Vibration, waves and resonance in machines and structures: Earthquakes, measuring vibration and avoiding resonance
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 7: Vibration, waves and resonance in machines and structures Part 5 of 5Earthquakes, measuring vibration and avoiding resonance
An earthquake is a forced vibration with the whole ground as the driver, and a tall building is a tuned structure with its own period. This part shows how those two meet, how Indian codes design buildings to sway without falling, and how engineers measure natural frequencies and keep machines and structures clear of them. It ends with resonance used on purpose, in a gauge that measures strain by its pitch.
5.1 An earthquake sends waves through the ground, and a building feels them as a push on every floor
When a fault slips, the rock rings like a struck bell and energy runs outward as waves. Three kinds matter. Primary (P) waves are compressions, like sound, and are the fastest, around 6 km/s in the crust. Secondary (S) waves shear the rock sideways, travel at about 3.5 km/s and cannot cross liquid. Surface waves, slower still, roll along the top of the ground and often shake buildings the most, with long periods.
The gap between the P and S arrivals gives distance. If the S waves trail the P waves by 30 s, then distance x (1 / 3.5 - 1 / 6) = 30, since the time in each case is distance over speed. The bracket is 0.119 s per km, so the distance is about 250 km. A seismometer is itself a use of part 2: a heavy mass hung softly on a spring stays nearly still when the frame under it moves, because the shaking is far above the instrument's own natural frequency, and the gap between mass and frame is the record.
Ground shaking contains many frequencies, and the soil changes the mix. Soft soil tends to amplify shaking and shift it towards longer periods, which is why damage often differs sharply across a city.
Now the building. Its foundation moves with the ground, but its upper floors, by inertia, want to stay put, so the structure is strained as it is dragged along. In module 3 terms, every floor feels a force of mass x acceleration, and the sum of those forces over all floors, applied at the base, is the base shear. Heavy buildings therefore attract larger forces than light ones of the same shape, which is one reason designers avoid heavy roofs and tanks on top.
P about 6 km/s, S about 3.5 km/s, surface waves slower
2 Local soilcan amplify the shaking and lengthen its period
3 Foundationmoves with the ground, back and forth, in all directions
4 Building swaynatural period decides how much the shaking is magnified
5 Inertia force on each floormass x acceleration, summed at the base as base shear
Outputs Sideways load on columns and wallsset by mass, period, soil and dampingEach link is a place where the engineer can intervene: soil, foundation, stiffness, mass or damping.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
5.2 A building has a natural period that rises with its height, and tall buildings sway slowly
A building is a vertical cantilever, like the ruler of part 1 stood on end. Its mass is spread up its height, its stiffness comes from columns, walls and frames, and it has a natural period of sway. Taller means a longer period, because height makes it both softer and heavier. A skyscraper may take five or more seconds to sway once each way.
Indian seismic practice gives a simple approximate formula for a reinforced concrete frame building: period in seconds = 0.075 x height in metres, raised to the power 0.75. Steel frames use 0.085. Buildings with masonry infill panels or shear walls have their own formula, with base width in it, because infill walls make a building much stiffer and shorter in period than a bare frame. Estimate 15 puts numbers on four heights.
Why does the period matter? Because the shaking of an earthquake contains most of its energy in a band of periods, and a structure responds most to the part of the shaking near its own period. A quick rule is about 0.1 s per storey. Short stiff buildings are pushed with high accelerations, and long flexible ones with lower accelerations but bigger swings of movement, so tall ones fear the long-period waves from far away earthquakes and soft soil, and low ones fear the nearby, sharp shaking.
