Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Heat and thermodynamics: engines, heat pumps and their limits: Real cycles: steam, petrol, diesel and gas turbine plants

All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 6: Heat and thermodynamics: engines, heat pumps and their limits Part 3 of 5

Real cycles: steam, petrol, diesel and gas turbine plants

A cycle is the loop a working fluid follows so that a machine can run for ever: heat in, work out, heat rejected, back to the start. Almost every heat engine on the site is one of a few loops. This part takes each at the level of principle, estimates what it can reach, and shows how stacking two loops gives the best efficiencies ever achieved from fuel.

3.1 A steam power plant boils water, spins a turbine and sends nearly half of its fuel to the condenser

A coal plant follows the Rankine loop. Water is pumped to high pressure, boiled into steam at about 540 °C and 17 MPa (subcritical) or at 24 MPa and 565 °C or more (supercritical), expanded through a turbine, and condensed back to water in a condenser held under vacuum, at about 0.07 bar and 39 °C. Then the loop repeats. See the node Steam turbine.

Two features of this loop repay thought. First, the pump is cheap to run. A liquid is nearly incompressible, so lifting its pressure takes only one to three per cent of the turbine's output, whereas compressing a gas of the same mass would take a large share of what its expansion returns. Second, the condenser is held at a vacuum so the steam can keep expanding to a low pressure, which makes the turbine do more work. The cold end fixes Tc, and the heat leaving there is by far the largest loss.

The flow figure follows one megawatt hour, 3.6 GJ of electricity, through a good supercritical unit. About 13 per cent of the fuel goes up the stack and into ash, and about 48 per cent leaves in the condenser. The condenser heat is only about 10 K above ambient, far too cool to run another engine, so it goes to a river, the sea or a cooling tower.

Carnot pulls the designer towards higher temperature and pressure, and the price is thicker tubes, creep-resistant alloys and costly welds. That is why Indian practice moved from 210 MW subcritical sets to 660 and 800 MW supercritical ones. In service the fleet does worse than the design, because part load and age pull the average down: a 2024 study of 806 Indian units reported average heat rates equal to about 26 to 31 per cent for subcritical units and 32 to 40 for supercritical ones, depending on the estimation method (efficiencies calculated from its means).

Process flowchart Worked estimate 5: one megawatt hour from a supercritical coal unit
Inputs Coalabout 667 kg at 15 MJ/kg, 10 GJ Process steps 1 Boiler

about 87 per cent of the coal's heat reaches the steam; the rest leaves with flue gas and ash

2 Turbine and condenser

steam expands and spins the shaft; the unused heat is condensed away

3 Generator and auxiliary plant

fans, pumps, mills and the generator take a small share

Outputs Electricity sent out3.6 GJ, 1 MWh (36 per cent) Heat to cooling waterabout 4.8 GJ Stack and ashabout 1.3 GJ Generator and own-use lossesabout 0.3 GJ

Round numbers for a good modern unit at full load, on the coal's gross heating value; results calculated. Indian power-station coal is high in ash, about 35 per cent on average in the Central Electricity Authority's returns for April to September 2022, and its heating value is taken here as an assumed 15 MJ/kg (about 3,600 kcal/kg). At that value the unit burns about 0.67 kg of coal per kWh.

Source: Central Electricity Authority, 'Fly Ash Generation at Coal/Lignite Based Thermal Power Stations and its Utilization in the Country for the 1st Half of the Year 2022-23' (March 2023), average ash content of coal consumed, 35.41 per cent; https://cea.nic.in/wp-content/uploads/tcd/2023/05/Half_Yearly_Ash_Report_2022_23.pdf
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 8, 'Thermodynamics', section 8.2 ('Automobiles': heat engines)
  • A Dataset of the Operating Station Heat Rate for 806 Indian Coal Plant Units using Machine Learning (arXiv, 2024) · mean heat rates of 12.91 and 11.17 MMBtu/MWh (subcritical) and 10.72 and 8.56 (supercritical) by two methods; https://arxiv.org/html/2410.00016v1
  • Central Electricity Authority, 'Fly Ash Generation at Coal/Lignite Based Thermal Power Stations and its Utilization in the Country for the 1st Half of the Year 2022-23' (March 2023) · ash content of coal consumed; https://cea.nic.in/wp-content/uploads/tcd/2023/05/Half_Yearly_Ash_Report_2022_23.pdf

3.2 Condenser heat has to go somewhere, and for a plant that means a large flow of water

The 4.8 GJ per megawatt hour that leaves the condenser must be carried away by something. The simplest scheme is once-through cooling: draw river or sea water, pass it through the condenser tubes, and discharge it a few kelvin warmer. The heat needed to warm a mass of water is mass x 4.19 kJ/kg K x rise. With a rise of 8 K, each kilogram takes 33.5 kJ, so 4.8 GJ needs 143,000 kg, or 143 m3 of water per megawatt hour. A 500 MW unit at 85 per cent load then draws about 17 m3/s, the flow of a small river. Coastal plants can do this. Inland plants usually cannot.

