Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions: Phases of matter, phase changes and density
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 10: Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions Part 2 of 6Phases of matter, phase changes and density
Ice, water and steam are one substance in three costumes. This part asks what the particles do in each phase, why a phase change takes energy without warming, why water boils at 88 degrees C in Leh and 120 degrees C in a pressure cooker, and what sets density.
2.1 In a solid, liquid or gas the particles are the same and only their freedom differs, and the gap between them is the whole story
Pour water from a glass into a bowl and it changes shape and keeps its volume. Pour air from a balloon and it fills the room. A brick does neither. These three behaviours, the solid, the liquid and the gas, come from how much freedom the particles have.
In a solid, each particle sits in a fixed place and only vibrates. The place may be part of a regular crystal, as in salt and metals, or a random jumble, as in glass, but the neighbours stay neighbours, so the shape stays. In a liquid, particles are still touching but can slide past one another, so the liquid flows to fit its container and hardly compresses. In a gas, particles are far apart and fly freely, colliding rarely, so a gas fills any space and squeezes easily. There is a fourth phase, plasma, a gas hot enough that atoms lose electrons, as in lightning and the Sun. See Gas laws for how pressure follows from the motion. Random collisions also make particles wander: a drop of food colouring spreads through a still glass of water over hours with no stirring. This drift from crowded to less crowded regions is diffusion, the same jostling seen as Brownian motion in the atoms and periodic table module.
The table puts numbers on the gap. Liquid water has each molecule occupying a box about 0.31 nanometres on a side, almost touching its neighbours. In air at room conditions the box is about 3.4 nanometres, so a gas is mostly empty space, and that is why a given amount of water vapour takes about 1,350 times the volume of the liquid.
The same ruler measures a whole field. Nanotechnology works at sizes of 1 to 100 nanometres, where a particle has so few atoms that a large share of them sit on its surface.
| Quantity | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Volume of one water molecule's box in liquid | 18.0 g per mole / (1.00 g per cm3 x 6.022 x 10^23 per mole) | 3.0 x 10^-23 cm3 |
| Side of that box | cube root of 3.0 x 10^-29 m3 | 0.31 nm |
| Volume per molecule in a gas at 25 C, 1 atm | 24.5 L per mole / 6.022 x 10^23 | 4.1 x 10^-26 m3 |
| Side of that box | cube root of 4.1 x 10^-26 m3 | 3.4 nm, about 11 molecule widths |
| Volume ratio, gas to liquid water | 24,450 cm3 / 18.1 cm3 | about 1,350 times |
| Gold cube 10 nm wide: atoms along an edge | 10 nm / 0.288 nm | 35 |
| Atoms on the surface | 1 - (33 / 35)^3 = 1 - 0.838 | 16 per cent, nearly 1 in 6 |
The gas figure treats the vapour as an ideal gas at 1 atmosphere. Real air has a molar volume within about one per cent of 24.5 L. Values: water 1.00 g per cm3 and the ideal-gas molar volume at 25 C.
Source: Royal Society of Chemistry, Periodic table, Osmium, https://periodic-table.rsc.org/element/76/osmium (density 22.5872 g per cubic centimetre)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Investigating Matter'
- Feynman, Leighton and Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. I (Caltech) · further reading only: https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_01.html, chapter 1 'Atoms in Motion', and chapter 12 'Characteristics of Force'
2.2 Changing phase moves energy into or out of the attractions between molecules, so the temperature stays still while it happens
Heat a pan of ice on a stove and the thermometer sticks at 0 degrees C until the last ice is gone. Then it climbs to 100 degrees C and sticks again until the pan is dry. The energy is not wasted. It is spent pulling molecules apart from the neighbours that attract them, which raises their potential energy but not their average motion, and temperature measures the motion. The energy comes back as heat when vapour condenses or water freezes. The Latent heat node holds the same idea.
For water, melting a kilogram of ice takes about 334 kJ, and boiling a kilogram away takes about 2,257 kJ, nearly seven times as much, because turning a liquid to vapour pulls molecules entirely out of contact, while melting only loosens them. Per molecule, boiling costs about 6.8 x 10^-20 J. The typical thermal energy of a molecule at 100 degrees C is only about 5 x 10^-21 J, a thirteenth of that, so only a rare, fast molecule can escape. That is evaporation: a quiet leak from the surface at any temperature, which carries off the fastest molecules and so cools what is left. Boiling is different. It starts when the liquid's vapour pressure reaches the pressure of the air above, so bubbles of vapour can form inside. Raise the outside pressure and the boiling point rises. See Vapour-liquid equilibrium (Raoult's law).
