Material Insights · Understanding the Material World

Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions: Substances, elements and mixtures: sorting matter by what it is

All courses / Understanding Science / Module 10: Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions Part 1 of 6

Substances, elements and mixtures: sorting matter by what it is

Chemistry begins with a sorting question: is this one substance or several, and did a change make something new? This part separates physical from chemical change, shows how Lavoisier and Dalton made chemistry a counting science, explains formulas and names, and ends with separating mixtures.

1.1 A chemical change makes a new substance and a physical change does not, so identity is the test

Leave a lump of camphor in an open dish and it shrinks, then vanishes, leaving a sharp smell and no puddle. Light another lump and it burns with a sooty flame. Both are changes, but of different kinds. In the first, camphor molecules have gone into the air as camphor molecules. In the second, camphor has joined with oxygen and turned into carbon dioxide, water vapour and soot, none of which smells or burns like camphor.

A pure substance is a material of one fixed make-up, such as water, iron or table salt. Its physical properties can be measured without changing it: colour, density, melting point, hardness, how well it conducts. Its chemical properties describe what it does with other substances: iron rusts, petrol burns, gold ignores air. Melting ghee, bending a spoon and dissolving salt are physical changes, and the starting material comes back by cooling, straightening or evaporating. Turning milk into dahi, rusting, frying an egg and burning wood are chemical changes. New substances with new properties appear, and cooling will not undo them.

Clues help but do not decide. Bubbles, a colour change, heat or light and a new smell hint at a chemical change, yet boiling water makes bubbles and is not one. The firm test is identity: is there now a substance with different properties?

Chemistry sits between physics and biology. Why gold is yellow and soft is a question about how its atoms hold their electrons, and a working cell is thousands of reactions run in order.

Data Sorting everyday changes by one test: is the substance the same afterwards?
ChangeSame substance after?KindEvidence
Ghee melting in a warm kitchenYesPhysicalSets again on cooling
Camphor shrinking in an open dishYesPhysicalSame smell, found in the air
Camphor burningNoChemicalSoot, flame, new gases
Milk setting into dahiNoChemicalSour taste, new acid, cannot be reversed
Iron nail left in damp airNoChemicalBrown flakes that are not iron
Salt stirred into waterYesPhysicalSalt returns on evaporation
Water boiling in a panYesPhysicalVapour condenses to the same water
Silver spoon tarnishingNoChemicalDark film of a new compound

A change can be physical for one substance and chemical for another in the same pot: boiling dal separates water as vapour (physical) while the starch and protein change (chemical).

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Investigating Matter'

1.2 Lavoisier and Dalton showed that matter keeps its mass and combines in fixed ratios, which means it is made of atoms

Until the 1770s, burning was thought to release a substance called phlogiston from the burning body. Antoine Lavoisier asked a plain question: what do the scales say? He heated metals in sealed vessels and weighed everything before and after. The metal gained weight, and the air in the vessel lost exactly that much. Burning was a combination with a part of the air, which he named oxygen. In 1789 he set down the principle that the total mass of the substances before a reaction equals that after. He also gave 'element' its working meaning: a substance that no known method could split into simpler ones.

Around 1800, Joseph Proust showed that a given compound has the same mass proportions however it is made or wherever it is found. Then John Dalton, working between 1803 and 1808, supplied the explanation. Each element is made of atoms that all have the same mass, and a compound is a fixed grouping of such atoms. Fixed groupings give fixed mass ratios. Dalton also predicted a new pattern: if two elements form more than one compound, the masses of one that combine with a fixed mass of the other should be in small whole-number ratios. Measurement agreed.

His atoms were right and some of his formulas were wrong. He assumed the simplest grouping and wrote water as HO, so his atomic masses were off.

Data Worked estimate: mass in, mass out for 10 g of paraffin wax, and the whole-number rule (calculated)
StepWorkingResult
ReactionC25H52 + 38 O2 gives 25 CO2 + 26 H2OAtoms of each kind balance
Molar mass of wax25 x 12.011 + 52 x 1.008352.7 g per mole
Oxygen needed for 10 g10 g x (38 x 32.00) / 352.734.5 g
Carbon dioxide formed10 g x (25 x 44.01) / 352.731.2 g
Water formed10 g x (26 x 18.015) / 352.713.3 g
Mass check10 + 34.5 = 44.5; 31.2 + 13.3 = 44.5Equal: mass is conserved
Oxygen per 1 g of hydrogen in water and in hydrogen peroxide8 g in H2O; 16 g in H2O2Ratio 1: 2
Oxygen per 12 g of carbon in carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide16 g in CO; 32 g in CO2Ratio 1: 2

The 1: 2 ratios are Dalton's multiple proportions: two different compounds of the same elements differ by whole atoms, not by fractions.

Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Atom: the beginnings of modern atomic theory, https://www.britannica.com/science/atom/The-beginnings-of-modern-atomic-theory (Dalton turned atomic philosophy into a scientific theory between 1803 and 1808; his 1808 book was the first application of atomic theory to chemistry; atoms of an element have the same fixed mass; he wrote water as HO; law of multiple proportions, carbon dioxide has twice the oxygen of carbon monoxide for the same carbon); Purdue University, Chemistry Education, Antoine Lavoisier, https://chemed.chem.purdue.edu/genchem/history/lavoisier.html (Lavoisier found that mass is conserved in a chemical reaction; atoms are neither created nor destroyed; water roughly 85 per cent oxygen and 15 per cent hydrogen by weight)

1.3 A formula counts the atoms in a compound, and a name built by rule tells you what is in it

Only about ninety elements occur naturally on Earth, yet there are tens of millions of known compounds. Atoms join in different ratios and arrangements, as a few dozen letters make every word. A compound is a substance whose atoms are of two or more elements joined in a fixed ratio. Its properties are not an average of its parts. Mercury is a silvery liquid and sulphur a yellow powder, yet together they make cinnabar, the red mineral once ground for vermilion.

A chemical formula records the count. H2O has two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom. A bracket and a subscript multiply what is inside: Ca(HCO3)2 has one calcium, two hydrogen, two carbon and six oxygen atoms. The word molecule means a group of atoms bonded together as a unit. O2 is a molecule of an element, and H2O a molecule of a compound. Salt is different: it is a block of alternating sodium and chloride ions with no separate NaCl molecules, and its formula gives only the ratio 1: 1. Part 3 shows how X-rays revealed this.

The naming rules of IUPAC, the international body for chemical terms, make a name readable as a recipe. Name the metal first, then the non-metal with the ending changed to '-ide'. Oxygen-rich groups take '-ate'. A metal that forms more than one ion gets its charge in Roman numerals. For molecules, number prefixes count the atoms.

Data Reading formulas and names
Household nameFormulaSystematic nameAtoms in one formula unit
Table saltNaClsodium chloride2
Washing sodaNa2CO3sodium carbonate6
Baking sodaNaHCO3sodium hydrogencarbonate6
Slaked limeCa(OH)2calcium hydroxide5
Chalk, limestoneCaCO3calcium carbonate5
Rust (one form)Fe2O3iron(III) oxide5
Gas from burningCO2carbon dioxide3
Hard-water mineralCa(HCO3)2calcium hydrogencarbonate11

'Iron(III)' means iron with three positive charges per ion. The related FeO is iron(II) oxide, a different substance with different properties.

  • Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Investigating Matter'

1.4 A mixture keeps the properties of its parts, so every separation method exploits one property in which the parts differ

Almost nothing we handle is a single substance. Air, sea water, concrete, brass, milk and field soil are all mixtures: two or more substances together, each keeping its own identity. A mixture whose parts are spread evenly, so that every spoonful is alike, is homogeneous, and it is called a solution if the parts are separate molecules or ions. Sea water and brass are of this kind. A mixture with visible or patchy parts, like concrete or muddy water, is heterogeneous. Milk, fog and blood sit between: their particles are too small to settle quickly but big enough to scatter light, which is why a headlight beam shows in fog. These are colloids and suspensions.

To separate a mixture, find a property in which the parts differ, then use it. Grain from husk differs in weight, so the farmer winnows it in the wind. Wheat flour from bran differs in particle size, so it goes through a sieve. Iron from sand differs in magnetism. A gold-panner uses density: swirl, and the heavy grains stay. Dissolved salt differs from water in how easily each leaves a liquid, so heating separates them. The method for liquids with different boiling points is distillation, and for chemicals that cling differently to a surface it is chromatography. Mikhail Tsvet used it in the early 1900s to split plant pigments into coloured bands. The engineering module Matter at the atomic scale: bonds, reactions and process engineering shows these as industrial steps. Understanding Chemicals covers salt and soda ash in Heavy inorganics: salt, sulphur, nitrogen and phosphorus.

The salt pans of Gujarat show one method at work on a huge scale. India made about 300 lakh tonnes of salt in 2019-20, over 81 per cent of it in Gujarat, mostly by letting the Sun evaporate sea water.

Data Separation methods and the property each one uses
MethodProperty that differsEveryday case
Sieving, filteringParticle sizeAtta through a chalni, tea through a strainer
Winnowing, settlingWeight or densityGrain from chaff; mud from pond water
CentrifugeDensity, sped upCream from milk
MagnetMagnetismIron filings from sand
Evaporation, crystallisationHow readily a part leaves the liquidSalt from sea water
DistillationBoiling pointDrinking water from brackish water; spirits
ChromatographyStickiness to a surface versus ease of dissolvingInk spots spreading on blotting paper

See it in the table

H₂O WaterAu GoldHg MercuryNaCl SaltSda Soda ashWh WheatSu SugarTea TeaH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenCO2 Carbon dioxide

Check your understanding

A student heats a clear colourless liquid and collects drops of the same liquid on a cold plate. Which statement is best supported?

The collected drops are the original substance, so only its phase changed. Bubbles and vanishing from view are clues, not proof.

In a sealed jar, 5.0 g of iron wool rusts and the jar plus contents gains no weight and loses none. The iron oxide formed weighs 7.2 g. How much oxygen from the jar joined the iron?

Mass is conserved in a closed system, so 7.2 g minus 5.0 g of iron leaves 2.2 g of oxygen.

A compound is analysed from two sources, a mine and a laboratory, and the mass ratio of its elements is the same. What does this support?

Fixed mass ratios were Proust's observation and Dalton explained them: atoms join in fixed numbers, so fixed masses follow.
← Module contentsMark read · Part 2: Phases of matter, phase changes and density →