Vibration, waves and resonance in machines and structures: Balancing, waves and sound
All courses / Understanding Engineering / Module 7: Vibration, waves and resonance in machines and structures Part 3 of 5Balancing, waves and sound
A vibration that leaves its source becomes a wave. This part starts with the rotating parts that cause so many vibrations and how they are balanced, then follows the disturbance as it travels: along a taut steel cable, through air as sound, and into the ear. It ends with pitch and loudness, and the decibel scale that engineers use for the second.
3.1 Balancing puts a rotating part's centre of mass on its axis, and the force it removes grows with the square of speed
The fan and the washing machine had an off-centre mass. Engineers cure this by balancing: adding or removing a small mass so that the centre of mass sits on the axis. For a thin disc such as a car wheel, one correction in the plane of the disc is enough. For a long rotor, such as a crankshaft or a turbine rotor, a single correction is not enough, because two equal and opposite off-centre masses at the two ends cancel the net sideways pull but still twist the shaft as it turns. These need corrections in at least two planes. Hence the terms static balance for one plane and dynamic balance for two.
Car tyre fitters spin each wheel on a machine that senses the shaking and shows where to clip a small weight on the rim, usually a few grams up to about 60 g. Estimate 8 shows why such a small mass matters. The pull is 20 g x (angular speed)^2 x radius, and the speed enters squared, so the shake at 120 km/h is nine times the shake at 40 km/h. The wheel's turning rate at highway speed also falls in the 10 to 20 Hz range, where a wheel and its suspension commonly have resonances of their own, so the steering wheel starts to shimmy at about 80 to 100 km/h, then often fades at higher speed, as in the fan.
A long shaft is itself flexible and has a bending natural frequency of its own. At that turning rate, called a critical speed, the shaft bows out and whirls, and any imbalance is magnified. Big 'Steam turbine' and 'Gas turbine' rotors run above their first critical speed and pass through it quickly on start-up, and are balanced to a few grams on tonnes. Leftover unbalance wears out a 'Rolling bearing' long before its stated life, so balancing is worth its cost.
| Speed (km/h) | Speed (m/s) | Wheel turning rate (rad/s, Hz) | Out-of-balance pull = 0.02 x w^2 x 0.19 (N) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | 11.1 | 37, 5.9 Hz | 5 |
| 60 | 16.7 | 56, 8.8 Hz | 12 |
| 80 | 22.2 | 74, 11.8 Hz | 21 |
| 100 | 27.8 | 93, 14.7 Hz | 33 |
| 120 | 33.3 | 111, 17.7 Hz | 47 |
Turning rate = speed / rolling radius. Hz = rad/s / 2 x pi. A pull of 33 N is the weight of 3.3 kg, rotating once every 70 ms, and it acts on a wheel and hub that sit on springs of their own. Check: the pull at 120 km/h is (120/40)^2 = 9 times that at 40 km/h, matching 47 / 5. Garage practice is to balance to within a few grams, and the shimmy is typically felt in the 80 to 100 km/h band.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
3.2 A wave is a disturbance that travels without carrying material along, and a taut cable shows how wave speed and frequency are linked
Strike a tight steel cable, such as one of the stays of a cable-stayed bridge, and a kink runs along it to the anchor, reflects and runs back. The steel at any point only moves sideways and returns; what travels is the shape, and the energy goes with it. Every wave obeys one bookkeeping rule: speed = frequency x wavelength. Sound, water and earthquake waves follow it, and so do light and radio (module 9).
On a cable the speed is set by two things: speed = square root of (tension / mass per metre). Pull harder and the kink runs faster; make the cable heavier and it runs slower. When waves bounce to and fro between two fixed ends, only those that fit a whole number of half wavelengths into the length survive, and they form a standing wave that stays in place. The longest that fits has a half wavelength equal to the length L, so the lowest frequency, the fundamental, is speed / (2 x L). The next patterns, with one, two and three still points along the cable, vibrate at two, three and four times the fundamental. These are the harmonics.
