Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions: Solutions: dissolving, concentration, soap and hard water
All courses / Understanding Science / Module 10: Matter and bonding: phases, elements, compounds, solutions Part 6 of 6Solutions: dissolving, concentration, soap and hard water
A solution is the most intimate kind of mixture. This part explains why salt and sugar vanish in water but oil does not, how to state and limit how much dissolves, how soap works, and why borewell water scales a kettle and scums a bucket.
6.1 A substance dissolves when its attraction to the solvent can pay for the attractions it gives up, so like dissolves like and oil and water stay apart
In a solution the dissolved substance is the solute and the liquid it is spread through is the solvent. Stir salt into water and the crystal disappears. Each water molecule has a negative oxygen end and a positive hydrogen end. Around a sodium ion the oxygen ends crowd in, and around a chloride ion the hydrogen ends do. This ion-dipole attraction is strong enough to pull ions out of the crystal one by one. Each ion ends up wrapped in a shell of water, and is said to be hydrated. Sugar dissolves for a different reason: its many O-H groups form hydrogen bonds with water, so water can replace the sugar molecules' bonds to each other.
For salt, the lattice costs 787 kJ per mole to pull apart and hydration pays back about 783. The sums nearly balance. The small shortfall is drawn from the water's heat, and the gain in disorder as ions spread out tips the balance towards dissolving.
Now add cooking oil. Its molecules are long chains of carbon and hydrogen with no charge to offer. Letting one in costs water some of its hydrogen bonding and gains it almost nothing, so the oil gathers into drops that rise and float. Oil mixes freely with petrol, since both rely on dispersion forces. The rule 'like dissolves like' is short for this: polar and ionic solutes go with polar solvents, and nonpolar with nonpolar.
| Solute in solvent | What the solute offers | What the solvent offers | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Table salt in water | Ions | Polar molecules, ion-dipole pull | Dissolves well |
| Sugar in water | O-H groups, hydrogen bonding | Hydrogen bonding | Dissolves well |
| Cooking oil in water | Dispersion only | Strong hydrogen bonding to itself | Does not mix |
| Cooking oil in petrol | Dispersion | Dispersion | Mixes |
| Iodine in water | Dispersion only | Strong hydrogen bonding to itself | Very little dissolves |
| Iodine in ethanol | Dispersion | Dispersion and some polarity | Dissolves |
Salt energy account: lattice 787 kJ per mole to break up, hydration about 783 kJ per mole returned, net about + 4 kJ per mole, so a salt solution changes temperature only a little.
Source: Purdue University, Chemistry Education, Lattice energy, https://chemed.chem.purdue.edu/genchem/topicreview/bp/ch7/lattice.php (lattice energy of NaCl 787.3 kJ/mol; Mg2+ with O2- 3791 kJ/mol; the bond is stronger for larger charges and smaller ions)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Chemical Bonds and Mixtures'
- Purdue University, Chemistry Education, Lattice energy · web
6.2 Concentration says how much solute is in a given amount of solution, in mass percent, parts per million or moles per litre
Two cups of tea can both contain sugar and taste quite different, so we need a number for how much. Concentration is the amount of solute divided by the amount of solution, and chemists use several versions.
Mass per volume says how many grams are in a litre. Mass percent says how many grams in each hundred grams of solution. For very dilute solutions such as drinking water, parts per million is handy: one part in a million, which in water is the same as 1 milligram per litre. One part per million is like a single drop in about 50 litres. For chemistry, the most useful measure is molarity, moles of solute per litre, because it counts particles and so lets us compare equal numbers of molecules.
The Indian standard, IS 10500, accepts up to 500 mg per litre of dissolved solids in drinking water, or 2,000 where no other source exists. Sea water has about 35,000 mg per litre. Concentration decides what happens across a membrane: water moves towards the more concentrated side, the effect called osmosis. Pushing the other way with pressure is reverse osmosis, the principle of home purifiers. See Osmosis.
| Question | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Sweet tea: 10 g of sugar (342 g per mole) in 150 mL | 10 g / 342 g per mole = 0.0292 mol; / 0.150 L | 0.195 mol per litre, 6.7 g per 100 mL |
| One part per million in water | 1 mg in 1 L of 1,000,000 mg | 1 ppm = 1 mg per litre; about one drop in 50 L |
| Sea water at 35 g of salts per kg, mostly NaCl | about 27 g NaCl / 58.44 g per mole in 1 kg | about 0.46 mol of NaCl per kilogram |
| Dilute 5 L of 20 g per litre stock to 2 g per litre | 20 x V1 = 2 x 5 L, so V1 = 0.5 L | 0.5 L of stock, plus 4.5 L of water |
| BIS limit for dissolved solids, 500 mg per litre, as a percentage | 0.5 g / 1,000 g | 0.05 per cent |
The molarity figures treat one litre of solution as close to one kilogram of water, which is accurate to a few per cent at these dilutions.
