Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Carbon chemistry: from hydrocarbons to polymers: Why carbon is special: four bonds, chains, rings and the end of vitalism

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 12: Carbon chemistry: from hydrocarbons to polymers Part 1 of 6

Why carbon is special: four bonds, chains, rings and the end of vitalism

Carbon forms millions of compounds, more than all other elements together. This part shows why: four bonds, strong links to itself, and shapes that branch or close into rings. It starts with the 1828 experiment that weakened the belief in a vital force and ends with molecules that share a formula yet behave differently.

1.1 Wöhler made urea from a mineral salt in 1828, and organic chemistry came to mean the chemistry of carbon, not of life

Look at a pot of curry, a cotton shirt and a petrol pump. For centuries chemists thought the first two belonged to a different kind of chemistry from the third. Substances from plants and animals were called organic. Salt and quartz were inorganic. Many held that a living body carried a special vital force, and that only it could build organic matter. A flask could never do so.

In 1828 Friedrich Wöhler, a German chemist, was heating ammonium cyanate, a salt that looks mineral. He found crystals that matched urea, the main nitrogen waste in mammal urine. He wrote to his teacher Berzelius that he could make urea without a kidney. The two substances had the same atoms in the same proportions, N2H4CO, arranged differently. That was a second shock, because chemists had assumed composition fixed identity.

The result was not a clean knockout. Wöhler himself was cautious, and urea is a simple waste product, not a living tissue. Vitalism faded over decades as more compounds fell to the flask. Hermann Kolbe made acetic acid from its elements in 1845, and chemists later built fats and sugars.

The word organic survives with a narrower meaning. To a chemist, organic chemistry is the study of compounds built on carbon, almost always with hydrogen, and often with oxygen, nitrogen, sulphur or halogens. In a shop, organic means farmed without synthetic chemicals, which is another matter.

Data Two substances, one set of atoms
PropertyAmmonium cyanateUrea
Formula (atoms in one unit)N2H4CON2H4CO
How the atoms are joinedIons: NH4+ and OCN-One molecule: two NH2 groups on a carbon-oxygen double bond
Where it was foundPrepared in the laboratory from mineral saltsWaste product of mammals; also made industrially for fertiliser
Amount in 100 g (molar mass 60 g per mole)100 / 60 = 1.67 mol, holding 3.33 mol of nitrogen atoms (calculated)1.67 mol, holding 3.33 mol of nitrogen atoms (calculated)

Same atoms, same mass, different arrangement. Urea is the world's most used nitrogen fertiliser; see the node 'Urea'.

Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Friedrich Wohler, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Friedrich-Wohler (in 1828 Wohler told Berzelius he had made urea without the use of a living kidney; urea has the same composition as ammonium cyanate; later supporters called it the death knell of vitalism, though Wohler's own anti-vitalist claims were muted and qualified)
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 14, 'Organic Compounds'
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, Friedrich Wohler · web
  • Standard histories of organic chemistry and polymers, as summarised in the ACS National Historic Chemical Landmarks and Encyclopaedia Britannica · standard dates not re-fetched: Kolbe's acetic acid (1845), Hoffmann's aspirin at Bayer (1897), Goodyear's vulcanisation (1839), Staudinger's Nobel Prize (1953), Ziegler and Natta (Nobel 1963), Heeger, MacDiarmid and Shirakawa (Nobel 2000)

1.2 Carbon makes four bonds and holds on to itself, which lets it build chains, branches and rings that no other element matches

A carbon atom has four electrons in its outer shell, as module 8 (Atoms, the periodic table and the quantum idea) showed. Sharing each with a neighbour gives four covalent bonds, as module 10 (Matter and bonding) explained. Four bonds spread as far apart as they can, pointing to the corners of a tetrahedron, about 109.5 degrees apart.

Two facts then make carbon exceptional. A carbon-carbon bond is strong, about 346 kJ per mole, and a carbon-hydrogen bond is stronger still, about 413. Carbon can also use one, two or three of its bonds on a single neighbour, giving single, double and triple links. Silicon, directly below carbon in the table, tells the story by contrast. A silicon-silicon bond is only about 222 kJ per mole, while a silicon-oxygen bond is about 452. Silicon chains are therefore easily broken by oxygen and water, and rock is made of silicon-oxygen frameworks. A carbon-oxygen single bond (about 358) is barely stronger than a carbon-carbon one, so trading a carbon neighbour for an oxygen gains little. Burning a hydrocarbon to carbon dioxide and water releases much energy, but needs a push to start (module 11), so chains survive for millions of years until lit. Silane, SiH4, by contrast catches fire in air unaided.

