Vibration, waves and resonance in machines and structures: Why things vibrate: mass, springiness and damping
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 7: Vibration, waves and resonance in machines and structures Part 1 of 5Why things vibrate: mass, springiness and damping
A bouncing car, a swinging lamp and a humming wire share one story. Each has a mass that resists change and a spring-like force that pulls it back. This part shows how those two things fix the rate of vibration, why stiff and light things ring high, and how friction makes the ringing die away. Later parts depend on these three ideas.
1.1 Anything with mass and a restoring force will oscillate, and the two together fix its natural frequency
Flick a steel ruler held over the edge of a desk, tap a steel bucket, or watch a car bounce after a pothole. All three have the same two ingredients. There is a mass, which wants to keep moving, and there is a restoring force, which pulls the mass back towards its rest position. Pull the mass aside and let go. The force speeds it back, the mass overshoots, the force now acts the other way, and the cycle repeats. This repeated motion is vibration. The number of cycles per second is the frequency, measured in hertz (Hz), and the time for one cycle is the period.
Energy shows it well. At the ends of the motion it is stored in the spring; at the middle it is all motion, as in module 3, 'Force, motion and energy'. The pace of the swap is set by the system, not by how hard you pulled.
For a mass on a spring, the natural frequency is the square root of (stiffness / mass), divided by 2 x pi. Stiffness is the force needed per metre of stretch, the idea behind Young's modulus in module 4, 'Structures and materials'. A stiffer spring raises the frequency. A heavier mass lowers it. Quadruple the mass and the frequency halves. The size of the swing does not appear in the formula, so a car bounces at the same rate after a shallow ridge as after a deep pothole; only how far it moves changes. When gravity supplies the restoring force, as for a load hanging from a crane hook, the mass cancels out and only the cable length counts: period = 2 x pi x square root of (length / g). A load on 25 m of cable takes about 10 s for one full swing (calculated), which is why a 'Tower crane' driver moves slowly and lets the swing settle.
Estimate 1 puts numbers on it and finds the bounce near 1.3 Hz, which is close to the pace of a brisk walk. Designers aim there on purpose.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Sprung mass per corner | A 1,200 kg car; about 1,000 kg rests on springs; divide by 4, then add a little for the share of the engine: use 320 kg | 320 kg |
| Spring stiffness | A coil spring of 20 N per mm = 20,000 N/m | 20 kN/m |
| Static sag (check) | weight / stiffness = 320 x 9.81 / 20,000 | 0.157 m, so 157 mm |
| Natural frequency | square root of (20,000 / 320) = 7.9 per second; divide by 2 x pi (6.283) | 1.26 Hz, one bounce in 0.8 s |
| Four passengers added | extra 280 kg, 70 kg per corner: mass 390 kg; square root of (20,000 / 390) = 7.16; divide by 6.283 | 1.14 Hz, a slower bounce |
| Same answer from sag alone | frequency = 0.5 / square root of sag in metres = 0.5 / 0.396 | 1.26 Hz |
Units first: stiffness in N/m, mass in kg, so stiffness / mass is per second squared. Check: ordinary cars have body bounce between about 1 and 1.5 Hz, and a loaded car does bounce more slowly. The last row is a useful shortcut: how far a thing sags under its own weight gives its natural frequency without knowing mass or stiffness separately.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
1.2 Stiff and light things ring high, heavy and floppy things ring low
Because frequency rises with stiffness and falls with mass, a thing that is stiff for its weight vibrates fast.
Shape matters as much as material. Take a bar fixed at one end, like the ruler on the desk, a balcony, or a chimney. Its frequency rises in proportion to its thickness and falls with the square of its length. Halve the overhang and the frequency goes up four times. This follows from the second moment of area in module 4, which makes a thicker bar far stiffer, while a longer bar is both softer and heavier.
Material enters in a neat way. For bars of the same shape, the frequency scales with the square root of (modulus / density), which is also the speed at which a pulse travels along the material. Steel has a modulus of 200 GPa and density 7,850 kg/m3, giving about 5,050 m/s. Aluminium has 69 GPa and 2,700 kg/m3, which gives almost the same, 5,050 m/s. So a steel ruler and an aluminium ruler of the same size ring at nearly the same pitch, even though one is three times stiffer. The lighter metal is exactly as much softer as it is lighter. A plastic ruler, with a modulus around 3 GPa and a density near 1,200 kg/m3, gives about 1,600 m/s and rings about three times lower.