The trade-off is built in. Stiffening a building shortens its period and can make it feel the strongest part of the shaking. Making it flexible lowers force but increases drift between floors, which breaks partitions, glass and pipes. Designers limit the drift, and use damping to reduce both.
| Building | Height (m) | Working: T = 0.075 x h^0.75 | Period (s) | Rule of thumb, 0.1 s per storey |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Three storeys, a school block | 10 | 10^0.75 = 5.62; x 0.075 | 0.42 | 0.3 |
| Ten storeys, a residential tower | 30 | 30^0.75 = 12.8; x 0.075 | 0.96 | 1.0 |
| Twenty storeys | 60 | 60^0.75 = 21.6; x 0.075 | 1.6 | 2.0 |
| Forty storeys | 120 | 120^0.75 = 36.2; x 0.075 | 2.7 | 4.0 |
Assumes about 3 m per storey and a bare concrete moment frame; infill walls in a real building shorten the period. The rule of thumb drifts high for tall buildings. Check: ten-storey buildings do sway about once a second in measured records, and a forty-storey tower sways more slowly than a person can count.
Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, Criteria for earthquake resistant design of structures, cl. 7.6.2, approximate fundamental period (RC moment frame 0.075 x h^0.75, steel 0.085 x h^0.75), via the Autodesk Robot Structural Analysis help page on IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, https://help.autodesk.com/cloudhelp/2025/ENU/RSAPRO-UsersGuide/files/GUID-1DFE3234-1AF0-4A7D-8744-C91C323C827E.htm; zone factors (II 0.10, III 0.16, IV 0.24, V 0.36), R = 5 for a special RC moment frame, Sa / g = 1.36 / T for medium soil from 0.55 to 4 s, and Ah = Z I Sa / (2 R g), read from the official text of the 2002 edition (Public.Resource.Org copy, https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.1893.1.2002.pdf), values the 2016 edition keeps- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, Criteria for earthquake resistant design of structures · cl. 7.6.2, approximate fundamental period (RC moment frame 0.075 x h^0.75, steel 0.085 x h^0.75), via the Autodesk Robot Structural Analysis help page on IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, https://help.autodesk.com/cloudhelp/2025/ENU/RSAPRO-UsersGuide/files/GUID-1DFE3234-1AF0-4A7D-8744-C91C323C827E.htm; zone factors (II 0.10, III 0.16, IV 0.24, V 0.36), R = 5 for a special RC moment frame, Sa / g = 1.36 / T for medium soil from 0.55 to 4 s, and Ah = Z I Sa / (2 R g), read from the official text of the 2002 edition (Public.Resource.Org copy, https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.1893.1.2002.pdf), values the 2016 edition keeps
- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
5.3 Buildings are designed to bend and yield without falling, and the code cuts the force on the strength of that ductility
A building struck by its strongest shaking in a lifetime would need enormous strength to stay elastic. That would cost far too much, so modern codes accept damage in a very strong earthquake and design for survival. The tool is ductility, the property from module 4: a member that can yield and deform a long way without breaking absorbs energy as it does so.
In the Indian code the design force on a building is the base shear, equal to a coefficient times the building's seismic weight. The coefficient is (Z / 2) x (I / R) x (Sa / g). Z is the zone factor, I an importance factor (above 1 for hospitals), Sa / g the spectral acceleration for the building's period and soil, and R the response reduction factor, 5 for a special ductile concrete frame. Z runs from 0.10 in zone II to 0.36 in zone V. These are the values of IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, back in force since a 2025 revision with a sixth zone was withdrawn in March 2026. R is the code's credit for ductility: with proper detailing, such as closely spaced stirrups in beam-column joints, the building may be designed for one fifth of the force it would feel if it stayed elastic. Estimate 16 works through a ten-storey building.
Detailing is where this succeeds or fails. Strong-column, weak-beam design makes the beams yield first, so the building does not collapse as a stack of failed columns. An open ground floor with no walls, used for parking, creates a soft storey where the sway concentrates in a few columns. After the magnitude 7.7 Bhuj earthquake in Gujarat on 26 January 2001, engineers linked many of the collapses of apartment blocks in Ahmedabad to such open ground storeys whose columns lacked the ductility to take it.