Turn the rule round and it becomes a measuring tool. Tension is hard to measure on a finished bridge, because there is nowhere to put a load cell. Frequency is easy: fix an accelerometer to the stay, let wind and traffic shake it, and read the peaks in the record. From the fundamental, the length and the mass per metre, tension = 4 x mass per metre x L^2 x frequency^2. Since tension goes with frequency squared, a 1% fall in frequency means a 2% loss of tension, which is how inspectors spot a slipping anchor or broken wires.
Estimate 9 finds the tension in one stay and shows how small a change the method can see.
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Stay length L (assumed) | anchor to anchor | 100 m |
| Mass per metre (assumed) | 55 steel strands of about 150 mm2 at 1.18 kg/m each = 65 kg/m, plus sheath and filler | 70 kg/m |
| Measured fundamental (assumed) | first peak in the acceleration record; harmonics near 2.4, 3.6 and 4.8 Hz confirm it | 1.20 Hz |
| Wave speed = 2 x L x f | 2 x 100 x 1.20 | 240 m/s |
| Tension = mass per metre x speed^2 | 70 x 240^2 = 70 x 57,600 (calculated) | 4.03 MN, about 410 tonnes of force |
| Stress in the steel | 4.03e6 N / (55 x 150e-6 m2) = 4.03e6 / 0.00825 (calculated) | 490 MPa |
| Against strand breaking strength of about 1,860 MPa | 490 / 1,860 | 26%, well under a common service limit of about 45% |
| Frequency later reads 1.188 Hz (1% lower) | tension x 0.99^2 = x 0.980 (calculated) | about 80 kN lost, worth investigating |
Units: kg/m x (m/s)^2 = kg m/s^2 = N. The strand area, mass and strength are typical of 15.7 mm prestressing strand and are assumptions for this illustration, as are the length and frequency. Check: long stays on real bridges do have fundamentals of about 0.5 to 2 Hz, and the vibration method is a standard way to check stay forces. A sitar string obeys the same rule: it is shorter and far lighter, so its fundamental is in the hundreds of hertz.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
3.3 Sound is a pressure wave in air, and its wavelength explains why bass goes round corners
A speaker cone or vibrating string pushes on the air next to it. The push squeezes a layer of air, which squeezes the next layer, and so a pulse of higher and lower pressure passes outward. Unlike the wave on a cable, where the motion is sideways, in sound the air moves back and forth along the direction of travel.
The speed of sound in air depends on temperature, not on loudness or pitch. At 20 degrees Celsius it is about 343 m/s, and it rises by about 0.6 m/s for each degree of warming. In water it is about 1,500 m/s, and in steel about 5,000 m/s, because stiffer materials carry the pulse faster.
With speed known, wavelength follows: wavelength = speed / frequency. A low note of 100 Hz has a wavelength of 3.4 m, longer than a door, so it flows round obstacles and leaks through walls, which is why you hear the thump of bass next door but not the words. A high note of 10 kHz has a wavelength of 3.4 cm and casts a sharper shadow.
A pipe of air has resonances of its own. A tube closed at one end and open at the other resonates when its length is a quarter of a wavelength, at speed / (4 x L), and at odd multiples of that. Engineers use this to silence engines. A closed side branch on an exhaust or intake pipe sends the sound back half a cycle out of step, and it cancels the tone it was cut for. To kill a 100 Hz drone in cool air the branch must be 0.86 m long, but sound runs faster in hot exhaust gas, so the branch has to be longer. The trade-off is that such a branch works only near one frequency and its odd multiples, and it takes space. Estimate 10 gathers the numbers, including echo timing in ranging devices.
