Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions: Electronegativity, shape and polarity: why water is bent and polar
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 10: Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions Part 4 of 6Electronegativity, shape and polarity: why water is bent and polar
Real bonds are rarely shared equally, and that decides whether a molecule has a positive and a negative end. This part measures the tug with Pauling's scale, predicts shape from electron-pair repulsion, and combines the two to show why water is polar and carbon dioxide is not.
4.1 Electronegativity measures an atom's pull on shared electrons, and the difference between two atoms sets how lopsided their bond is
In a bond between two identical atoms, such as Cl-Cl, the shared pair sits midway. In a bond between hydrogen and chlorine, the pair is pulled towards chlorine, whose outer electrons feel a stronger pull from its nucleus. The bond is still shared, but unequally, so chlorine carries a small negative charge and hydrogen a small positive one. Chemists write these partial charges as delta minus and delta plus. Such a bond is polar covalent.
Linus Pauling gave this pull a number in 1932. His idea was ingenious and uses only energies. If A and B shared equally, the A-B bond energy should be about the average of the A-A and B-B bond energies. Measured A-B bonds are stronger than that average, and the extra is greater the more unequal the two atoms are. Pauling turned the excess into a scale of electronegativity, with fluorine at 3.98, the highest, and the alkali metals near 1 or less. The scale rises across a period and falls down a group, the same pattern as ionisation energy in the atoms and periodic table module, for the same reason: nuclear pull against shielding. Pauling summed up his work in the 1939 book The Nature of the Chemical Bond and won the 1954 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for it.
The difference in electronegativity sets the type of bond, but as a gradual slope and not a pair of boxes. A small difference gives a nearly equal bond, a middling one a polar covalent bond and a large one an almost fully ionic bond. Pauling gave a rule of thumb for the percentage of ionic character: one minus the exponential of minus a quarter of the difference squared.
| Bond | Electronegativities | Difference | Ionic character, 1 - exp(- difference squared / 4) | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cl-Cl | 3.16 and 3.16 | 0 | 0 per cent | Equal sharing |
| C-H | 2.55 and 2.20 | 0.35 | 3 per cent | Nearly nonpolar |
| N-H | 3.04 and 2.20 | 0.84 | 16 per cent | Polar covalent |
| O-H | 3.44 and 2.20 | 1.24 | 32 per cent | Polar covalent |
| H-F | 3.98 and 2.20 | 1.78 | 55 per cent | Strongly polar |
| Na-Cl | 3.16 and 0.93 | 2.23 | 71 per cent | Mostly ionic |
Values are Pauling's electronegativities as widely tabulated. The percentage is Pauling's own approximation and not a measured quantity.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Linus Pauling, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Linus-Pauling (1954 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for research into the nature of the chemical bond; a scale giving a number for an atom's power of attracting electrons in a covalent bond; The Nature of the Chemical Bond, 1939); Oregon State University Libraries, Linus Pauling and The Nature of the Chemical Bond: a documentary history, https://scarc.library.oregonstate.edu/coll/pauling/bond/papers/1932p.11-02.html (The nature of the chemical bond. IV. The energy of single bonds and the relative electronegativity of atoms, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 54 (1932) 3570-3582)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Chemical Bonds and Mixtures'
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Linus Pauling · web
- Oregon State University Libraries, Linus Pauling and The Nature of the Chemical Bond: a documentary history · web
4.2 Electron pairs repel and spread out, which fixes the shape of a molecule and bends water at 104.5 degrees
Each bonded pair and each unshared (lone) pair of valence electrons is a cloud of negative charge, and clouds repel. So they arrange themselves as far apart as they can around the central atom. This is the valence-shell electron-pair repulsion model, VSEPR for short, introduced by Nevil Sidgwick and Herbert Powell in 1940 and developed by Ronald Gillespie and Ronald Nyholm in 1957.
Count the clouds around the central atom. Two clouds sit opposite each other, giving a line, 180 degrees. Three spread in a flat triangle, 120 degrees. Four reach furthest apart at the corners of a tetrahedron, and geometry gives that angle as 109.5 degrees, the angle whose cosine is minus one third. Methane has four bonded pairs and is a perfect tetrahedron. Ammonia has four clouds too, but one is a lone pair. A lone pair is held by only one nucleus, so it spreads wider and squeezes the bonded pairs, closing the angle to 107 degrees. Water has four clouds, two lone pairs and two bonds. The two lone pairs squeeze harder, so the bond angle is 104.5 degrees.
So water is bent because oxygen keeps two lone pairs: its four clouds point to the corners of a tetrahedron, and only two corners hold atoms.
How do we know? Infrared and microwave spectra, X-ray and electron diffraction and dipole measurements all agree on the angles.
| Molecule | Valence electrons on centre | Bonds | Lone pairs | Clouds | Shape | Angle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CO2 | 4 | 2 double | 0 | 2 | Straight line | 180 degrees |
| BF3 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 3 | Flat triangle | 120 degrees |
| CH4 | 4 | 4 | 0 | 4 | Tetrahedron | 109.5 degrees |
| NH3 | 5 | 3 | 1 | 4 | Pyramid | 107 degrees |
| H2O | 6 | 2 | 2 | 4 | Bent | 104.5 degrees |
A double bond counts as one cloud. The tetrahedral angle is arccos(-1/3) = 109.47 degrees, found by asking how far apart four points on a sphere can be.