Base isolation takes the other route. A building set on laminated rubber and steel bearings (the 'Seismic base isolation' node) has its period lengthened to 2 to 3 s, so most of the ground's energy passes under it, and the bearings take the movement. The cost is a gap round the building for 200 to 400 mm of travel, and the bearings. It suits stiff, low-rise hospitals, not tall towers that already sway slowly.
| Quantity | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Zone factor Z | Zone V | 0.36 |
| Importance I, response reduction R | ordinary residential; special ductile frame | I = 1, R = 5 |
| Period and spectral value | T = 0.96 s from estimate 15; for medium soil between 0.55 and 4 s, Sa / g = 1.36 / T = 1.36 / 0.96 (calculated) | 1.42 |
| Design coefficient | (0.36 / 2) x (1 / 5) x 1.42 (calculated) | 0.051, about 5% of weight |
| Seismic weight W | 12 kN/m2 x 600 m2 per floor x 10 floors | 72,000 kN, about 7,300 tonnes |
| Design base shear | 0.051 x 72,000 (calculated) | about 3,700 kN, about 375 tonnes of force |
| If it had to stay elastic (R = 1) | 5 times larger | about 18,400 kN |
Sa / g comes from the code's spectrum for 5% damping on medium soil; the seismic weight per square metre is an assumed round value, and real weights vary. The base shear is spread up the height, larger on the upper floors, and each floor's share is carried down by columns and walls. Check: a coefficient of about 5% for zone V is the right order for a mid-rise frame, and the factor of five between rows is the price of not having ductility.
Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, Criteria for earthquake resistant design of structures, cl. 7.6.2, approximate fundamental period (RC moment frame 0.075 x h^0.75, steel 0.085 x h^0.75), via the Autodesk Robot Structural Analysis help page on IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, https://help.autodesk.com/cloudhelp/2025/ENU/RSAPRO-UsersGuide/files/GUID-1DFE3234-1AF0-4A7D-8744-C91C323C827E.htm; zone factors (II 0.10, III 0.16, IV 0.24, V 0.36), R = 5 for a special RC moment frame, Sa / g = 1.36 / T for medium soil from 0.55 to 4 s, and Ah = Z I Sa / (2 R g), read from the official text of the 2002 edition (Public.Resource.Org copy, https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.1893.1.2002.pdf), values the 2016 edition keeps- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, Criteria for earthquake resistant design of structures · cl. 7.6.2, approximate fundamental period (RC moment frame 0.075 x h^0.75, steel 0.085 x h^0.75), via the Autodesk Robot Structural Analysis help page on IS 1893 (Part 1):2016, https://help.autodesk.com/cloudhelp/2025/ENU/RSAPRO-UsersGuide/files/GUID-1DFE3234-1AF0-4A7D-8744-C91C323C827E.htm; zone factors (II 0.10, III 0.16, IV 0.24, V 0.36), R = 5 for a special RC moment frame, Sa / g = 1.36 / T for medium soil from 0.55 to 4 s, and Ah = Z I Sa / (2 R g), read from the official text of the 2002 edition (Public.Resource.Org copy, https://law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/S03/is.1893.1.2002.pdf), values the 2016 edition keeps
- Ghosh, 'Observations from the Bhuj Earthquake of January 26, 2001', PCI Journal, March to April 2001 · open ground storeys for parking as soft storeys; many collapses in Ahmedabad; https://www.pci.org/PCI_Docs/Publications/PCI%20Journal/2001/March-April/Observations%20From%20the%20Bhuj%20Earthquake%20of%20January%2026,%202001.pdf
- Murty, 'The 2001 Bhuj Earthquake', National Information Center of Earthquake Engineering, IIT Kanpur · magnitude 7.7, 26 January 2001; https://www.iitk.ac.in/nicee/EQ_Reports/Bhuj/report.htm
- Drishti IAS, 'Rollback of Seismic Code of 2025' (13 March 2026, read November 2026) · BIS withdrew IS 1893:2025; IS 1893 (Part 1):2016 back in effect; https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-analysis/rollback-of-seismic-code-of-2025
5.4 Engineers measure natural frequencies by tapping and listening, then keep operating speeds well clear of them
Natural frequencies can also be measured, most simply with a tap. Strike the structure with an instrumented hammer, record its response with an accelerometer, and look at the record in the frequency domain. A computer turns the record into a spectrum showing how much motion there is at each frequency, and the peaks are the natural frequencies.