| Question | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Wavelength at 100 Hz in air at 20 degrees Celsius | 343 / 100 | 3.4 m |
| Wavelength at 440 Hz | 343 / 440 | 0.78 m |
| Wavelength at 10 kHz | 343 / 10,000 | 3.4 cm |
| Quarter-wave branch to cancel 100 Hz in air at 20 degrees Celsius | 343 / (4 x 100) (calculated) | 0.86 m |
| Same branch in exhaust gas at about 350 degrees Celsius | speed = 331 x square root of (623 / 273) = 500 m/s; 500 / (4 x 100) (calculated) | 1.25 m |
| Gap between lightning and thunder: 3 seconds | distance = 343 x 3 | about 1 km |
| Sonar echo returns 4 s after the ping in sea water | distance = 1,500 x 4 / 2 | 3 km |
| Ultrasound echo from 15 cm deep in tissue | time = 2 x 0.15 / 1,540 | about 0.2 ms (195 microseconds) |
Echo ranging halves the time because the pulse goes out and comes back. The speed in soft tissue, about 1,540 m/s, is the figure medical scanners assume. Check: counting seconds between flash and bang and dividing by three is the old rule for kilometres, and it agrees with 343 m/s. See the nodes 'Sound waves', 'Sonar' and 'Medical ultrasound'.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
3.4 Pitch follows frequency, loudness follows intensity, and the decibel scale compresses a huge range into a few tens
The ear judges pitch by frequency. Young ears hear from about 20 Hz to 20 kHz. What they sense is the ratio between frequencies and not the difference: a note at 880 Hz is an octave above 440 Hz, as 440 Hz is above 220 Hz, even though the first gap is 440 Hz and the second only 220. In equal temperament each of the 12 semitones in an octave is a factor of 1.0595.
Loudness is judged from the intensity of the sound, the power per square metre, but the ear is also logarithmic. The quietest sound heard is about 1e-12 W/m2 and sounds that hurt are about 1 W/m2, a range of a million million. To handle that, engineers use the decibel (dB): level = 10 x log10 (intensity / 1e-12 W/m2). Every factor of 10 in intensity adds 10 dB. Doubling the intensity adds 3 dB. Since intensity is proportional to pressure squared, a factor of 10 in sound pressure is 20 dB.
Three working rules follow. A change of 10 dB sounds about twice as loud, and 3 dB is just noticeable. Two equal sources add 3 dB, and a source 10 dB quieter than another adds almost nothing. In the open, each doubling of the distance from a small source lowers the level by 6 dB. Sound meters usually apply an A-weighting, written dB(A), which discounts the low and very high notes to match the ear, and regulations are written in dB(A). A common occupational guide treats about 85 dB(A) over eight hours as the level at which ear protection is needed, for example in the guidance of the US NIOSH.
Estimate 11 shows how decibel arithmetic works for a few everyday cases.
| Case | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Intensity ratio for +20 dB | 10^(20/10) | 100 times the power, 10 times the pressure |
| Two machines, each 70 dB at your ear | 10 x log10(2) = 3.0, added to 70 | 73 dB |
| One at 70 dB and one at 60 dB | relative intensities 10^7 and 10^6 add to 1.1 x 10^7; level = 10 x log10(1.1 x 10^7) | 70.4 dB: the quieter one hardly matters |
| Ten identical machines, 70 dB each | 70 + 10 x log10(10) | 80 dB |
| A source gives 80 dB at 1 m; level at 4 m in open air | 80 - 20 x log10(4) = 80 - 12 | 68 dB |
| Same source at 10 m | 80 - 20 x log10(10) | 60 dB |
The distance rule assumes a small source with nothing reflecting; indoors, walls bounce the sound and the fall is slower. Reference values: 1e-12 W/m2 corresponds to a pressure of 20 micropascals. Check: a conversation at about 60 dB heard at 1 m becomes 40 dB at 10 m, which is the quietness of a library.
Source: Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015), ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'- Bloomfield, How Things Work (Wiley, 2015) · ch. 9, 'Resonance and Mechanical Waves'
See it in the table
H₂O WaterSt SteelCheck your understanding
A car wheel with a 20 g imbalance is driven first at 50 km/h and then at 100 km/h. How does the out-of-balance pull compare?
The pull is mass x (angular speed)^2 x radius, so doubling the speed gives four times the force.The measured fundamental frequency of a stay cable is 10% higher than last year, with nothing else changed. How has its tension changed?
Tension goes with frequency squared: 1.1 x 1.1 = 1.21, so the tension is about 21% higher. Frequency alone rises only with the square root of tension.A machine in a room gives 70 dB at your ear. A second, identical machine is switched on. The level becomes about
Doubling the intensity adds 3 dB, since 10 x log10(2) = 3. Decibels are not added like ordinary numbers.