Some solids skip the liquid: camphor and dry ice sublimate straight to vapour, and iodine vapour deposits crystals on a cold glass.
| Question | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Cooling in an earthen pot: 10 kg of water at 35 C seeps through the clay and 100 g evaporates. Energy taken, with 2.42 MJ per kg at 35 C | 0.1 kg x 2.42 MJ per kg | 242 kJ |
| Temperature fall if all that energy is taken from the water | 242 kJ / (10 kg x 4.18 kJ per kg K) | 5.8 K, so about 29 C |
| Boiling point at Leh, about 3,500 m, pressure about 65 kPa | ln(65 / 101.3) = - 0.444; 1/T = 1/373.2 + 0.444 / (40,650 / 8.314) | T = 361 K, about 88 C |
| Boiling point in a cooker at about 2 atmospheres absolute (200 kPa) | ln(200 / 101.3) = 0.680; 1/T = 1/373.2 - 0.680 / 4,889 | T = 394 K, about 120 C |
| Heat ratio, boiling to melting, 1 kg of water | 2,257 kJ / 334 kJ | about 6.8 |
The matka answer is a ceiling, because the pot also gains heat from the air, so a fall of a few kelvin is what is seen. The boiling points use the Clausius-Clapeyron relation with 40.65 kJ per mole.
Source: NIST Chemistry WebBook, Water (enthalpy of vaporisation at the normal boiling point about 40.65 kJ/mol), https://webbook.nist.gov/cgi/cbook.cgi?ID=C7732185 (standard value, quoted as 40.65 kJ/mol, about 2,257 kJ/kg)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Investigating Matter'
- NIST Chemistry WebBook, Water (enthalpy of vaporisation at the normal boiling point about 40.65 kJ/mol) · web
2.3 Density is mass per volume, and it rises with heavier atoms and tighter packing, which decides what floats
A kilogram of cotton and a kilogram of iron weigh the same and differ hugely in size. Density, mass divided by volume, says how much matter is packed into each cubic metre. It is a physical property, and so it helps to identify a substance and to sort a mixture.
Two things set it. One is how heavy the atoms are: a gold atom is about 197 atomic mass units and an aluminium atom is 27. The other is how closely the atoms are packed: a gas has its particles about eleven widths apart, a liquid or solid has them touching. That is why a gas is roughly a thousand times less dense than the same substance as a liquid. Most solids are slightly denser than their liquids because particles pack better when they hold their places. Water is the great exception. Ice is about 8 per cent less dense than liquid water because hydrogen bonds hold its molecules in an open pattern (part 5). Ice floats, with about 92 per cent below the surface in fresh water and about 90 per cent in sea water.
What floats follows from density alone. Archimedes' principle says that a body sinks until the weight of water it pushes aside equals its own weight, so anything less dense than water floats. A steel ship floats because its hollow shape makes its average density low. See Buoyancy (Archimedes' principle).
| Material | Density (kg per m3) | What explains it |
|---|---|---|
| Osmium | 22,590 | Heavy atoms, tightly packed metal |
| Gold | 19,300 | Heavy atoms, close packing |
| Mercury (liquid) | 13,530 | Heavy atoms, still touching |
| Iron | 7,870 | Mid-weight atoms, close packing |
| Aluminium | 2,700 | Light atoms, close packing |
| Water at 25 C | 997 | Light molecules, touching |
| Ice | 917 | Open hydrogen-bonded pattern |
| Petrol | about 740 | Carbon chains, loosely attracting |
| Air at 25 C | 1.18 | Mostly empty space |
| Hydrogen gas at 25 C | 0.082 | Lightest atoms, mostly empty space |
- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 11, 'Investigating Matter'
- Royal Society of Chemistry, Periodic table, Osmium · web
See it in the table
H₂O WaterAl AluminiumSt SteelAu GoldNaCl SaltI IodineCt CottonH2 HydrogenEl ElectricityCheck your understanding
Why does the temperature of boiling water stay at 100 degrees C although a stove keeps adding heat?
Temperature measures the average motion energy. During boiling, the energy goes to the potential energy of separation, which is the latent heat.On a mountain pass the air pressure is lower. What happens to the boiling point of water there and why?
A liquid boils when its vapour pressure equals the pressure above it. Less outside pressure means that happens at a lower temperature.A block of an unknown metal has mass 270 g and volume 100 cm3. Using the table, what is it most likely to be?
270 g in 100 cm3 is 2.7 g per cm3, the density of aluminium.