Source: Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 10500:2012 Drinking water: specification (second revision), as hosted by the National Consumer Helpline, https://consumerhelpline.gov.in/public/assets/docs/bis/IS10500-2012.pdf (total hardness as CaCO3: acceptable limit 200 mg/l, permissible in the absence of an alternate source 600 mg/l; total dissolved solids 500 and 2,000 mg/l)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Chemical Bonds and Mixtures'
- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 10500:2012 Drinking water: specification (second revision), as hosted by the National Consumer Helpline · web
6.3 Solubility has a ceiling at each temperature, solids usually dissolve better when hot, and gases dissolve worse
A cook making brine for pickles finds that past about 36 g of salt per 100 g of water the grains lie on the bottom however long the pot is stirred. The brine is saturated: at that temperature, ions leave the crystals and rejoin them at the same rate. The solubility is the mass that will dissolve in a given amount of solvent. Salt's barely changes with heat, reaching only 39 g at 100 degrees C. Sugar is far more soluble, about 204 g at 20 degrees C, and potassium nitrate leaps from about 32 g to 169 g between 20 and 80 degrees C.
Solids usually dissolve better when hot, because heat helps break the crystal. A saturated hot solution then deposits crystals as it cools, which is how mishri is made, and why sugar mills grow their crystals from cooled or boiled-down syrup. If the solution cools without crystals forming it can hold more than the ceiling for a while. It is then supersaturated, and a single seed crystal sets it off.
Gases behave in the opposite way. A dissolved gas is a molecule that has dropped into the liquid, and warmth shakes it back out. Fresh water at 20 degrees C holds about 9 mg of oxygen per litre at air pressure, and at 30 degrees C only about 7.5. That is why a warm pond in summer can suffocate fish. Pressure pushes the other way: a sealed soda bottle holds CO2 at several atmospheres, and opening it drops the pressure, so the gas comes out as bubbles.
| Substance | At 20 C | At higher temperature | Crystals when cooled (per 100 g water) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sucrose (sugar) | 204 g | 487 g at 100 C | 487 - 204 = 283 g |
| Potassium nitrate | 32 g | 169 g at 80 C | 169 - 32 = 137 g |
| Sodium chloride | 36 g | 39 g at 100 C | 39 - 36 = 3 g |
| Oxygen, per litre of fresh water | about 9.1 mg | about 7.5 mg at 30 C | not crystals: the gas leaves the water on warming |
Oxygen solubility is quoted at air pressure. The USGS gives 8.97 mg per litre at 20 C and 750 mm of mercury.
Source: FAO, Fruit and vegetable processing, chapter 6, Auxiliary raw materials, https://www.fao.org/4/V5030e/V5030E0f.htm (a saturated solution needs 2,040 g of sucrose per litre of water at 20 C and 4,870 g at 100 C); Chemister.ru database of inorganic compounds, Potassium nitrate, https://chemister.ru/Databases/Chemdatabase/properties-en.php?id=513 (solubility in water, g per 100 g: 31.6 at 20 C, 110.1 at 60 C, 168.8 at 80 C); U.S. Geological Survey, Techniques and Methods 9-A6.2, Dissolved oxygen, https://pubs.usgs.gov/tm/09/a6.2/tm9a6.2.pdf (freshwater oxygen solubility 8.97 mg/L at 20.0 C and 750 mm of mercury)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Chemical Bonds and Mixtures'
- U.S. Geological Survey, Techniques and Methods 9-A6.2, Dissolved oxygen · web
- FAO, Fruit and vegetable processing, chapter 6, Auxiliary raw materials · web
- Chemister.ru database of inorganic compounds, Potassium nitrate · web
6.4 Soap bridges oil and water with a charged head and a greasy tail, and calcium and magnesium in hard water throw it out of use
Soap is made by boiling fat with caustic soda, which splits the fat into glycerol and the sodium salts of long fatty acids. Each soap molecule, such as sodium stearate, has two parts: a tail of 17 carbons that is nonpolar and dissolves in grease, and a head carrying a negative charge that is happy in water. In water, the tails hide from the water by clustering together and the heads face out, forming a ball called a micelle. Add greasy cloth and the tails dissolve in the grease while the heads face outward, so the grease is carried away in the rinse as tiny droplets in a stable mixture.