The other scheme is the cooling tower. Hot water falls through a stream of air and about one part in fifty of it evaporates. Because water takes 2,260 kJ/kg to evaporate, the latent heat of section 1.3 does the work: if all the 4.8 GJ went out by evaporation, only 4.8 GJ / 2.4 GJ per tonne, about 2 tonnes (2 m3), would be consumed per megawatt hour. Add the water drawn off to keep salts from building up, the drift, and ash handling and boiler make-up, and a figure of 3 to 4 m3/MWh is typical in practice. A 2015 environment ministry notification, amended in 2018, caps tower-cooled units installed from 2017 at 3 m3/MWh and older ones at 3.5, with plants cooled by sea water exempt.

The trade-off is plain. Once-through uses 40 times more water withdrawn but wastes almost none and runs a little colder, giving a higher efficiency. A tower uses far less water overall, but it consumes it, and it is dearer to build, with fans that use power. The river-side or coastal location is therefore worth money to a power developer.

Data Worked estimate 6: cooling water for a 500 MW unit at 85 per cent load
StepWorkingResult
Energy sent out per hour500 MW x 0.85425 MWh/h
Condenser heat per MWh10 GJ x (1 - 0.36 - 0.13 - 0.03)about 4.8 GJ
Once-through, 8 K rise4.8 GJ / (4.19 kJ/kg K x 8 K) = 143,000 kg143 m3/MWh, so 60,800 m3/h, 16.9 m3/s
Cooling tower, all by evaporation4.8 GJ / 2.4 GJ per m3 (latent heat near 30 °C)about 2.0 m3/MWh
Tower in practice, norm 3 m3/MWh3 x 425about 1,275 m3/h, 354 L/s, 30,600 m3/day

Results calculated; rises and loads are assumed round values. The 3 m3/MWh norm, and the 70 to 200 m3/MWh withdrawal for once-through plants, come from the 2026 summary cited below.

Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 7, 'Heat and Phase Transitions', section 7.2 ('Water, Steam, and Ice': latent heat of evaporation)
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 7, 'Heat and Phase Transitions', section 7.2 ('Water, Steam, and Ice')
  • Powerline, 'Water stress: thermal power plants take steps to optimise consumption' (4 September 2026) · 2015 norms (3.5 m3/MWh for existing and once-through plants; 2.5 for plants from 2017), raised to 3 for new plants in June 2018, sea-water plants exempt; once-through withdrawal 70 to 200 m3/MWh (Centre for Science and Environment); tower plants about 4 m3/MWh; https://powerline.net.in/2026/09/04/water-stress-thermal-power-plants-take-steps-to-optimise-consumption/

3.3 Petrol and diesel engines burn fuel inside the cylinder, and compression ratio sets their limit

A farmer's diesel pump set and a city car's petrol engine run the same short loop, the Internal combustion engine: squeeze air, burn fuel in it inside the cylinder, let the hot gas push the piston, throw the gas out. Because the heat is released in the gas itself, not passed through a boiler tube, the gas briefly reaches 2,000 °C or more.

How much of that heat can become work is set mainly by the compression ratio r: the cylinder volume with the piston at the bottom divided by the volume with it at the top. For an idealised loop using air, efficiency = 1 - 1/(r^0.4), where 0.4 reflects how strongly air heats when squeezed. Squeezing harder raises the temperature at which heat is added, the engine's version of raising Th, and the ideal rises from 56 per cent at r = 8 to 68 per cent at r = 18.

What caps r is the fuel. In a petrol engine the fuel is already mixed with the air during the squeeze, and above a ratio of about 10 to 13 the hot mixture fires by itself before the spark, a pressure shock called knock that can crack pistons. A diesel squeezes air alone, to r = 16 to 20, and sprays fuel in at the end of the stroke, where it lights on contact with the hot air. That is the main reason diesels get more work from each litre. The best large truck engines, the kind under Heavy-duty diesel engine, reach 45 to 50 per cent at their best load.

Real engines fall well short of the ideal. Heat leaks into the walls, the exhaust leaves still hot and under pressure, burning takes time, and friction takes its share. A good petrol car engine peaks at 35 to 40 per cent and averages 20 to 25 in city traffic at light load, which is why module 5 (Fluids) assumed 25 per cent for its car. The trade-off is efficiency against emissions: a higher ratio and leaner mixture save fuel but raise the nitrogen oxides formed in very hot gas.

