 tonnes in all. At 130 km/h, which is 36 m/s, the kinetic energy is half x 1,000,000 kg x 36 x 36, about 650 MJ or 180 kWh. A litre of petrol holds about 32 MJ, so stopping that train throws away the heat content of 20 litres of petrol, in a minute or so.
A service stop at 0.6 m/s2 takes 60 s and 1,100 m, and the average braking power is 650 MJ / 60 s, about 11 MW. That is more than twice the continuous power of the locomotive that pulled the train. Friction brakes can cope because they act on every coach, not only on the locomotive, and because heat flows into the large steel discs, which are mounted on the axles of modern coaches.
The limit on braking is friction at the wheel and rail again, as in part 1. All coach wheels braked with a coefficient of 0.27 could give a deceleration of 2.6 m/s2. Operators use less than a quarter of that, for passenger comfort, for the risk of sliding wheels, and because a wheel-skid flat spot damages the rail. Stopping distance depends on the square of speed, so a train at 160 km/h needs about 1.5 times the distance of one at 130 km/h at the same deceleration.
The locomotive's motors can also act as generators, a method named regenerative braking, and return a part of the energy to the overhead line. It is limited by what the motors can absorb and by whether another train is drawing power at that moment. The air brakes take the rest.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Train mass | 123 t locomotive + 18 x 44 t coaches + about 70 t of passengers and luggage | about 985 t; call it 1,000 t |
| Speed | 130 / 3.6 | 36 m/s |
| Kinetic energy | half x 1,000,000 x 36 x 36 | 650 MJ, or 180 kWh |
| Petrol with the same energy | 650 MJ / 32 MJ per litre | about 20 litres |
| Braking distance at 0.6 m/s2 | speed squared / (2 x deceleration) = 1,300 / 1.2 | about 1,100 m |
| Braking time | 36 / 0.6 | 60 s |
| Average braking power | 650 MJ / 60 s | about 11 MW |
| Greatest possible deceleration if every wheel were braked at friction coefficient 0.27 | 0.27 x 9.8 | about 2.6 m/s2 |
| Required braking force at 0.6 m/s2 | 1,000,000 x 0.6 | 600 kN |
No measured braking distance was used here, so treat the result as an order of magnitude and redo it with the deceleration of the service you care about. Doubling the deceleration halves the distance. The energy in the spinning wheels and axles, a few per cent more, is left out.
Source: Indian Railways Institute of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, 'LHB Salient Features' (training notes, read November 2026), weights of LHB coach types from 40.9 t to 53 t; axle-mounted disc brakes; https://rskr.irimee.in/sites/default/files/LHB%20Salient%20Features.pdf- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 2, 'The Laws of Motion, Part 2'
- Indian Railways Institute of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, 'LHB Salient Features' (training notes, read November 2026) · weights of LHB coach types from 40.9 t to 53 t; axle-mounted disc brakes; https://rskr.irimee.in/sites/default/files/LHB%20Salient%20Features.pdf
- Modern Coach Factory, Raebareli, coach certificate for LHB AC three-tier coach 224647 (read November 2026) · tare weight 45.6 t; 72 berths; https://mcf.indianrailways.gov.in/uploads/NER224647L3T-2534.pdf
See it in the table
St SteelCheck your understanding
A person jumps from a 1 m wall and lands. Why do bent knees hurt far less than stiff legs?
The speed at landing is fixed by the fall, and it must be removed either way. Stopping over 0.4 m instead of 0.01 m cuts the average deceleration, and so the force, by a factor of about 40.A 9,000 kg truck and a 1,000 kg car hit head-on at equal speeds and move together. Compared with the truck, the car's occupants experience a change of velocity that is:
Momentum is conserved and the contact forces are equal and opposite for the same time, so the velocity changes are in inverse proportion to the masses. The light vehicle changes by nine times as much.A train of 1,000 tonnes at 130 km/h brakes to a stop. Where does most of its 650 MJ of kinetic energy go?
Energy cannot vanish. Friction brakes turn it into heat in discs and pads. Regenerative braking turns part of it back into electricity, limited by what the motors can handle.