Estimate 2 works it out. The same rule explains why tall buildings and long bridges sway slowly: they are long and heavy for their stiffness.
| Case | Working: f = 0.56 x t / (3.46 x L^2) x square root of (E / density) | Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| Steel ruler, 1 mm thick, 200 mm overhang | 0.56 x 0.001 / (3.46 x 0.04) x 5,050 | 20 Hz |
| Same ruler, overhang cut to 100 mm | length squared falls to a quarter, so frequency x 4 | 82 Hz, a low audible note |
| Aluminium ruler, same size | square root of (69e9 / 2,700) = 5,055 m/s, almost equal to steel | 20 Hz |
| Plastic ruler, same size | square root of (3e9 / 1,200) = 1,580 m/s | 6.4 Hz |
| Steel ruler, 2 mm thick, 200 mm overhang | thickness doubles, so frequency x 2 | 41 Hz |
The constant 0.56 comes from solving the beam equation for a bar fixed at one end, and t / 3.46 is the radius of gyration of a thin strip. Check: at 20 Hz you see the ruler blur and hear a flutter rather than a note, and shortening it to a few centimetres more than does bring the pitch up into hearing, as the table says.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
1.3 Damping is the energy lost on every swing, and it decides how long a vibration lasts
No real vibration lasts for ever. The motion drains away as friction in joints, internal friction in the material, and the push of air turn it into heat. Engineers call this damping. A bell has very little, so it rings for many seconds. A car's shock absorber has a lot, so the body settles in about a swing.
The usual measure is the damping ratio, written zeta. Zero would mean no loss at all. A value of 1 is called critical damping: the thing returns to rest as fast as possible without overshooting once. Each cycle, the swing shrinks by a fixed fraction, whose size depends on zeta. Rough values for zeta: a struck bell or tuning fork, well below 0.01; a welded steel frame, about 0.01; a reinforced concrete building, 0.02 to 0.05; a car with healthy shock absorbers, 0.2 to 0.4.
The choice for a car is a trade-off. With a damping ratio near 0.7 the body settles very fast, but the damper itself carries a lot of every bump into the cabin. With 0.1 the ride is smooth for a moment and then wallows on. Around 0.3 gives a few well-behaved bounces, which is why the shock absorber (a piston forcing oil through small holes) is tuned there and not at the extreme. Estimate 3 shows what a worn damper costs.
Damping becomes the whole story near resonance, in the next part, because it alone sets how big the motion can grow. Engineers therefore add it deliberately, with oil dampers, rubber layers and tuned masses.
| Case | Fraction left after one cycle = exp(-2 x pi x zeta / square root of (1 - zeta^2)) | Cycles to fall to 5% (about 20 times smaller) | Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Car, healthy dampers, zeta 0.3, bounce 1.26 Hz | 0.139 | about 1.5 cycles | about 1.2 s |
| Car, worn dampers, zeta 0.05 | 0.73 | 9.5 cycles | about 7.5 s |
| Concrete building, zeta 0.02, sway 0.5 Hz | 0.88 | 24 cycles | about 48 s |
| Steel chimney, zeta 0.005, 1 Hz | 0.97 | 95 cycles | about 95 s |
The number of cycles to reach 5% is ln(20) / (2 x pi x zeta), where ln(20) = 3.0. Check: a mechanic's quick test is to push down on a car corner and let go. A healthy car comes up once and sits; a worn one keeps bouncing, which matches the table. Tall buildings do sway for a minute or so after a quake or a gust, as the last rows suggest.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
See it in the table
Al AluminiumSt SteelCheck your understanding
A mass on a spring is replaced by a mass four times as heavy on the same spring. What happens to the natural frequency?
Frequency goes with the square root of (stiffness / mass). Four times the mass gives half the frequency, since the square root of 4 is 2.A steel ruler and an aluminium ruler of identical size are held with the same overhang and flicked. Why do they vibrate at almost the same frequency?
Steel is about three times stiffer and about three times denser than aluminium. The ratio of modulus to density, which sets the frequency for a given shape, is nearly the same.A car's damping ratio is 0.05 instead of 0.3. What would you notice?
Low damping means little energy is lost each cycle, so the bounce lasts for many cycles. The natural frequency is set by mass and stiffness, not by damping.