Data Worked estimate 7: ideal engine efficiency against compression ratio, and what it means for fuel
CaseWorkingResult
Ideal air cycle, r = 81 - 8^-0.4 = 1 - 0.43556%
Ideal air cycle, r = 101 - 10^-0.4 = 1 - 0.39860%
Ideal air cycle, r = 121 - 12^-0.4 = 1 - 0.37063%
Ideal air cycle, r = 18 (diesel range)1 - 18^-0.4 = 1 - 0.31568%
Petrol car, 13 kW at the wheels at 100 km/h, engine 25%13 / 0.25 = 52 kW; 52 kW / 32 MJ per litre = 1.63 mL/s; x 3,600 s per 100 km5.9 L per 100 km
Same car with a diesel engine at 33%13 / 0.33 = 39 kW; 39 kW / 36 MJ per litre = 1.09 mL/s; x 3,6003.9 L per 100 km

Results calculated. The ideal figures are air-standard values for a loop that has no friction or heat loss, and a real diesel loop gives a few points less than the formula at the same ratio. The 13 kW at the wheels is estimate 8 of module 5 (Fluids). Check: real small petrol cars use about 6 L per 100 km, and small diesels 4 to 5.

Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 8, 'Thermodynamics', section 8.2 ('Automobiles': compression ratio and engine efficiency)
  • Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 8, 'Thermodynamics', section 8.2 ('Automobiles')

3.4 A gas turbine burns fuel in a stream of air, and putting a steam plant on its exhaust gives the best efficiency yet

The gas turbine follows the Brayton loop, and uses no piston. A compressor squeezes air to 15 to 25 times atmospheric pressure, a combustor burns fuel in it, and the hot gas, at 1,400 to 1,600 °C at the turbine inlet of the largest modern machines, expands through a turbine. The node Gas turbine shows the machine, and the node Aircraft engine uses the same loop with the exhaust turned into thrust.

The weak point of the loop is that the compressor eats a large share of the turbine's output, often half of it. Net work is a small difference between two large numbers, so every loss is magnified. That is why gas turbines only became practical when materials allowed a high inlet temperature. Blades are single crystals of nickel alloy, ceramic-coated and cooled by air through internal channels. The trade-off: each extra 50 K of inlet temperature buys efficiency, but cooling air steals part of the gain and blades must be replaced after set hours.

A simple-cycle gas turbine reaches 35 to 44 per cent. But the gas leaving the turbine is still 550 to 650 °C, well above the 40 °C of a condenser. A combined cycle puts a heat recovery boiler in that exhaust, raises steam, and runs a steam turbine from it. The gas turbine works at the top of the temperature range and the steam turbine at the bottom, so together they come close to the whole span of the Carnot limit. The flow figure shows the arithmetic for 100 units of fuel energy. The best whole-plant result, verified by Guinness World Records in 2024, is 64.18 per cent at Keadby 2 in England on a Siemens Energy turbine, a corrected gross figure under ISO test conditions.

A combined cycle is also cheaper per kilowatt to build than a coal plant and starts in an hour or less. Its weak point is fuel: natural gas has often been too dear for Indian plants to run steadily.

Process flowchart Flow: 100 units of gas energy through a combined cycle
Inputs Natural gas100 units of fuel heat Process steps 1 Gas turbine and generator

about 39 units become electricity; 61 units leave as exhaust at 550 to 650 °C

2 Heat recovery boiler

captures about 54 units of the exhaust heat as steam; 7 units leave up the stack

3 Steam turbine and generator

about 21 units become electricity; 33 units leave in the condenser

Outputs Electricity60 units (39 + 21) Condenser heat33 units Stack7 units

Round numbers for a modern large unit on the fuel's lower heating value; results calculated. GE Vernova and Siemens Energy both advertise about 64 per cent for their newest designs, and the verified record is 64.18 per cent. Compare the simple cycle at 39 and a coal plant at 36 per cent on the coal's gross heating value.

Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 8, 'Thermodynamics', section 8.2 ('Automobiles': heat engines and temperature)

See it in the table

H₂O WaterGas Natural gasNi NickelEl Electricity

Check your understanding

Why does a steam plant pump water before boiling it instead of compressing the steam?

A liquid is nearly incompressible, so raising its pressure costs only one to three per cent of turbine output. Compressing steam or air would take a large share of the work the expansion returns.

A diesel engine can use a higher compression ratio than a petrol engine mainly because

A petrol and air mixture squeezed too hard ignites early and knocks. A diesel compresses air alone and sprays fuel in at the top, so it can use ratios of 16 to 20 and gets higher efficiency.

In the combined cycle flow, why does the steam turbine add 21 units instead of the exhaust being wasted?

The exhaust is still a hot source relative to ambient, so a second engine can work between it and the condenser. The two loops together span a wider range of temperature, which is what the Carnot limit rewards.
← Part 2: The first and second laws: the audit and the limitMark read · Part 4: Refrigerators, air conditioners and heat pumps: moving heat uphill →