Source: R. J. Gillespie, Citation Classic commentary on Gillespie and Nyholm, Inorganic stereochemistry, Quarterly Reviews of the Chemical Society 11 (1957) 339-380, https://garfield.library.upenn.edu/classics1984/A1984SP02000001.pdf (the relation between bond geometry and the number of valence-shell electron pairs was pointed out earlier by Sidgwick and Powell, Proc. Roy. Soc. A 176 (1940) 153-180; electron pairs in the valence shell keep as far apart as possible; Gillespie named it the VSEPR theory)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Chemical Bonds and Mixtures'
- R. J. Gillespie, Citation Classic commentary on Gillespie and Nyholm, Inorganic stereochemistry, Quarterly Reviews of the Chemical Society 11 (1957) 339-380 · web
4.3 A molecule is polar only if its polar bonds do not cancel, so bent water is polar and straight carbon dioxide is not
A polar bond is like a tiny arrow pointing from the positive end to the negative end. A whole molecule has a polarity only if the arrows, added as vectors, leave something over. Shape decides.
Carbon dioxide has two strongly polar C=O bonds, but they point in opposite directions along a line, so they cancel exactly. Its measured dipole moment is zero. Methane and carbon tetrachloride cancel by symmetry. Water has two polar O-H bonds at 104.5 degrees, so both pull the same way and their sum points through the oxygen, between the hydrogens. Ammonia too has a net dipole. Measured dipole moments are 1.85 debye for water and 1.47 debye for ammonia. This test was Peter Debye's. His measurements of dipole moments, work that the 1936 Nobel Prize in Chemistry recognised, helped establish that water must be bent, because a straight H-O-H would have no dipole.
The arithmetic runs both ways. Each O-H arrow makes half the bend angle, 52.25 degrees, with the line that splits the molecule, so the total is twice one bond's share times cos 52.25 degrees, or 1.22 times one bond. Divide the measured 1.85 debye by 1.22 and each O-H bond contributes about 1.5 debye, the value tables quote. That 1.5 is inferred from water, so it cannot test the angle. The real test is simpler: in a straight molecule each arrow makes 90 degrees with that line, the cosine is zero and the sum vanishes, so any dipole at all rules the straight shape out.
Polarity matters because charges attract. Polar molecules attract each other and attract ions, and that is why water dissolves salt and sugar, why water is such a good solvent for life, and why a microwave oven heats food: the oven's changing electric field twists polar water molecules back and forth.
| Molecule | Polar bonds? | Shape | Do bond arrows cancel? | Dipole moment (debye) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CO2 | Yes, C=O | Straight | Yes | 0 |
| CH4 | Slightly, C-H | Tetrahedral | Yes | 0 |
| O2 | No | Straight | No bonds to cancel | 0 |
| H2O | Yes, O-H | Bent | No | 1.85 |
| NH3 | Yes, N-H | Pyramid | No | 1.47 |
| HF | Yes, H-F | Straight | One arrow only | 1.82 |
Water: 1.85 D / (2 x cos 52.25 degrees) = 1.51 D per O-H bond (calculated). That bond value is taken from water itself, so it checks consistency and does not predict the dipole independently.
Source: NC State University (Pressbooks), Organic Chemistry, 2.2 Polar covalent bonds and dipole moments, https://ncstate.pressbooks.pub/organicchem/chapter/polar-covalent-bonds-and-dipole-moments-2/ (dipole moments: water 1.85 D, ammonia 1.47 D, methane 0 D, carbon dioxide 0 D); LibreTexts Chemistry (university-hosted), Map: Organic Chemistry (Smith), 1.7 Polarity of molecules, https://chem.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Organic_Chemistry/Map%3A_Organic_Chemistry_(Smith)/01%3A_Structure_and_Bonding/1.07%3A_Polarity_of_Molecules (bond moment of the O-H bond 1.5 D, net 2(1.5) x cos(104.5/2) = 1.84 D; HF 1.82 D)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Chemical Bonds and Mixtures'
- OpenStax (Rice University), Organic Chemistry, section 2.2, Polar covalent bonds and dipole moments · web
- Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1936, summary · web
- NC State University (Pressbooks), Organic Chemistry, 2.2 Polar covalent bonds and dipole moments · web
- LibreTexts Chemistry (university-hosted), Map: Organic Chemistry (Smith), 1.7 Polarity of molecules · web
See it in the table
H₂O WaterCs CaesiumNaCl SaltSu SugarCl2 ChlorineH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenCO2 Carbon dioxideNH3 AmmoniaCheck your understanding
Which of these bonds is the most polar?
Polarity grows with the difference in electronegativity: 0.35, 0.84, 1.24 and 0 respectively.Nitrogen trifluoride has three bonds and one lone pair on nitrogen. Which shape does VSEPR predict?
Four clouds make a tetrahedral arrangement, and with one cloud being a lone pair the atoms form a pyramid, like ammonia.Carbon dioxide has polar bonds but a dipole moment of zero because
Equal arrows in opposite directions sum to zero. Water has the same two arrows at an angle, so they add up.