The idea that atoms in a molecule are linked in a definite pattern came from Kekulé and, separately, Archibald Couper in 1857 and 1858: carbon is tetravalent and carbon atoms join each other. Aleksandr Butlerov, from 1861, argued that how atoms are arranged, not just which atoms are present, fixes a substance's behaviour. The site's node 'Structural theory of organic chemistry' follows this story.

Data Why carbon, not silicon, builds long chains (approximate mean bond energies)
BondEnergy (kJ per mole)Meaning
C-C346Strong; chains survive
C-H413Stronger than C-C; hydrogen caps the chain ends
C-O358Close to C-C; trading a carbon neighbour for oxygen gains little
Si-Si222Weak; silicon chains are fragile
Si-O452Much stronger than Si-Si; silicon ends up bonded to oxygen as silica and silicates

Compare module 11, Chemical reactions, where bond energies were used to find the heat of a reaction.

Source: Rounded standard reference values (bond energies, boiling points, densities, molar masses, heating values) as tabulated in the CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics and the NIST Chemistry WebBook, quoted to two or three figures as round numbers for estimates; not re-fetched in this session

1.3 Isomers share a formula but not a structure, and the number of possible molecules grows explosively with chain length

Count the atoms in C4H10. Two different substances fit. In butane the four carbons form one chain. In methylpropane, also called isobutane, three carbons form a chain and the fourth hangs off the middle. Same atoms, same mass, yet butane boils at about minus 1 degree C and methylpropane at about minus 12. Molecules with one formula and different bonding are structural isomers. Wöhler and Liebig had already found in the 1820s that silver cyanate and silver fulminate share one composition, and urea gave another such pair. In 1830 Berzelius named the effect isomerism.

The difference in boiling point comes from module 10. Dispersion forces act over the surface where molecules touch. A branched, rounder molecule touches its neighbours over less area, so it is less sticky and boils at a lower temperature.

Two other ideas are worth separating. Configuration is the pattern of which atom is bonded to which, and changing it needs bonds to break. Conformation is the shape a molecule takes by twisting around single bonds, which spin freely at room temperature, so a chain flexes through countless conformations and remains the same molecule. A double bond does not rotate, so groups fixed on its same side or opposite sides give cis and trans forms, which are separate substances.

Data Same formula, different behaviour
FormulaSubstanceBoiling point (degrees C)State at 25 degrees C
C4H10Butane (straight chain)-1Gas, liquefied under pressure in cylinders
C4H10Methylpropane (branched)-12Gas
C5H12Pentane36Liquid
C5H122-methylbutane28Liquid
C5H122,2-dimethylpropane10Gas on a warm day
C2H6OEthanol78Liquid; hydrogen bonds
C2H6ODimethyl ether-25Gas; no hydrogen bonds

The last pair shows how much bonding pattern matters: ethanol has an O-H group that makes hydrogen bonds, dimethyl ether does not.

Source: Rounded standard reference values (bond energies, boiling points, densities, molar masses, heating values) as tabulated in the CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics and the NIST Chemistry WebBook, quoted to two or three figures as round numbers for estimates; not re-fetched in this session
  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 14, 'Organic Compounds'
  • Rounded standard reference values (bond energies, boiling points, densities, molar masses, heating values) as tabulated in the CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics and the NIST Chemistry WebBook · quoted to two or three figures as round numbers for estimates; not re-fetched in this session
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, Friedrich Wohler · web

See it in the table

H₂O WaterSi SiliconAg SilverNaCl SaltCt CottonH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenCO2 Carbon dioxideUr UreaAcOH Acetic acid

Check your understanding

What did Wöhler's 1828 experiment show?

He made urea from ammonium cyanate. This weakened the idea that only living bodies could make organic matter, although the vital-force belief faded slowly rather than in one stroke. The two substances share the same atoms, so the last option is wrong.

Why does carbon form so many more compounds than silicon?

C-C is 346 kJ per mole and C-O 358, so carbon gains little by trading carbon neighbours for oxygen. Si-Si is 222 and Si-O 452, so silicon gains a great deal and ends up surrounded by oxygen.

How many hydrogens does a saturated, open-chain molecule with 6 carbons hold?

The rule is 2n + 2, so 2 x 6 + 2 = 14. This is hexane, C6H14. A ring with six carbons would hold 12.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: Hydrocarbons, crude oil and fuels →