Avoiding resonance is a matter of listing every frequency that can drive a machine, and comparing it with every natural frequency. A rotating machine drives at once per turn, twice per turn, at blade-pass rates and gear-mesh rates. A chart of those lines against speed is a Campbell diagram, and wherever a drive line crosses a natural frequency line there is a critical speed. Designers aim for a separation of at least 15 to 20% where the machine is to run, and pass quickly through crossings that cannot be avoided.
A wind turbine tower shows the idea (estimate 17). The rotor drives the tower once per turn (1P) and three times per turn from the three blades (3P). The tower's frequency is placed between the 1P and 3P bands. A stiffer tower above the 3P band would be safer but needs far more steel, so the usual choice is the cheaper middle band.
Resonance can also be a measuring tool. A vibrating-wire strain gauge, cast into dams, tunnel linings and foundations, is a short steel wire stretched between two anchors fixed in the concrete. A small coil plucks the wire and listens to its note. When the concrete stretches or shortens, the wire's tension changes and so does its pitch, since frequency squared goes with tension, as for the stay cable in part 3. A frequency survives hundreds of metres of cable far better than a small voltage, so such gauges can be read for many years (estimate 18). The gyroscopes among 'MEMS sensors' in a phone also work by keeping a tiny silicon structure vibrating at resonance.
| Question | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Rotor speed range 8 to 15 rpm: once-per-turn band (1P) | 8 / 60 = 0.13 Hz to 15 / 60 = 0.25 Hz | 0.13 to 0.25 Hz |
| Blade-passing band (3P) | 3 x those values | 0.40 to 0.75 Hz |
| Tower chosen at 0.32 Hz: margin above 1P, below 3P | 0.32 / 0.25 = 1.28; 0.40 / 0.32 = 1.25 | 28% and 25% clear |
| Gauge wire 0.10 m long, set to sound 1,000 Hz: wave speed | 2 x 0.10 x 1,000 | 200 m/s |
| Stress in the wire = density x speed^2 | 7,850 x 200^2 (calculated) | 314 MPa, a strain of 314e6 / 200e9 = 1,570 microstrain |
| Concrete stretches by 100 microstrain | 1,000 x square root of (1,670 / 1,570) (calculated) | 1,031 Hz, a clear 31 Hz rise |
| Smallest strain seen if the reader resolves 0.1 Hz | strain change = 2 x (0.1 / 1,000) x 1,570 (calculated) | about 0.3 microstrain |
The speed range, tower frequency and gauge dimensions are illustrative; real turbines and gauges vary. For a wire, tension / mass per metre equals stress / density, so the wire's own size drops out. Check: the 25 to 28% margins match the usual aim of keeping at least 15 to 20% clear of each drive band, and a resolution well under one microstrain is why these gauges are used to watch slow creep and shrinkage in concrete.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves' (waves on a taut string)- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
See it in the table
St SteelSi SiliconCheck your understanding
For a ten-storey concrete frame building, which period is the best estimate?
The code formula gives about 0.96 s for a 30 m building, and the rule of thumb of 0.1 s per storey agrees.Why does the Indian code allow a design force of one fifth of the elastic force for a special ductile frame?
The response reduction factor credits ductility, the ability to deform and absorb energy without collapsing, provided the detailing is right.On a Campbell diagram, a crossing of a drive line with a natural frequency line marks
At such a crossing the driving frequency matches a natural one, so the response is magnified.