Hard water spoils this. Hardness is simply the dissolved calcium and magnesium. As rain trickles through soil it picks up carbon dioxide and becomes slightly acid, then dissolves limestone to make calcium hydrogencarbonate. Calcium ions meet the soap's heads and make an insoluble solid, the grey scum on a bathroom wall. Synthetic detergents have heads that do not precipitate, so they work in hard water.
Boiling the water drives out CO2, and calcium carbonate then forms as the white scale in kettles and on heating coils. That is temporary hardness. Sulphates and chlorides stay dissolved, which is permanent hardness. The Indian standard sets total hardness at 200 mg per litre as calcium carbonate as acceptable, and 600 as the limit where no better source exists. The US Geological Survey calls anything over 180 'very hard', so the acceptable Indian limit is already in that band.
| Question | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Hardness of 300 mg per litre as CaCO3 in moles | 300 mg / 100.1 mg per mmol | 3.0 mmol of Ca per litre |
| Calcium in a 20 L bucket | 20 L x 3.0 mmol per litre | 60 mmol |
| Soap lost, since 2 soap ions bind each Ca2+ (sodium stearate 306.5 g per mole) | 60 mmol x 2 x 306.5 mg per mmol | 36.8 g, over a third of a 100 g bar |
| Washing soda to remove it (sodium carbonate, 106 g per mole; one carbonate per calcium) | 60 mmol x 106 mg per mmol | 6.4 g |
| Scale from a kettle that boils 2 L a day, if all hardness precipitated | 2 L x 0.3 g per litre x 365 days | at most 219 g of CaCO3 a year, about 80 cm3 |
Only temporary hardness forms kettle scale, so the true figure is lower, often by half or more. The soap figure assumes all the soap is used up in precipitation before any cleaning begins.
Source: U.S. Geological Survey, Water Science School, Water hardness, https://www.usgs.gov/water-science-school/science/hardness-water (hardness is dissolved calcium and magnesium; soft 0 to 60, moderately hard 61 to 120, hard 121 to 180, very hard over 180 mg/L as calcium carbonate; soap scum; scale of calcium carbonate on heating); Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 10500:2012 Drinking water: specification (second revision), as hosted by the National Consumer Helpline, https://consumerhelpline.gov.in/public/assets/docs/bis/IS10500-2012.pdf (total hardness as CaCO3: acceptable limit 200 mg/l, permissible in the absence of an alternate source 600 mg/l; total dissolved solids 500 and 2,000 mg/l); Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation, Central Laboratory, IS 10500:2012 limits with supplied water quality, https://ahmedabadcity.gov.in/Images/_CORP_DEPT_CentralLaboratory_IS_10500_2012.pdf (permissible limits in the absence of an alternate source: total hardness 600, calcium 200, magnesium 100, total dissolved solids 2,000 mg/L); Central Ground Water Board, State Hydrochemical Report, Uttarakhand (AAP 2024-25), https://www.cgwb.gov.in/cgwbpnm/download/1721 (208 pre-monsoon samples, May 2023; one sample, Iqbalpur in Haridwar, exceeded total hardness 600 mg/L at 650 mg/L); Encyclopaedia Britannica, Soap and detergent, https://www.britannica.com/science/soap (a cleaning molecule has a water-insoluble part that attaches to soil and a water-soluble group that attaches to water; hot caustic soda acting on fats gives soap and glycerin; soap forms a scum in hard water; synthetic detergents are much less affected)- Hewitt, Lyons, Suchocki and Yeh, Conceptual Integrated Science, 2nd edition (Pearson, 2013) · ch. 12, 'Chemical Bonds and Mixtures'
- U.S. Geological Survey, Water Science School, Water hardness · web
- Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation, Central Laboratory, IS 10500:2012 limits with supplied water quality · web
- Central Ground Water Board, State Hydrochemical Report, Uttarakhand (AAP 2024-25) · web
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Soap and detergent · web
- Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 10500:2012 Drinking water: specification (second revision), as hosted by the National Consumer Helpline · web
See it in the table
H₂O WaterMg MagnesiumNaCl SaltSu SugarTea TeaNaOH Caustic sodaH2 HydrogenO2 OxygenCO2 Carbon dioxideFA Fatty acidsCheck your understanding
Which pairing is most likely to give a solution?
Salt is ionic and water is polar, so the ion-dipole attraction pays for pulling the crystal apart. Oil, wax and petrol are nonpolar and have nothing comparable to offer.A solution of 90 g of glucose (180 g per mole) in 2.0 L of water has what molarity, taking the volume as 2.0 L?
90 g is 0.50 mol, and 0.50 mol in 2.0 L gives 0.25 mol per litre.Why does soap make a scum in hard water?
The negatively charged soap heads combine with Ca2+ or Mg2+ to form calcium or magnesium soaps, which do not dissolve.